Goniopora

[micky015]

Brown film growing over goniopora coral, coral was healthy and fully extended for a week then it closed for a day and started developing the brown jelly film over itself, I’ve tried coral dip, I’ve tried manually removing the film (jelly like) multiple times but it comes back within a day.
Unsure of what to do, the coral won’t even open anymore.
Any help would be appreciated

EDIT: have also tried more light, less light, more flow, less flow.

 

[micky015]

Have also tried more flow, less flow, more light, less light. Nothing is working

 

[bnord]

in your dips have you included antibiotics?

 

[heyhei99]

How did it go? I think mine having the same issues

 

[nothing_fancy]

Probably a goner, no pun intended... Parameter check?

 

[micky015]

How did it go? I think mine having the same issues

Honestly I think my tank just wasn’t mature enough as all my corals are now doing fine, I didn’t have any iodine to do an iodine dip it was dead the next day

 

[exnisstech]

Aquacultured or wild harvested? The reason I ask is because through the years I have tried gonni several times and failed but the they were all wild harvested. I have had four aquacultured frags for a several months now and they are doing well.

 

[Kasrift]

Aquacultured or wild harvested? The reason I ask is because through the years I have tried gonni several times and failed but the they were all wild harvested. I have had four aquacultured frags for a several months now and they are doing well.

Couldn't agree with this more. I got a random goni from a local fish store that some other hobbyist had traded in for store credit and it is the happiest thing ever. I had two die that were wild.