Goni with a sweeper tentacle? Or no?

  • Thread starter Thread starter dochou
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users None

dochou

Active Member
View Badges
Joined
Jan 2, 2018
Messages
129
Reaction score
72
What state or country do you live in
California
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Is this normal behavior or look of a goniopora? I didn't think they had sweepers. Most goni seem to have all tentacles near the same length. I wish all the tentacles were long like the dominant one in the pic.
Any advise?
58887e986ca49b511144c8eee117f4c4.jpg
fb16296303582299b8c6676541096993.jpg
 
My advice... enjoy the specimen and see how it grows out. Nice BTW.
 
Oh, of course! I enjoy the heck out of it everyday. It's my favorite coral...for now at least. I've had it for 2 months and it seems to be happy.
 
It is a sweeper tentacle. I have gonioporas that do this. Very mean sting also. Make sure you keep it out of reach from other corals, they will most likely lose...
 
It is a sweeper tentacle. I have gonioporas that do this. Very mean sting also. Make sure you keep it out of reach from other corals, they will most likely lose...

Thanks for your insight.
Anyone else have thoughts?
 
Definitely normal. The ends have nematocysts so it could be a feeding response or a defensive mechanism against other corals.

So these 2 gonioporas shouldn't be this close?
 
Thanks, I won't mess with them.

It will be a beautiful reef one day, it's still very young, 7 months old.
 
Aren't sweepers more stringy and clear and from reading in the goniporas case they are more dense then normal heads/polyps? While goniopora do have sweepers, this to me looks just long a elongated polyp/head. Could it just be catching more flow/ the perfect amount of flow? My entire colony is the size of a softball and always looks like your longer tentacle and I doubt most are all sweepers since only the newer bottom heads are smaller on mine since are new/growing out. My tang brushes it always and so do my wrasse and no issues ever.

Study
"The massive coral Goniopora tenuidens can develop elongated "sweeper" polyps. These are thought to be involved in aggressive interactions with neighbouring benthic organisms, like the sweeper tentacles of other corals. The cnidoms of sweeper polyps and ordinary polyps of G. tenuidens from the Great Barrier Reef were compared. Sweeper polyps had significantly greater densities of elongate holotrichous isorhizas (34577 ± 3839/mg; mean ± SD, n = 6) than ordinary polyps (936 ± 371/mg; p < 0.05), while ordinary polyps had significantly greater densities of spirocysts (75994 ± 15992/mg) than sweeper polyps (19469 ± 7808/mg; p < 0.05). This suggests that sweeper polyps of G. tenuidens, like the sweeper tentacles of other corals, are modified for aggression, and that they probably act through nematocyst discharge. However, the scattered distribution of sweeper polyps observed on colonies of G. tenuidens in the field suggests that sweeper polyps may have other functions. "

 
It's always just a handful of polyps that extend 2 to 3 times the length of the others and it's not for more than just a few hours.
 
Aren't sweepers more stringy and clear and from reading in the goniporas case they are more dense then normal heads/polyps? While goniopora do have sweepers, this to me looks just long a elongated polyp/head. Could it just be catching more flow/ the perfect amount of flow? My entire colony is the size of a softball and always looks like your longer tentacle and I doubt most are all sweepers since only the newer bottom heads are smaller on mine since are new/growing out. My tang brushes it always and so do my wrasse and no issues ever.

Study
"The massive coral Goniopora tenuidens can develop elongated "sweeper" polyps. These are thought to be involved in aggressive interactions with neighbouring benthic organisms, like the sweeper tentacles of other corals. The cnidoms of sweeper polyps and ordinary polyps of G. tenuidens from the Great Barrier Reef were compared. Sweeper polyps had significantly greater densities of elongate holotrichous isorhizas (34577 ± 3839/mg; mean ± SD, n = 6) than ordinary polyps (936 ± 371/mg; p < 0.05), while ordinary polyps had significantly greater densities of spirocysts (75994 ± 15992/mg) than sweeper polyps (19469 ± 7808/mg; p < 0.05). This suggests that sweeper polyps of G. tenuidens, like the sweeper tentacles of other corals, are modified for aggression, and that they probably act through nematocyst discharge. However, the scattered distribution of sweeper polyps observed on colonies of G. tenuidens in the field suggests that sweeper polyps may have other functions. "

Stringy sweepers are associated with favia species, euphyllia, even chalices. Goniopora will send out elongated polyps of the coral. Even hammers can do this, you'll see an actual polyp itself 4" longer than the rest.
 
Stringy sweepers are associated with favia species, euphyllia, even chalices. Goniopora will send out elongated polyps of the coral. Even hammers can do this, you'll see an actual polyp itself 4" longer than the rest.
Maybe stringy was the wrong word? Thin being better i guess since they do look different according to the study above. Just my opinion above i do not think this is a sweeper just a polyp/head in more flow, but i could be wrong as im basing it of my own experience and all mine are that size in the "perfect" flow. But like stated I could be wrong. :)
 
They definitely will send out sweepers. The nematocysts on the tips of the polyps are their defense. I believe I've read they can actually release some nematocysts as well but I can't remember where.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%
Back
Top