Final fish recs for my 40G reef tank.

  • Thread starter Thread starter Coxey81
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users None

Coxey81

Well-Known Member
View Badges
Joined
Aug 25, 2021
Messages
868
Reaction score
1,561
Location
Huntsville
What state or country do you live in
Alabama
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
So, I have a 40G Breeder (20g sump) I bought used and came with livestock and I'm trying to decide on what fish to add to the current residents.

Current:

Yellowtail Blue Damsel
Six-Line Wrasse
Scopus Tang

In QT awaiting addition:

Diamond Goby

Adding after Goby: Pair of Clowns

I know the tang is going to get too big for the tank, so I plan to rehome her this year at some point.

What are some good options to add after the clowns?

I would like a colorful swimmer that doesn't hide too much and is reef safe.

I've looked at...

Royal gramma and other basslets (hear they hide alot)

Neon Dottyback or other dottyback (aggressive, but considering for last addition)

Firefish (not really big swimmers, but gorgeous)

Coral beauty (tank is a little small and possibly a coral nibbler)

Banggai cardinalfish (not as colorful as I'm hoping for, but a big swimmer)

I know nothing is perfect, but is there anything I'm missing that would really fit what I'm looking for?

Thanks for any help
 
Midas Blenny is fun to watch with the way he swims and backs into his home. Longnose hawkfish isn’t much of a swimmer but mine would perch in the front of the tank.
 

Attachments

  • B3376AA8-AD53-4A94-BB0E-7BCB3D962F7A.jpeg
    B3376AA8-AD53-4A94-BB0E-7BCB3D962F7A.jpeg
    216.3 KB · Views: 44
  • 0BD8EEFB-07A1-42C7-BC23-2B76373C6B25.jpeg
    0BD8EEFB-07A1-42C7-BC23-2B76373C6B25.jpeg
    205.3 KB · Views: 55
  • 199EACD3-ECEB-4E3F-A955-C6E57414001A.jpeg
    199EACD3-ECEB-4E3F-A955-C6E57414001A.jpeg
    128.2 KB · Views: 47
So, I have a 40G Breeder (20g sump) I bought used and came with livestock and I'm trying to decide on what fish to add to the current residents.

Current:

Yellowtail Blue Damsel
Six-Line Wrasse
Scopus Tang

In QT awaiting addition:

Diamond Goby

Adding after Goby: Pair of Clowns

I know the tang is going to get too big for the tank, so I plan to rehome her this year at some point.

What are some good options to add after the clowns?

I would like a colorful swimmer that doesn't hide too much and is reef safe.

I've looked at...

Royal gramma and other basslets (hear they hide alot)

Neon Dottyback or other dottyback (aggressive, but considering for last addition)

Firefish (not really big swimmers, but gorgeous)

Coral beauty (tank is a little small and possibly a coral nibbler)

Banggai cardinalfish (not as colorful as I'm hoping for, but a big swimmer)

I know nothing is perfect, but is there anything I'm missing that would really fit what I'm looking for?

Thanks for any help
Multicolor angel or a cherub
 
I don't have a midas blenny but went to a local club meeting last week where the host had one and I'm about ready to tear out and rock and redo it to have better habitat for one, lol. Banggai aren't colorful like you said but they're honestly pretty fascinating to watch. I highly recommend them. I had a royal gramma but mine hid constantly. It died out of the blue one day, sadly. I likely won't get another unless I get a bigger tank in the future.

I ultimately got rid of my diamond goby recently, but had a full grown on for a while and it was probably my most active swimmer honestly. He was all over the place. Make sure you have a tight fitting lid though, they're jumpers!
 
I don't have a midas blenny but went to a local club meeting last week where the host had one and I'm about ready to tear out and rock and redo it to have better habitat for one, lol. Banggai aren't colorful like you said but they're honestly pretty fascinating to watch. I highly recommend them. I had a royal gramma but mine hid constantly. It died out of the blue one day, sadly. I likely won't get another unless I get a bigger tank in the future.

I ultimately got rid of my diamond goby recently, but had a full grown on for a while and it was probably my most active swimmer honestly. He was all over the place. Make sure you have a tight fitting lid though, they're jumpers!


Thanks, I have a canopy and recently added plastic mesh around the edges for jumpers.

20220130_160131.jpg 20220130_160136.jpg 20220130_160138.jpg
 
Purple fire fish
 

Attachments

  • 20211125_144003.jpg
    20211125_144003.jpg
    203.4 KB · Views: 37
I don’t recommend anything with an established scopas tang… that’s a killing spree waiting to happen.


We will see, if so I'll move my goby back to QT and find the tang a new home. Going to have to eventually anyway.

I tried the mirror method out on all my current fish and they ran and hid from themselves, lol. Tang included.
 
Do they swim around alot or just stick to the rocks/certain areas?
They swim around a little but tend to stay close to their cave. Beautiful peaceful fish. Gets along fine with my wrasses, dottyback and blennies.
 
So, I have a 40G Breeder (20g sump) I bought used and came with livestock and I'm trying to decide on what fish to add to the current residents.

Current:

Yellowtail Blue Damsel
Six-Line Wrasse
Scopus Tang

In QT awaiting addition:

Diamond Goby

Adding after Goby: Pair of Clowns

I know the tang is going to get too big for the tank, so I plan to rehome her this year at some point.

What are some good options to add after the clowns?

I would like a colorful swimmer that doesn't hide too much and is reef safe.

I've looked at...

Royal gramma and other basslets (hear they hide alot)

Neon Dottyback or other dottyback (aggressive, but considering for last addition)

Firefish (not really big swimmers, but gorgeous)

Coral beauty (tank is a little small and possibly a coral nibbler)

Banggai cardinalfish (not as colorful as I'm hoping for, but a big swimmer)

I know nothing is perfect, but is there anything I'm missing that would really fit what I'm looking for?

Thanks for any help
Just went back and realized I'm very late to this one, lol. But:

Personally, I'd rehome the scopas now and get a tomini tang on the small side... though you'd probably need to rehome it eventually because even the smallest tang will outgrow a 40 gal.

My suggestion would be:
1. Swap scopas for tomini
2. Add pair of clowns
3. Get a blenny - hands down the most entertaining fish, and some like the canary blenny are bright and all over the tank. Actually, I just got a Striped Fang Toothed Blenny. It's gorgeous, stands out, and very active but peaceful.
4. Skip most of the basslets and probably all dottybacks (even though dottybacks can be aggressive, I've never seen one not hiding amongst the rocks but I also have not had one personally so am no expert whatsoever lol). Is it mainly the purple/pink color you're looking to add? If so, the firefish could be an ok pick thought they do tend to be shy (make sure you have a tight fitting lid too - this also goes for the diamond goby, they're jumpers), or just go with the royal gramma. :)
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 30 44.8%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 13.4%
  • No.

    Votes: 25 37.3%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.5%
Back
Top