Gut loading rosey red minnows

  • Thread starter Thread starter kenand
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users None

kenand

Active Member
View Badges
Joined
Oct 15, 2023
Messages
276
Reaction score
42
Location
plant city
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
If you can gut load ghost shrimp with marine food,can you do the same with rosey red minnows for lionfish? And can they be kept together?
 
If you can gut load ghost shrimp with marine food,can you do the same with rosey red minnows for lionfish? And can they be kept together?
You can, but you don't want to use minnows as feeders - Guppies, Mollies, and Ghost/Grass Shrimp are recommended because they're brackish water critters and have a much better nutritional profile for saltwater predators. Also, it's likely not a good idea to keep predators their live feeders - the predator experts suggest that feeding them too frequently can cause serious health problems that lead to the predators dying fairly quickly (a "fast/gorge" feeding schedule is recommended).

My post in the thread linked below is a lot of info to take in, but it's packed with good info on keeping and feeding predators, but if you're not up for reading all of it, I'd strongly suggest at least reading lion king's links in the quote below:
Here's 3 of my most comprehensive threads on feeding lionfish and other predators.

 
You can, but you don't want to use minnows as feeders - Guppies, Mollies, and Ghost/Grass Shrimp are recommended because they're brackish water critters and have a much better nutritional profile for saltwater predators. Also, it's likely not a good idea to keep predators their live feeders - the predator experts suggest that feeding them too frequently can cause serious health problems that lead to the predators dying fairly quickly (a "fast/gorge" feeding schedule is recommended).

My post in the thread linked below is a lot of info to take in, but it's packed with good info on keeping and feeding predators, but if you're not up for reading all of it, I'd strongly suggest at least reading lion king's links in the quote below:
The place where I buy the fish said I could do ghost shrimp as a snack ,maybe every 2 weeks or so. It's just something I wanted to try,but I'm going to do what you recommend for me to be honest. I trust your opinion.
 
These fish and other feeders often come with disease as they are grade b,c,d quality hence the low cost of them. A high risk to say the least
 
These fish and other feeders often come with disease as they are grade b,c,d quality hence the low cost of them. A high risk to say the least
I understand. 1 loinfish is eating the frozen shrimp. It comes to the top of the tank before it hits the water . Which is awesome. The other viotin is not eating yet,or the dwarf. 1 dwarf us missing or hiding. I assume not dead because of no ammonia spike. I want to move some rocks but don't want to get stung. It's been a week maybe since I've seen it. As far as the others not eating, I might have to get live shrimp.
 
I understand. 1 loinfish is eating the frozen shrimp. It comes to the top of the tank before it hits the water . Which is awesome. The other viotin is not eating yet,or the dwarf. 1 dwarf us missing or hiding. I assume not dead because of no ammonia spike. I want to move some rocks but don't want to get stung. It's been a week maybe since I've seen it. As far as the others not eating, I might have to get live shrimp.
Assure you dont have elevated readings with ammonia and nitrate causing this as well as heavy breathing . They are susceptible ich- inspect them well.
Often IF there was an ammonia spike, it can shoot up yet settle to the point at testing time, its near undetectable.
What test kits are you using ?
As for rocks, stinging yes is a risk- Tis below will be your bset friend as well as aqua gloves.

Aquarium tongs:

1712579123733.png


Aqua Gloves ($20):


1712579179687.png
 
I will order the gloves now. As far as feedind tge others live for now? I use api test kit. I can go to where I buy fish and have it tested today.
 
I understand. 1 loinfish is eating the frozen shrimp. It comes to the top of the tank before it hits the water . Which is awesome. The other viotin is not eating yet,or the dwarf. 1 dwarf us missing or hiding. I assume not dead because of no ammonia spike. I want to move some rocks but don't want to get stung. It's been a week maybe since I've seen it. As far as the others not eating, I might have to get live shrimp.
This may help:
Once acclimated immediately offer live ghost shrimp, or live guppies. Many times a new lion will only respond to live food, another reason for an observation tank. 9/10 a healthy lion will immediately eat live ghosties or guppies. The other 1/10 healthy lion will eat them within a very short time. If they have not responded to a live food offering with 24hrs, immediately treat with general cure or fritz paracleanse. They do come in with internal parasites frequently, and refusing food is a tell. They also come in with flukes, so watch for cloudy eyes and swimming at the surface. Prazi pro is more effective on flukes. Another reason for an observation tank.
Unfortunately, lion king hasn't posted in a while now, but to quote his posts to answer this (they basically recommend Prazi for flukes and GC for internal parasites)
 
What are those?
PraziPro and General Cure are medications to treat parasites our fish get (flukes are a kind of parasite).

Basically, if the lionfish don't eat very soon after being added to an aquarium, there's a good chance they have parasites and need treated before they die - if they have flukes, the recommendation is to treat with PraziPro; if they don't have flukes but aren't eating, the recommendation is to treat with General Cure.
 
As far as feedind tge others live for now?
I would try the live shrimp or guppies and see if the lions that haven't been eating go for it, but I'd also suggest picking up the meds recommended just in case.

If they eat the live, then you may just need to train them to eat dead/prepared foods like you're wanting them to (I quoted Jay Hemdal's methodology for training onto prepared foods in the "2 new lionfish" link above), but if they don't, then I'd suggest treating them ASAP.
 
I would try the live shrimp or guppies and see if the lions that haven't been eating go for it, but I'd also suggest picking up the meds recommended just in case.

If they eat the live, then you may just need to train them to eat dead/prepared foods like you're wanting them to (I quoted Jay Hemdal's methodology for training onto prepared foods in the "2 new lionfish" link above), but if they don't, then I'd suggest treating them ASAP.
Thanks. Can you send a link for the meds?
 
Thanks. Can you send a link for the meds?
 
Buy both or pic one? And this is for the ghost shrimp?
 
Buy both or pic one? And this is for the ghost shrimp?
If the lions don't eat the live ghost shrimp, then I would assume your lionfish are sick and need to be treated with medication (the lionfish, not the shrimp).

If your lionfish are sick and refusing to eat, it's most likely either flukes or internal parasites, and will require one of the medications above.

Flukes will generally be accompanied by other symptoms like cloudy eyes and swimming at the surface of the tank - flukes would require PraziPro to treat.

Internal parasites won't have visible symptoms like the cloudy eyes or swimming at the surface - these would require General Cure.

To treat the fish, you would make sure they're in a tank you can safely add the medication to (a lot of meds are not reef-safe and will kill inverts including corals), and you would add the medication to the water as recommended by the instructions that come with the meds.
 
If the lions don't eat the live ghost shrimp, then I would assume your lionfish are sick and need to be treated with medication (the lionfish, not the shrimp).

If your lionfish are sick and refusing to eat, it's most likely either flukes or internal parasites, and will require one of the medications above.

Flukes will generally be accompanied by other symptoms like cloudy eyes and swimming at the surface of the tank - flukes would require PraziPro to treat.

Internal parasites won't have visible symptoms like the cloudy eyes or swimming at the surface - these would require General Cure.

To treat the fish, you would make sure they're in a tank you can safely add the medication to (a lot of meds are not reef-safe and will kill inverts including corals), and you would add the medication to the water as recommended by the instructions that come with the meds.
It's a fish only tank.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%
Back
Top