First scape(s) for first tank (RSR 350)

[wsoldier]

Brutally honest feedback welcome. This will be for mixed reef tank.

Option A seemed too plain.


I'm leaning towards Option B.


Other suggestions welcome. Thanks!

 

[gcarroll]

I prefer B as A seems too symmetrical. Maybe get rid either the first or third stand alone rock in the front.

 

[NY_Caveman]

Brutally honest feedback welcome. This will be for mixed reef tank.

Option A seemed too plain.


I'm leaning towards Option B.


Other suggestions welcome. Thanks!

I like B better too. That structure on the left is excellent and really grabs my attention the way it kind of weaves into itself. The small rock in front of it takes away from the structure I think.

The right structure is good and I like the central ball rock in front which balances it all. I would ditch the rock in the center front as well.

Normally I would say the right structure being larger should be taller, and I would recommend the other structure being about 2/3 the height. That left structure is so nice though I would not mess with it.

If it were me I would probably remove the rock on the top of the right structure and its left support. Then take the two rocks I said to pull from the front and use one or both of them on the right structure kind of like this rough image.

Again, just saying what I would do for my personal tastes.

 

[SPR1968]

Option B definitely and looks great as it seems to flow back into the sand more

 

[Katrina71]

+1 on B

 

[toti21]

Brutally honest feedback welcome. This will be for mixed reef tank.

Option A seemed too plain.


I'm leaning towards Option B.


Other suggestions welcome. Thanks!

option B. I have almost the same setup

 

[RMS18]

I vote B, will look nice covered in corals!

 

[Michael Llabona]

B for sure. Consider removing the small islands on the sand. It will open it up. Once you are ready you can put sand dwelling corals instead.