Fish dying.....any advice would help my stress level tremendously!!

SniffanyB

New Member
View Badges
Joined
Apr 23, 2020
Messages
24
Reaction score
8
What state or country do you live in
Georgia
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
My first fish to die was on Wednesday night, a Geo Pygmy Hawkfish. I noticed he wasn't acting himself so we took him out and put him in a temporary bucket with aerator overnight. (I didn't have a QT tank set up) which I now have. Then two days later I noticed my Royal Gramma had something on him. Wasn't Ick or Velvet that I could tell, but seemed to have scales standing out on his sides. I will attach pics of him, he also wasn't acting his self either. I didn't put him in the temp bucket because I was afraid that is what killed the Hawkfish and I was getting my QT tank set up. I woke up and he just wasn't anywhere to be found. That evening my hubby got home and helped me look better. We found most of him, the crabs and snails had found him during the night I suppose. Now my Canary Blenny is COVERED in what I think is velvet, I just FW dipped him and put I'm in QT tank, my Watchman Goby seems normal all except for the cloudy eyes, which the RG and Hawkfish both had just before they were found dead. Is he beyond helping? I have 5/6 dwarf blue legged hermit crabs 6-8 assortment of snails, live rock and a bunch of mixed corals. We didn't notice any heaving breathing with Hawkfish but did with RG. Blenny doesn't seem to be breathing other than normal along with what I can tell with my WM Goby. He watches from inside his cave a lot so it's hard to see him.

Water premiers:
pH-8.2
Nitrite-.1-.2
Nitrates- <.5
Ammonia -.1
KH- 12.6/4.5Meq/l
Ca- 360 (we added API CA and also eight.four
Mg-1520 (not sure why we have such a high reading, I did this test twice both resilts1520 & 1560)
Salinity- 1.025




Is Goby past help?
How is the best way treat tank and hopefully prevent a reinfestation?
Whats the best MV treatment for the Blenny in QT tank?
Also the pic of Goby is just yesterday afternoon he looked perfectly healthy.

21C52805-5A24-4390-8B45-5A67B334D432.jpeg F1CDF4A1-B755-4144-AEE8-AF3821605204.jpeg 1EBB6947-B236-43BF-A169-82A13EE0D8D5.jpeg 6920688F-9CDF-4C64-9A8D-2C186846BC4B.jpeg
 
Last edited:
Breathe...

How long has your tank been set up? Looks like you have some cycle values there. Nitrite is never a good sign in a reef tank.
Since you mentioned not having a qt, did your fish go directly into the dt from your supplier? How long have you had them? Did you use any type of dip or meds prior to adding them? How did you acclimate them?
 
We have had the tank up since April 19th and didn't add anything except I've rock until 5/6 weeks later. So the goby and hawkfish weve had for about 4 weeks. The RG and Blenny maybe two. No I'd didn't do any dipping or QT before adding them. Aren't the nitrites still within a safe range?
 
So, to clarify, you had the tank and equipment running since April 19th and then added live rock in late May? Where was the live rock from? It sound like maybe your cycle did not finish which would be strange if you added true live rock to the system.
No, nitrite and ammonia should never be detectable with our test in a fully cycled reef system. Nitrates, yes.
As far as the fish, it is hard to say without doing a necropsy and seeing if it was parasitic. I do not see obvious signs on the pictures of one thing to pinpoint. Diseased and sick, yes. Just not obvious to my eye on the pictures.

I would suggest you do some research on the cycling process to make sure it has fully happened and maybe some searches on qt for the future fish. I forgot to ask, what size is your tank?
 
i would treat the tank with “prime” it will detoxify the ammonia and help remove nitrite, which is causing stress on the fish and likely contributing to their death. You should never put fish in an uncycled aquarium. Also, please do more water changes, when in doubt, a large water change can do wonders. Not just one, do a few 50% water changes with RODI water over then next few days. Only add the Prime after a water change, if you get ur QT set up, you must do a cycle of the QT before you put things in it.. a completely separate cycle, you don’t want to cross contaminate your QT and DT
 
No live rock
So, to clarify, you had the tank and equipment running since April 19th and then added live rock in late May? Where was the live rock from? It sound like maybe your cycle did not finish which would be strange if you added true live rock to the system.
No, nitrite and ammonia should never be detectable with our test in a fully cycled reef system. Nitrates, yes.
As far as the fish, it is hard to say without doing a necropsy and seeing if it was parasitic. I do not see obvious signs on the pictures of one thing to pinpoint. Diseased and sick, yes. Just not obvious to my eye on the pictures.

I would suggest you do some research on the cycling process to make sure it has fully happened and maybe some searches on qt for the future fish. I forgot to ask, what size is your tank?
Everything was added at tank set up from LFS (everything we've gotten as come from this store) except a couple piece of live rock until 5/6 weeks later. We had the cycle finish watched all the numbers and waited for them to stabilize before adding fish and CUC. I'm so confused. The RG was the fish and a couple pieces of coral that I think started it. So now I'm not sure I want to buy fish from anywhere. I mean even QTing a fish isn't going to keep it from dying it will inky keep it from spreading to DT. I thought repute ble fish/reef stores helped in spreading this stuff before selling the fish!?? Is that Justin perfect world? God I'm stressed and sad as he'll.
 
