Going Bare Bottom

A Toadstool Leather

Well-Known Member
View Badges
Joined
Apr 1, 2017
Messages
911
Reaction score
638
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
I am planning on removing my sandbed in my reef tank. Can I remove the whole thing at once, or should I do it slowly? My tank has a low bioload so I would think the bacteria in the live rock is enough. If I want to have a sandbed again after going bare bottom can I add new sand without causing issues?
 
Depends on how long its been established. If it was my tank, and even if it was recently established, I would slowly remove it over the course of a month or more. I would also keep prime on hand and add it each time I removed sand. Adding the new sand should not cause any problems.
 
What is your sand to live rock ratio, how big is the tank, and what is the bioload, and how long have the sand and live rock been in the tank?

The rule is take it slow, like Cment suggested seems cautious and reasonable
 
I changed my entire sandbed all at once from 9 yrs old to brand new wo a cycle, low bioloading, high coral loading, we seem to have similar setups. there is absolutely no harm in doing it slowly and arriving at the BB condition, agreed there. my ratio of live rock to water was five pounds per gallon, so I knew it was safe. lesser live rock setups are a concern, agreed

post your full tank shot lets see overall ratios am curious
 
What is your sand to live rock ratio, how big is the tank, and what is the bioload, and how long have the sand and live rock been in the tank?

The rule is take it slow, like Cment suggested seems cautious and reasonable
There is about 20lbs of live rock in my 30 gallon. I only have one fish in it, and some of the sand is close to 2 years old and the youngest sand is 1 year old.
 
Agreed with Salty due to the ratios stated it's ok to pull if you want to. It's important to rinse off and dislodge any detritus from up under and within the rocks as well before you count on them the be your sole filtration and to be instantly set back up along with fish. Extra detritus stores have the potential to liberate ammonia and other metabolites of degredation when disturbed, our entire sand rinse thread has zero losses but pages of work because we never re assemble a cloudable setup, you'll be able to lift up a rock and shake it roughly in another container of water to get an idea how much clouding, if any, they've retained.


So interestingly it's not the removal of sandbed bacteria to concern about, its reassembling any form of clouding along with reduced surface area you need to plan for. Though your sandbed was extra surface area, this was in excess to what few pounds of live rock can do and as long as the rock has nice flow and clean pores from being cleaned out that's more than enough surface area to handle a bioloading beyond your stated levels. Pls take pics of whatever you wind up applying so we can feature it in work threads
 
Last edited:
Agreed with Salty due to the ratios stated it's ok to pull if you want to. It's important to rinse off and dislodge any detritus from up under and within the rocks as well before you count on them the be your sole filtration and to be instantly set back up along with fish. Extra detritus stores have the potential to liberate ammonia and other metabolites of degredation when disturbed, our entire sand rinse thread has zero losses but pages of work because we never re assemble a cloudable setup, you'll be able to lift up a rock and shake it roughly in another container of water to get an idea how much clouding, if any, they've retained.


So interestingly it's not the removal of sandbed bacteria to concern about, its reassembling any form of clouding along with reduced surface area you need to plan for. Though your sandbed was extra surface area, this was in excess to what few pounds of live rock can do and as long as the rock has nice flow and clean pores from being cleaned out that's more than enough surface area to handle a bioloading beyond your stated levels. Pls take pics of whatever you wind up applying so we can feature it in work threads
I will post results later when I do a water change tomorrow. So you are saying I can clear the sand as long as I clean the rocks and the space under them?
 
I love bare bottom tanks. I always suggest a sheet of cheap Mylar under the glass on the bottom. It is very reflective >97%

It will really make your tank look incredibly bright and help provide PAR from all angles.....much less bleaching from shading and colors under your corals.
 
I love bare bottom tanks. I always suggest a sheet of cheap Mylar under the glass on the bottom. It is very reflective >97%

It will really make your tank look incredibly bright and help provide PAR from all angles.....much less bleaching from shading and colors under your corals.
Most of my corals are soft corals, is this still needed for softies?
 
Interesting concept. Is there algae build up like on the side walls where you have to scape?
Yes. If you want to make the most of it all 5 sides of glass should be cleaned regularly.
 
I just tore down my 75 which had sand and though I thought I kept it clean it was horrible. I move everything into a 30 long with a piece of 1/4" thick starboard on the bottom. 5 days after the switch my corals have never looked this good. The switch from crushed coral to sand improved my tank. Now the switch from sand to bare bottom has taken it to another level.
 
Not to hijack the thread but apart from tearing the tank down, what are some of the best ways to remove a sandbed from an established system?
 
IMO the best way is just syphon out a small amount with each water change until it’s removed, super easy and less impact on your system... if you want to reintroduce sand do the same, add a little at a time until you reach your desired volume.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%

New Posts

Back
Top