Going to metal halide t5 from led. What should I know?

Hockeypunk1

Active Member
View Badges
Joined
Oct 21, 2016
Messages
299
Reaction score
110
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
I have been running a hydra 52 and a kessil 150 over my 55 corner tank. I can't seem to dial in the spectrum and coverage to get the growth I desire. My par varies from 50ish at the sandbed to around 250-300 at the top of my rock structure. I recently bought an oddysea 24 inch t5 metal halide fixture. I also ordered a 14k phoenix bulb and 4 ati blue plus bulbs from brs. My question is how should I acclimate the new lighting system? I was thinking I would run the t5 for 12 hours and the halide for 4 to start and slowly increase to 8 hours. Currently I run the hydra for 12 hours with a 4 hour ramp and the kessil runs about 11 hours. I love the hydra but I seem to get some dark side recession on all my acropora that are not at the top of the structure. I wish I had a practical way to implement t5 with the hydra but it would look bad.
 
I have never ran anything other than led lights so anything about t5 mh that I should know ahead of time would be greatly appreciated. I ran fish only and softy tanks for the last 6 years. I had a fowlr tank when I was in college. Over the last year I have went all in on sps.
 
Go MH/LED look at the Reef Brite hybrid fixtures
Too late for that. Lol. I already bought the oddysea. I know it's cheap and all but I've seen good reviews and seen some good results from users.
 
You can stack screens to shade the tank and remove a layer every couple days. But that would really depend on the MH bulb wattage .
I had always found the 14000k bulbs to be pretty forgiving. (Phoenix, Hamilton etc..)
 
Start at 2 hours on the MH and increase 30 mins per day.
Personally, I'd stop around 6 hours, at least for now.
8 hours is a lot of light for full blast MH.
For the T5, Blue+ are a really high par bulb and not very blue. More of a white blue, with a hint of green tint. Personally, I don't care for them outside of the high par.
I would run two of those (or a KZ Super Blue (no green tint) or whatever the Geisemann equivalent is, i dont remember) and then run at least one Geisemann Super Actinic, if not two. These will help give you that color pop morning and evening.
 
When you consider the actual spread, and low initial cost, I don't find halide to be inefficient at all .... IF the right reflector/ballast is used, and it's spread is utilized. The odd dimensions of your corner tank utilize a singe halide well. Oddyessa is very low quality as halide systems go. DE halides in general don't spread as yell as single ended bulbs, and the ballast + reflectors used are poor quality. This fixture will still be leap and bounds ahead of a single kessil and AI over a 55 corner, but if you happen to see a used 24" gieseman spectra GET IT! I paid $400 for mine and it lights my 32x32x26 SPS reef beautiful (400w radium).
 
The t5 in the oddseay are weak, run as long as you'd like. I would start the halide @ 5 hours per day and see how corals respond. Should be an immediate positive response. In next few weeks maybe increase to 7 or 8 (if nutrients are high). I personally run my 400w 7 hrs daily. There will be more heat while the halide is on obviously. I run a fan across the fixture and water surface which is hooked up to my apex to turn on at desired temp.
 
I ran metal halide for years ranging tank sizes 29 - 300 gallon tanks. I loved it. I ran my MH for 8 hours while the T5's went 12 dawn to dusk. I recently purchased a Red Sea Max 260 E with the accompanying AI Prime 26 HD. I don't care for this lighting all that much. There is shadowing (not that it bothers me all that much) but the colors and pop while nice have changed the colors of my acros. If I had my druthers it would definitely be BACK to MH and T5.
 
D2Mini has it right, start with a short duration 'day', and increase 30m per day until the desired duration is reached. 6 hours or so under halides. The T5's you have are likely not providing more PAR than your LED's, I'd run them however you want to and not be too worried.

That your electric bill is not going to be happy. ;)

I switched from an 80w LED light to a 250w electronic ballast halide. Ran some numbers before hand.
80w led, 8 hours per day at 12¢/KwH == $2.15/month
250w Halide, 6 hours per day at 12¢/KwH == $5.04/month

Add in the fact that my 350w heater doesn't run while the halide is running, but DID, nearly 3 hours per 8 hour 'day' while the LED was running...
350w Heater, 3 hours per day at 12¢/KwH == $3.53/month
Then, try and figure out how much more time your air conditioner runs during the summer due to halide, and how much less time your furnace runs during winter with the halide... It's a wash, folks.

Honestly, since my normal household monthly usage is about 4700 KwH, I don't think I'm ever going to notice, one way or the other.
 
I just came home for lunch and the fixture has arrived. I plugged it in and everything works except the halide! The ballast seems to have a rattle inside. I was thinking about upgrading this anyway. The bulb kinda flickers and then nothing. I'm going to email the supplier first. Also their is some kind of white panel over the t5s. I'm thinking those will be coming off. I wish I could have bought a higher end light but for 250 bucks for everything including the extra bulbs from brs I figured it was worth a shot
 
Never mind it works and it's way brighter than I thought it would be. The problem was the halide light that comes with it wasn't plugged in to the slots. I can't believe it survived shipping like that. The t5 lights were the same way
 
I appreciate everyone's insight! If there is anything else I should know about this foreign light fixture I would appreciate any and all knowledge. I heard that the halide has a burn in period and something about not turning it on and off without a cool down period. Can anyone elaborate on this?
 
It was shipped with the bulbs already in place? Hmpf. Folks talk about how intense their LED's are... there's a reason why they use Metal Halides to light up parking lots ;)
 
I heard that the halide has a burn in period and something about not turning it on and off without a cool down period. Can anyone elaborate on this?

Don't know about this particular fixture, but most halide ballasts won't re-fire for 10 minutes or so after shutting off. If you have to shut your halides off during the 'day'... just give them some time to cool before turning them back on. Halides do 'burn in' a bit, they'll be brighter after a few hours of use. They also color shift as you use them. A decent quality bulb will burn bright for several years of daily use, but the color won't be what it was originally. I change mine yearly.

Watch the heat. Halides, especially in an enclosed canopy, can have a huge impact on water temps. Venting helps. Fans help more. Chillers are expensive, and unless you keep it real warm in your home, probably not necessary. Don't panic about it, but keep a close eye on temp swings.
 
It was shipped with the bulbs already in place? Hmpf. Folks talk about how intense their LED's are... there's a reason why they use Metal Halides to light up parking lots ;)
They sure did ship them with bulbs in place. The double end halide was mostly sitting on the protective glass pannel and once I pushed it in I was able to fire it up. It is really bright! Way brighter than my hydra 52
 
Don't know about this particular fixture, but most halide ballasts won't re-fire for 10 minutes or so after shutting off. If you have to shut your halides off during the 'day'... just give them some time to cool before turning them back on. Halides do 'burn in' a bit, they'll be brighter after a few hours of use. They also color shift as you use them. A decent quality bulb will burn bright for several years of daily use, but the color won't be what it was originally. I change mine yearly.

Watch the heat. Halides, especially in an enclosed canopy, can have a huge impact on water temps. Venting helps. Fans help more. Chillers are expensive, and unless you keep it real warm in your home, probably not necessary. Don't panic about it, but keep a close eye on temp swings.
Ok that makes sense. Even when I turned it on for about a minute or two I could see the bulb getting brighter. I have an open top and am transitioning to a basement sump with an in line frag tank so heat shouldn't be an issue. I'm also in the process of hooking up an apex classic my girlfriend bought me for Christmas. So temp will be monitored and controlled by the apex.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 30 44.8%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 13.4%
  • No.

    Votes: 25 37.3%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.5%
Back
Top