I do w
i would treat the tank with “prime” it will detoxify the ammonia and help remove nitrite, which is causing stress on the fish and likely contributing to their death. You should never put fish in an uncycled aquarium. Also, please do more water changes, when in doubt, a large water change can do wonders. Not just one, do a few 50% water changes with RODI water over then next few days. Only add the Prime after a water change, if you get ur QT set up, you must do a cycle of the QT before you put things in it.. a completely separate cycle, you don’t want to cross contaminate your QT and DT
We do weekly water changes and the DT was cycled before adding the fish.
 
It's a 32
No live rock

Everything was added at tank set up from LFS (everything we've gotten as come from this store) except a couple piece of live rock until 5/6 weeks later. We had the cycle finish watched all the numbers and waited for them to stabilize before adding fish and CUC. I'm so confused. The RG was the fish and a couple pieces of coral that I think started it. So now I'm not sure I want to buy fish from anywhere. I mean even QTing a fish isn't going to keep it from dying it will inky keep it from spreading to DT. I thought repute ble fish/reef stores helped in spreading this stuff before selling the fish!?? Is that Justin perfect world? God I'm stressed and sad as he'll.
it is a 32.5 gallon Fluval Flex AIO with an added protein skimmer.
 
It's a 32

it is a 32.5 gallon Fluval Flex AIO with an added protein skimmer.
If you have nitrite and ammonia tank is not cycle. You need to add dr Tim’s all in one or bio spira to finish cycle off and knock down the Amonia and nitrite.
 
It's a 32

it is a 32.5 gallon Fluval Flex AIO with an added protein skimmer.
If fish have disease your going to have to set up qt tank and leave your other tank empty for a while. Treating your display tank with medication will kill all corals and inverts.
 
Why who is the cycle happening again? If set up on April 19th, did cycle waited Co ple weeks then added fish and CUC thin gs were fine. Now the past 10 or so days everything has gone to hell?! What causes that to happen?
If you have nitrite and ammonia tank is not cycle. You need to add dr Tim’s all in one or bio spira to finish cycle off and knock down the Amonia and nitrite.
 
The live rock may not have been heavily populated with enough bacteria to support your bioload. Adding more rock that maybe wasn’t fully cycled may have started an ammonia spike and it’s unable to catch up because it’s pretty new and you have livestock making more ammonia.
regarding your question as to why suppliers don’t prevent diseases from spreading...it costs them too much money and space to treat the amount of fish they get...it’s just not feasible for most of them to medicate and hang on to 100-200 fish for 30 plus days and still be able to make money.
 
I am sorry this has happened, but we need to get you comfortable with the cycling and how to qt, add fish in the future. Please read some of the following articles and it should help you get a good footing to begin to follow up. It is not unusual to have things go suddenly downhill in new tanks. Especially with new hobbyists. It is a big learning curve.

https://www.reef2reef.com/threads/cycling-an-aquarium.306554/
https://www.reef2reef.com/threads/beginners-guide-to-acclimation-and-quarantine.304980/
https://www.reef2reef.com/threads/the-supreme-guide-to-setting-up-a-saltwater-reef-aquarium.138750/
 
The live rock may not have been heavily populated with enough bacteria to support your bioload. Adding more rock that maybe wasn’t fully cycled may have started an ammonia spike and it’s unable to catch up because it’s pretty new and you have livestock making more ammonia.
regarding your question as to why suppliers don’t prevent diseases from spreading...it costs them too much money and space to treat the amount of fish they get...it’s just not feasible for most of them to medicate and hang on to 100-200 fish for 30 plus days and still be able to make money.
Yeah I know they can’t but I was so upset still am. I’m everything was going good for a while then boom fish dying. I think it’s Marine Velvet honestly. So treating that. My blenny and goby are in QT tank being treated and will leave DT fish free for two months. On good note that will give me time to make the DT even better moving coral around and making it more blenny and goby happy. I just feel bad. They rely on us to keep them safe and healthy and I did a crappy job by not following through. Thanks for all the info I REALLY appreciate it. I will be reading even MORE info tonight and tomorrow to keep it from happening. We cycled the DT for 5 1/2 weeks had the brown algae and thought it was finished. We used the AquaVitiro Seed to cycle it faster and still waited month and a bit before adding fish and inverts. Oh well what can I do but learn from this and move on. Again thank you all so so much for help and advice! I love this website!!
 
I understand your frustration @SniffanyB. Slow down and get your current livestock healthy. There’s a lot of information here and it’s overwhelming but take your time to read and learn and you will be in good shape before you know it.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 30 44.8%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 13.4%
  • No.

    Votes: 25 37.3%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.5%
Back
Top