Fish you have/had kept but wouldnt keep again

Any fish I hadn't researched before I bought it, there is plenty of readily available information out the to allow you to make an informed decision. For example- lots of the posts on here quote damsels- do your research, understand/identify the species and their needs and you can create a stunning fairly peaceful display. Flame angels, lots of info about them, they are known coral pickers but people still put them in reef tanks and blame the fish when they damage corals.

My answer to the question is- any impulse bought fish.
 
Part of the problem is that people aren't forewarned that Blue Spot Jawfish need temperatures a bit colder than you want in a reef (ie 74 degrees). At regular 77-79 degree reef temps they don't last long term. Wouldn't surprise me if it kept jumping because the tank was too warm for it.

Yup I bet his was definitely jumping due to the temp. I've had mine for I forget if it's been a year or two but whenever my temp creeps up he jumps into the overflow.. when it cools back down he jumps back into the tank. Although I keep mine 76-77
 
Do you mean goldflake angels? If so why cause id love to keep one someday
Yes. I had a pair before one died but they went to town on sps if they showed any decline. Also ate lobos and Scully etc. Just not worth the gamble in a mixed reef. Eventually it chilled out but still wont try keeping fleshy coral with it
 
Mandarins and Copperband butterfly.
Very beautiful but very difficult to keep - requires an enormous commitment of time and resources to keep alive
Flame hawk fish - love the beauty and personality but they are hell on crustaceans
 
Gosh, after listing these out, I realize that a) I've had a lot of fish, and 2) I'm glad this is only a saltwater list. :0) To be clear, I don't necessarily "hate" any of these fish, just would not buy them again.

Tomato clown with a bullet! These things are absolute terrors!

Domino damsel - unless it was in a tank with triggers, eels, etc. They are SO cool looking but just such little a$$holes. This is also true for 3 stripe, 4 stripe damsels. I do have some very nice Talbotts, azures, and half blacks now FYI.

Undulated triggerfish - looks amazing but is pure evil. But I love triggers otherwise. My humu is terrific.

Lionfish - now that they are invasive in the Atlantic/Caribbean I just can't look at them the same as I did as a teenager. Just want them all dead. :0)

Squirrelfish - their mouths are much bigger than you think and so are their appetites.

Grunt - same as above, but less colorful. Was a fun fish, but not one I'll buy again.

Hamlet - very cool fish but never had any luck with them doing well. Done trying.

Fimbriated Moray - truly an eye-catching fish. Voracious appetite and highly irritable. Wasn't able to keep it with anything else. Would go with Moray again but a more "docile" variety... which is almost any other species. :0)

Butterfly (any) - I just don't trust them. Raccoon butterfly caused the demise of a 100 gallon system many moons ago. I can't forgive the Family.

Panther grouper - I won't buy ANY grouper anymore unless it's cooked. Just not a smart purchase for the vast majority of aquarists.
 
Last edited:
Ok, let me begin by saying fish trend toward a particular behavior. The Damsel family would be a good example. However, ALL fish have distinct personalities. You will hear plenty of good and bad.
There Is an occasional Anomaly here or there. In my case...

A Pakistani Angel. I Love Angel fish and unfortunately, they love corals! I knew this and purchased one anyway, hoping for positive outcome.
No such luck! MUNCH! CHOMP! Corals decimated which caused a cascade effect....
I think you get it.
 
Sohal Tang.

Like other psychotic beauties in my life, it didn't turn out well...

sohal-tang.jpg
 
Copperband Butterfly and Regal Angel - successfully kept them on frozen food and live black worms. Too much commitment and was not able to take any prolonged vacations. Can’t trust anyone to feed the tank frozen food or let alone let anyone inside my house without me being there.
 
I only have two clowns currently, so I don't have much input. I do wonder why so many people are saying they wouldn't want another clown.

I think its because they can become bullies especially spawning pairs, but ive never experienced this cus in every pair ive kept one always dies
 
I think its because they can become bullies especially spawning pairs, but ive never experienced this cus in every pair ive kept one always dies

I have a pair that is very attentive to one corner. Constantly cleaning it and trying to sweep the shells out, and moving the hernit crabs away. So I've suspected they're planning on spawning.... hopefully they don't turn mean when I get another fish.
 
Tomato Clown,Damsels,Six line Wrasse & Lion fish no matter how much I love the radiata. I would add the Maroon Clown but my wife loves them so I could be forced at some time to get another one. lol
What problems did you have with the wrasse?
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%
Back
Top