Finicky hard to care for fish.

bamachamp92

WIL E. COYOTE SUPERGENIUS
View Badges
Joined
Jan 20, 2008
Messages
1,458
Reaction score
6
Location
Soddy Daisy, TN.
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
I would like to start a thread for people to look at before they decide to get a fish that is classified as hard to keep or hard to get to eat. So they can see what they may have to go through, or what to get to be prepared to care for certain fish. I think this could make it easier to be successful keeping certain fish. So if you have successfully gotten filefish, mandarins, or copperbands to eat, or if you know specific requirements people will need for hard to keep fish post them here.
 
I have a mandarin fish for like around 3 years, he is nice and fat, but he doesn't eat any prepared foods, i have about 150# of live rock thats been providing him some copepods.
 
Butterflies
Red Fin Butterfly - eats only sps coral polyps
Myeri Butterfly - eats only sps coral polyps
Ornate Butterfly - eats only sps coral polyps
Moorish Idol - difficult to sustain long term
Copperband Butterfly - difficult to entice to eat, once it's eating food that is offered, easy to care for

Angels
Rock Beauty Angel - sponge eater, does very poorly in captivity despite appearing to do well at first

Wrasses
Leopard Wrasse - difficult eater (lots of exceptions in our club of healthy leopard wrasses due to expert care)

Gobies
Catalina Goby - cold water fish from colder Pacific waters, needs to have a dedicated system with a chiller
 
Great thread! Let's fill it up!

I am going to have to say an Achilles Tang for sure.
 
Powder Brown Tangs, seem to ich out easier than anything.

Purple Tilefish. One of my all-time favorite fish to look at, but only at the store. If you do buy them make sure they have been there for some time, they are deep water fish and can have decompression issues. You can see that when they swim with their tales higher than their heads. They are also know to be jumpers. But WOW, what beautiful fish.
 
Angels
Rock Beauty Angel - sponge eater, does very poorly in captivity despite appearing to do well at first
Just so you know, Rock Beauty Angelfish have been know to be the most destructive angelfish in a reef. They also have an extremely poor survival rate as most collectors use quinaldine (a type of poison) to catch them. Pretty much 100% chance in it dieing if they used quinaldine. Not all have extremely poor survival rate, just the ones that were caught using quinaldine. If the angelfish was caught WITHOUT using quinaldine, it will be hardy like any other angelfish. Its a gorgeous angelfish nonetheless! :)
 
Some anthias would be great also, there are a few beautiful, almost impossible to keep species.
 
I have a breeding pair of Mandarins in a nanocube. 3 Mandarins in all. All "trained" to eat frozen foods and fatter than wild specimens. Well the spotted is in isolation for being a jerk.
 
Grunts and Sweetlips are something I would add to this list. Live foods have always been a must when trying to get them to eat, and sometimes that doesn't work. There's nothing worse then watching a fish starve to death in your tank. I avoid these guys now.
 
Dwarf seahorses as well concidering it is widely believed they eat only live foods. I have never owned one so I cannot attest to that.
 
Pinnatus batfish=this fish should be left in the wild very difficult to feed
ribbon eels=same with this one
 
Purple Tilefish. One of my all-time favorite fish to look at, but only at the store. If you do buy them make sure they have been there for some time, they are deep water fish and can have decompression issues. You can see that when they swim with their tales higher than their heads. They are also know to be jumpers. But WOW, what beautiful fish.

I got one a few months ago. I was a little worried at first, cause he wouldn't eat for the first few days and acted like he couldn't even see the food. I think the tank lights were too bright for him at first, cause he'd eat in the QT tank, but stopped once he was in the main tank. He'd get excited that there was food in the water, but would always miss it. Took him about a week to get used to the lights. After a while he ate anything I gave him (mysis, frozen formula 1 or 2, pellets, etc.).

Found out recently that he LOVES clams! I just got a CBB who doesn't want to eat (any help on that would be great), so I smashed some live clams to see if he'd peck at them. No luck with the CBB, but the tilefish will grab a hunk of meat and thrash around until it comes loose, then swim around the tank with it in his mouth. He bites off such big pieces, he can't swallow them. My pseudochromis usually steals it out from his mouth. I cut smaller pieces for the tilefish and he'll eat them out of my hand. And found out today he likes squid (another try at getting the CDD to eat, no luck).

I got the purple tilefish from bluezooaquatics and it was nice and fat when I got it which helped at lot.

Anyone know anymore tricks with CBB's? I had one a while back that would eat mysis just fine, but I sold him. This CBB won't touch mysis, brine, clam, squid, blood worms, aiptasia, and only sort of picks at feather dusters (I even went out and tracked down some small feather dusters for the little guy). I've also soaked all the food in garlic and selcon a few time, but that didn't seem to help either. Anything else I can try?!
 
I keep my Mandarin well fed. I seeded the tank with a bottle of live pods. He went through those pretty fast. I have gotten him to eat frozen prawn roe. I place a small chunk into a mason jar and angle it so he can climb in but the larger fish can't. He goes in and eats his fill.
 
my mandarin likes the frozen bloodworms and mysis, i usually just defrost some in a glass of tank water and spray in on the rock with a turkey baster. I have a CBB that takes mysis, blood worms, and clams on the half shell. the half shell clams are the only thing he would eat at first, so maybe try those.
 
Are blue spot jaw fish hard to care for ?
From my understanding they are all captured almost fully matured and have trouble adapting to the aquarium life.
 
Are blue spot jaw fish hard to care for ?
From my understanding they are all captured almost fully matured and have trouble adapting to the aquarium life.

I just picked up a Blue Spot Jawfish a couple of weeks ago and it's eating frozen mysis.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%
Back
Top