Has anyone seen an emerald crab do this to a coral?

  • Thread starter Thread starter w2inc
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users None
I have tried 6 different female emerald crabs and they have ALL chosen to eat my corals such as acans instead of just algae....
 
I guess I'm lucky. I have 3 emerald crabs and they have never damaged any of my corals. They do an excellent job of keeping my algae issues under control. They actually spend their downtime resting in my birdsnest colony.

 
That was she. She is holding roe. Her man lives in and around the coral that has the bald spot on it. After lights out he stays on the damaged coral. He is either eating at it or protecting it an I am not sure. They all kind of scrape at polyps but I have never seen actual damage. I was up late last night and was able to catch the both of them and pull them out. (and do a lot of unintentional fragging). I found one emerald picking at a coral and she let me grab her without a fight.

They are living in another tank while I see what's up. I will check in if that fixes things.
Thats cool that they are breeding, not so goof if they are eating your coral, hope it works out
 
I guess I'm lucky. I have 3 emerald crabs and they have never damaged any of my corals. They do an excellent job of keeping my algae issues under control. They actually spend their downtime resting in my birdsnest colony.

I had a similar experience for the past 2 years. Even my massive males didn't mess with my corals that I could see. The new batch I got in the last month went straight to the bubble algae, but I have watched them casually crush small areas of my SPS. They have always left structural damage. This one was a little different because the polyps looked surgically removed. Someone on the bubble algae section mentioned polyp bailout. Anyone have thoughts on that?
 
I had a similar experience for the past 2 years. Even my massive males didn't mess with my corals that I could see. The new batch I got in the last month went straight to the bubble algae, but I have watched them casually crush small areas of my SPS. They have always left structural damage. This one was a little different because the polyps looked surgically removed. Someone on the bubble algae section mentioned polyp bailout. Anyone have thoughts on that?

Not likely. It is a known stress reaction (mostly when there is a lack of light at the base but bad parameters can cause it too) often seen in Stylophora pistillata that looks similar like the first photo but this doesn't look like a shaded spot. The spots in the Seriatopora though look nothing like a polyp bailout far to random in pattern.
 
Not likely. It is a known stress reaction (mostly when there is a lack of light at the base but bad parameters can cause it too) often seen in Stylophora pistillata that looks similar like the first photo but this doesn't look like a shaded spot. The spots in the Seriatopora though look nothing like a polyp bailout far to random in pattern.
No vodka dosing. I pulled the diffusers off of my lights and I believe I acclimated too quickly. The seriatopora is most likely burned. I turned the lights down and put the diffusers back on and there has been some tissue reclaim since that point. The Stylophora issue happened two days later when I thought it was over with. That is when I started looking for a predator.

When I caught the crab two nights ago I broke all kinds of tips off of the Stylophora. I didn't have time or a place for them so I threw them in my cardinal grow out tank that is plumbed to that system. Today when I went to mount them there were sections where sheets of in tact tissue had fallen off and was waving in the slow current.

The issue was so similar to what happened in the tank that polyp bailout or a bacterial infection seem like the only two rational options. I dipped them in Iodine and mounted them to see what they would do overnight. The parent colony has a spot on it from two days ago but it has not grown.

I believe the issue is environmental. Do you or anyone think that the two degree F temperature shift when the chiller kicks on could cause a stress reaction like that? The chiller is oversized and can drop the tank 2 degrees in 15 minutes.
 
Mine did that to my birdsnest when first introduced. They recovered and he moved on to other things.
 
Mine did that to my birdsnest when first introduced. They recovered and he moved on to other things.
Thanks for that input. I was almost sure it was something else. They really haven't done much for my bubble algae. I have gone back to over feeding the tank and that should keep them at bay until I can start catching them. I am not going to keep them in my new system. Sounds like there are way better options.
 
Nope... but a had a little white starfish do the exact same thing. Harlequin shrimp took care of that!
I had totally forgotten about that! Great info. I have them in my smaller reef and it is totally possible that I brought some over to the main reef. Thanks for pithing in.
 
He and his friend both live on the sump now.
emerald-eating-acro.gif
 
I found this guy living in a complete gutted a colony of green star polyp coral. Left nothing. If anyone can id, I’d appreciate it. Pretty sure it’s not a gorilla. And needless to say Mr Crab is no longer with us.

1FC1DE5B-1F7A-4C9E-9119-E3A07854419A.jpeg


8744D029-DEE7-40BD-82F2-0CB806026825.jpeg
 
I just removed a new emerald with a taste for sps! caught him in the act eating on a couple different ones before I could catch it :mad:

BD7F505F-220C-42C5-BE21-3B81B6A8F42C.jpeg
 
I found this guy living in a complete gutted a colony of green star polyp coral. Left nothing. If anyone can id, I’d appreciate it. Pretty sure it’s not a gorilla. And needless to say Mr Crab is no longer with us.

1FC1DE5B-1F7A-4C9E-9119-E3A07854419A.jpeg


8744D029-DEE7-40BD-82F2-0CB806026825.jpeg
bristly hairy crab. . . . genus of Hapalogaster mertensii
The hairy crab lives around rocks, stones and seaweed in the ocean and in sandy holes on the beach mostly in shallow water. It eats vegetation and meat including seaweed, worms, and carcasses of dead sea creatures.
 
I found this guy living in a complete gutted a colony of green star polyp coral. Left nothing. If anyone can id, I’d appreciate it. Pretty sure it’s not a gorilla. And needless to say Mr Crab is no longer with us.

1FC1DE5B-1F7A-4C9E-9119-E3A07854419A.jpeg


8744D029-DEE7-40BD-82F2-0CB806026825.jpeg
Rock crab. Had one start choping a freshly hatched shark, and devouring corals. Definitely not reef friendly.

Best part about that rock crab is, I prayed on my hands and knees in front of my tank, for Gods help with this crab. The next morning a perfectly healthy rock crab was hanging from a rock. I thought look at you, I'm gonna get you. It was very easy. He was just hanging very dead. I thought there's no way. Thank you Abba!!

Those emeralds are hit and miss. I've had a few go rogue. If you can't catch them, you can always bomb tank with interceptor. At that point they might as well be a red bug.
 
Last edited:
I had an emerald crab go after Duncan's and some sps
 
I have had some tissue loss on my corals for just over a week. I thought it was all kinds of things from new adjustment to lights, alk, something falling in the tank, medicated cream not washed off my hand, pH swing, and on and on. For some reason I normally pull back on food when things don't look right.

I thought I had it beat and I woke up to find this. I just put a bunch of emerald crabs in the system to go after my bubble algae. I have seen them picking at corals, but I have never seen them do much damage. Any thoughts?

IMG_2597.jpeg
IMG_2598.jpeg
I have a client dealing with the same issue they most definitely will eat birdsnest!
 
Rock crab. Had one start choping a freshly hatched shark, and devouring corals. Definitely not reef friendly.

Best part about that rock crab is, I prayed on my hands and knees in front of my tank, for Gods help with this crab. The next morning a perfectly healthy rock crab was hanging from a rock. I thought look at you, I'm gonna get you. It was very easy. He was just hanging very dead. I thought there's no way. Thank you Abba!!

Those emeralds are hit and miss. I've had a few go rogue. If you can't catch them, you can always bomb tank with interceptor. At that point they might as well be a red bug.
This was quite awhile back. I almost forgot about the little guy. I was thinking gall crab at first but wasn’t sure. Same thing when I removed this guy. He sat in the GSP and politely let me escort him out to meet his demise.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%
Back
Top