Hard choice, JBJ 45 or JBJ 29Pro

Which do you suggest? Leave comments and reasons why, advice, experaince, it will help alot!

  • JBJ 45 Rimless

  • JBJ Nanocube Pro 29

  • Something else (in comments)


Results are only viewable after voting.

Nibejeebies

R2R is the reason for my Insomia
View Badges
Joined
Jan 6, 2016
Messages
1,149
Reaction score
567
Location
Lenoir City, Tennessee
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
So after about two weeks of shopping, toying with the idea and looking around, watching youtube, reading others experiences and such Im still simply cant make up my mind (nor can my GF since its 'her' tank) which is better for us.

Currently we have a biocube 14 which this new tank will be replacing and once cycled will get the livestock from.

So from a cost perspective, they look like they will cost with in $50 of each other with all things said and done. (nano from the LFS, the 45 from drf&s online)

The Nano comes with the things that we would have to purchase separately for the 45. Both come with a stand. Both come with return pumps. the 45 would require the purchase of a light (thinking ocean revive since two of them are working well on the 72 in my signature) , a heater, and a power head (which we have a spare Xstream by Siece but that may be too much for this the 45.

My instincts scream go with the more water for less problems. The biocube has the occasional issue but Ive keep it running for the most part smoothly now for 7months. BUT....

The 45 is Rimless. And in the room it would be in, when the biocube's lid was open while I was changing out the lights, (was open for 5 hours, had to run to the store for a different bulb had got the wrong size, it runs PCs) and the temp dropped in that time from 79 to 71. Lucky the livestock seemed unaffected. I keep the house at 68 and there is a window unit in that room. I cant turn the temp of said unit up because it cools that room, as well as the attached bath, sadly that side of the house isnt very well insulated anything set above 70 and the room becomes way to hot.

I worry that there with a rimless there could be an issue with the stability of the temp...
But personally I feel that the water quality and the prams outside the temp would be easier to maintain stability.

If your wondering, we want something bigger for that room, and we are setting the biocube up at a family members house.

So which one should we choose? We cant make a decision so we thought we would ask the community we love and trust! Advice or your experiences would be greatly helpful!
 
I voted for the 45 but I would get the tank only and have a nice custom stand built. all of those manufacturer stands are poorly made.
 
I voted for the 45 but I would get the tank only and have a nice custom stand built. all of those manufacturer stands are poorly made.
Oh? Well I happen to be living next door to a retired carpenter that loves projects... (family!) in that case that would mean (I assume) I could put more money toward a better light!
 
I have the 45 with original stand. The stand supports the 45 plus and 20 gal trigger system sump. I love it. Granted I did put 1x3's on each side and on the top ( inside the stand) in two places but it's sturdy very sturdy. If I had my drothers I would have gone with a bigger stand the 1x3's cut off 2 inches and space is tight in there. But it's ok it looks good and it works. I love the 45 since I transitioned from freshwater I didn't buy a lot new per se ( I already of course heater, light and even a APEX) so I would go with the 45
 
Yes absolutely I did it. Look at my signature line and watch my utube videos on what I did. I actually stated with a coralvue icecap PK50 skimmer that I had in the back basket, I bought a trigger systems crystal cube sump ( 18 in x 18 in) which fits just fine in the stand ( after removing the center brace and bracing the stand with 1x3's. I added a additional 20 gallons to 45 gallons
 
I have the 30 gal jbj and wish I would have got the 45:rolleyes:
 
I had a 28 then the 45. While putting the one glass lid on it one day it caught the top corner and cracked the tank. I would of thought the thin lid would of gave in first. I think those curved corners are a week design. If your plumbing it for a sump you'd save a ton of your money just getting a 40g breeder during a Petco $1 a gallon sale.
 
I voted for the 45 but I would get the tank only and have a nice custom stand built. all of those manufacturer stands are poorly made.
Agreed big time. I have the JBJ 45 and stand, put an ATO under it and the hinges rusted within 2 months from water evap. Get a custom stand made that'll stand up to it. Plus there are awesome media baskets you can add, Tunze has a filter and a protein skimmer that you can add to the back area, then add a chaeto basket and an algae turf scrubber and you'll have on of the best filtration systems anyone could have.
 
Last edited:
They are both great aquariums, you will be happy with either one of them... In my personal opinion, it all comes down to how far do you wish to extend your reefing in the future, the 45 will allow you to keep some more fish, it will give you more equipment options to choose from with less modifications, is also a big plus that is made out of glass. On the other hand, I favor the 29 Pro, mainly because I like the enclosed look and the closer affiliation to a Nano tank ... It has plenty equipment upgrades readily available without making major modifications.

Best of luck.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%

New Posts

Back
Top