For those who struggled, but finally succeeded.

Mike in CT

Valuable Member
View Badges
Joined
Jan 29, 2013
Messages
1,123
Reaction score
498
Location
Connecticut
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Hi everyone!
Did your tank struggle for a year or two before things finally started taking off? Was there something you figured out that finally put you over the top from struggling tank to everything was thriving like you hoped for? ( new lighting, better maintenance, dosing... Etc)
Tell us if you figured out the mystery off what finally got you going in the right direction!

Thanks,
Mike
 
following along. my tank has bee up for almost a year and its not where I know it shoud be. I am thinking it has something to do with my rushed start up.
 
Had several tanks over years... still learning stuff. main thing I learned so far.

> GHA and cyano. You have to find the right equipment and maintenance routine that works for your tank to eliminate these problems. We all buy the same tanks but what we put in them (rock, sand, fish, food, top off water, WC, etc ...) differs. There is some combination of some or all of these things (eg. rock, skimmers, nitrate/GFO reactors, WC, RO/DI, food type and amount fed, carbon dosing ...) that will eliminate this for your unique tank.

> dosing stuff (eg. cal, alk, mg...) What you dose, how much, how often varies with your unique tank and periodic, regular testing will make sure you are dosing the right stuff when you need to. Observing corals, some can give you signs that stuff is starting to go bad so you can do something before it gets too far. I have 1 monti and a porrite in one tank that looses PE when some param are not in the recom ranges.

> dont overstock your tank with too many fish or fish that are too big, it will lead to excessive nutrients, GHA etc

> new stuff can often bring pests, dip corals, and quarantine rock, corals and fish if you don't want to deal with pests in your tank.

> decide what you want in your tank first, then buy the equipment it needs. You will have what you want in your tank and your tank will look good and be relatively easy to care for.
 
I think if I could do one thing over again it would be to use gfo or an equivalent to export phosphates before they became a problem. Seems like when I read about people having GHA and bubble algae they are going to through the same scenario as me. Things are pretty good the first year or so, and we don't think much about GFO because we don't have a problem with algae, then all of a sudden our tanks become saturated with phosphates and we are hit with massive algae blooms and caught trying get rid of phosphates that have been building up over time.
 
I've had my tank for about 10 months now and the tank started well in the beginning then I went through the last 8 months of pain. It all started because I hadn't been dosing and the couple SPS and LPS I bought sucked the calcium out of the water. Also my mag dropped real low. That's when I learned about alk, calc, and mag the hard way. Took 8 months to get to where I am today. Now I have SPS growing so quickly you can see a difference everyday. I also underwent a crash in the past month because my RO membrane failed. I was basically dosing phosphate into the tank with water changes and top off. Lost a lot of inverts and a couple chromis. But I persevered and the tank has cleared up and the corals are bouncing back and growing quickly. Some other things I've gone through are losing many fairy wrasses because they stop eating or they waste away even when eating. I definitely plan to setup a QT once I have the space so I can quarantine the more delicate species I want to keep.
 
I think if I could do one thing over again it would be to use gfo or an equivalent to export phosphates before they became a problem. Seems like when I read about people having GHA and bubble algae they are going to through the same scenario as me. Things are pretty good the first year or so, and we don't think much about GFO because we don't have a problem with algae, then all of a sudden our tanks become saturated with phosphates and we are hit with massive algae blooms and caught trying get rid of phosphates that have been building up over time.
This is something I'm glad I did from the start. I've been running GFO since about the 2nd month I started the tank. Also when I cycled the tank, I did it with the lights out. Helps cut down on unwanted algae growth.
 
My tank started off good also & I thought I was going to be able to do 15g water changes on a 125g tank 1x per wk & be fine... Boy was I wrong. I got initated into the land of dosing quick & fast. Also learned Alk & Cal are important but don't forget a/b Mg either!!! When I had a 45 gal tank all I ever heard was bigger tank = larger body of water = less parameter swings. Also, they got a snake oil in this hobby for just a/b everything, I took a ride on the Zeovit roller coaster for a/b 8-9 months. These tanks are beautiful, don't get me wrong, but getting a tank to look like this is like a finding the last unicorn. I bought w/ I thought was the upper level skimmer for my sump + an alge scrubber + I vodka dose. Now I'm reading that I'm stripping down my water too much. They say you need some nitrates but no phosphates. Members on here suggest "stump remover" to add nitrates. Gotta admit I'm kinda nervous adding stump remover to my tank. I think I'm gonna just turn down the alge scrubber so the system has more nutrients. Sorry for the rant just get a lil' frustrated w/ my reef addiction sometimes.
 
Over 10 years in the hobby and have run 30g, 75g and now 180g tanks.

Everybody talks about the nitrogen cycle when you start up a new tank. That's good info. But IMHO there is a 6 to 12 month cycle during which a tank 'simply' matures. And then things run much smoother. I'm not exactly sure what it is that changes. Maybe it's a lot of little things. But it sure makes a difference.
 
Last edited:
Hi everyone!
Did your tank struggle for a year or two before things finally started taking off? Was there something you figured out that finally put you over the top from struggling tank to everything was thriving like you hoped for? ( new lighting, better maintenance, dosing... Etc)
Tell us if you figured out the mystery off what finally got you going in the right direction!

Thanks,
Mike
Simple Macro algaes.
but than I'm an old FW planted type guy
My 55g after 3 months couldn't keep a new fish over 2 weeks. Ich, slow moving, heavy breathing then dieing. Meanwhile the fish already there were doing fine. I finally measured pH and found it very low. and one clerk at a local petsmark mentioned that if I was very lucky I might get some macro algae on the rocks. So I looked into macro algae and started culturing some in an old 20g and adding to the display.
Almost immediately the ph rose to over 8 and by the end of the week was up to 8.4. A new tang showing the first symptoms (white dots) recovered lived and tripled in size over the next year.
Then I discovered the macros are consuming the co2, adding oxygen, stabilize the tank by immediately consuming any "extra" ammonia, not to mention providing food for the tank which helps its immune system.
my .02
 
Over 10 years in the hobby and have run 30g, 75g and now 180g tanks.

Everybody talks about the nitrogen cycle when you start up a new tank. That's good info. But IMHO there is a 6 to 12 month cycle during which a tank 'simply' matures. And then things run much smoother. I'm not exactly sure what it is that changes. Maybe it's a lot of little things. But it sure makes a difference.
This makes sense to me. I'll have to keep this in mind as I start up my tank.
 
For me, it's always been water chemistry. Now its a lot better and things are taking off, my problem is always trying to get things right and not being patient.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 30 44.8%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 13.4%
  • No.

    Votes: 25 37.3%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.5%
Back
Top