Hanna checker

Hudsonvalleyreefguy

New Member
View Badges
Joined
Oct 19, 2018
Messages
16
Reaction score
3
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Just tested my calcium with my Hanna checker and it reads 200 ppm. Which is abnormal. I then tested with an api calcium kit and it reads 480 ppm. Was wondering if this has happened to anyone else with a Hanna checker
 
I’ve looked at getting one of these, but I haven’t yet because they seem to get fairly bad reviews. The other Hanna testers seem to get good reviews, but the calcium tester can be inaccurate according to the reviews. This is from the BRS website.
 
I’ve looked at getting one of these, but I haven’t yet because they seem to get fairly bad reviews. The other Hanna testers seem to get good reviews, but the calcium tester can be inaccurate according to the reviews. This is from the BRS website.
That's what is holding me back too
 
Was about to purchase the calcium checker this weekend but from I'm hearing im not sure
Got the kh hanna checker last weekend
Am well impressed it's a must have
 
I have the Hanna calcium (must use distilled or Hanna water) and check mine against Red Sea Pro kit on occasion and results are always within normal range. I would try the check standard (I also bout that) - possible that your Hanna reagents are bad?
 
Have you used it before? IMO the weak link is the darn micropipette. Unless you work in a research lab I think it's easy to miss-judge the "stops" when using it. There is a bit of feel that goes into it, and when your total added test sample is 0.01ml, well, it can be inaccurate. The other source of error (and, hey, maybe this is it) is that it's hard to be sure you got all the powder from the packet...if any is left behind, or you spill the slightest amount, you're gonna be off. I have finally started getting accurate readings on mine, as I always run it against a simultaneous Red Sea titration for Ca. I started way off, like you, but now they're matching up, so, again, I assume it's user error. But don't feel bad. BTW, I think after this experience that the Hanna isn't worth the trouble. It's actually silly how much user error is built in. It's not easy like their alkalinity (that's sweet, simple, fast, and accurate...well worth the $), so I'm sticking with the titration tests.
 
Use Hannah for ULR Phosphorus checker and their PH pen. Use Salifert for everything else.
 
Hanna makes a standards kit that you can test to see how accurate your tester is reading. Steps maybe help

1. I'd replace the battery just to make sure.
2. After C1. If it takes a long time to get to C2 I just start over means jts not reading something correctly
3. Maybe give the cuvettes a citrus acid bath, lemon juice whatever
4. Make sure there are zero I mean zero smudges or finger prints on the cuvette.
5. I've found some hanna cuvettes hold more or less than 10ml. So in this case I would add the 1ml of reagent then add 9ml of rodi water for c1 test.
6. Make sure you are putting in 0.1 ml of tank water or sample.
7. Vigorously shake the life outta the cuvette and then roll it around on its side making sure no bubbles are stuck the side walls.

Best tips I have for the Hanna checkers.and I use about all of them
 
P.S. I've had my Hanna Calcium checker since 2012 still calibrates within 2 ppm of dead accurate
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%
Back
Top