Fine aragamax live sand? Should be renamed Instagreen!

Reef.ductionist

Active Member
View Badges
Joined
Aug 11, 2013
Messages
326
Reaction score
5
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Well I had medium grain aragamax placed in my tank with live rock etc etc
No livestock and the process went very smoothly for me. No algae blooms... nada. Then I had this brilliant idea (not so brilliant after all). I went to the reef aquarium store and seeing a tank with super fine aragamax live sand in it was very impressed so bought a bag went home, switched the coarser sand with the finer sand waited and then had light green growing on everything. Now It would appear that given the flowowing:
A). My rock was still live rock covered in both bacteriums (oxygen and non~oxygen)
B). Skimmer was working well
C). One snail for bioload
D). Weekly water changes with RO/DI water
It would appear that this sand isn't as live as it claims.
If I'm not mistaken the coarser sand I had probably has a greater surface area
exposed and hence becomes live sand quicker----
The finer sand is more compact and captures and realeases nitrates faster if stirred at all.
Nuff said
How are my assumptions fellow reefers? Please enlighten me..
Cheers.
 
Hi
Before I changed the sand phosphates were undetectable and the nitrates were very near zero reading.
It was after I changed the sand my nitrates climbed phosphates still undetectable.
Perhaps something croaked via the sand bed change/but I am seriously doubting whether I should continue with this superfine aragamax livessand/my reasoning is the slightly coarser sand will be a better bacteria laiden substrate. I wanted to keep a bottom dwelling fish though to help filter and churn the sand, hence my quandary. The tank is only 14 gallon/maybe ten after rock etc so I am shooting for a few fish, as a result my guess is forget sps as they prefer next to zero nutrients and I'll settle on soft coral instead. But I don't want a sand that will be a nitrate vault. What's your opinion on the superfine?
 
Bacteria is actually the opposite of what mentioned. The courser the sand, the less surface area (hence bacteria) and also the courser sand allows for detritus to settle down in sand bed more easily. Honestly, don't think your sand bed (fine or course) is at fault. Likely a nutrient issue and could be due to too large of a bioload, excessive feeding, etc. With a 10 gallon water volume, things can go south quickly and think your thoughts on not keeping SPS is a good idea if your a novice aquarist. Good to keep softies, mushrooms, zoas and SPS at a later date when you have more xp or a larger tank volume to keep things stable.
 
Hi Dustin1300
Well ok, although the coarse sand verses the superfine seems a bit counter-intuitive Ill take your word for it.
The superfine keeping detritus out is somewhat believable considering it has a tighter packing in general. Where parameters are concerned I keep a vigilant eye on all of them...(I have completely automated everything and perform tests frequently on parameters not covered by my controller.
After counting my stock(four redlegged hermits and two astrea snails) I notice two hermits have flown ghe coop so to speak so that must be from whence the sudden nutrient spike came from. So...Im going to upgrade my skimmer to serve as a more effective means to nutralize these rare occurances and since Im installing a backdrop am going to clean everything , reinstall and get bigger skimmer.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 30 44.8%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 13.4%
  • No.

    Votes: 25 37.3%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.5%
Back
Top