Hawaiian fish ban lifted?

  • Thread starter Thread starter miyags
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users None
@Kona Diver what is the latest news on
Hmmm- He is on a military base . I just messaged him and he said they are collecting off west Hawaii but as of today (here is link ):

Judge lifts injunction prohibiting aquarium fish permits off Big Island’s west coast​

January 30, 2023 · 6:59 PM CST
twitter sharing button

email sharing button

sharethis sharing button

linkedin sharing button


Listen to this Article
3 minutes
A
A
A

File photo of tropical fish
Hawaiʻi Circuit Court Judge Jeffrey P. Crabtree today lifted an injunction that prohibited the issuance or renewal of aquarium fish permits to commercial collectors in the West Hawai‘i Regional Fishery Management Area.
In 2017, the state Supreme Court unanimously ordered a stop to commercial collection of aquarium fish in Hawaiʻi pending an environmental review.
An injunction on issuing or renewing aquarium fish permits in the rest of the state remains in effect.
The injunction, in the Umberger v. Department of Land & Natural Resources case filed by opponents of commercial aquarium fishing in 2012, was lifted because an environmental review pursuant to the Hawaiʻi Environmental Policy Act is complete for the West Hawaiʻi management area, according to a press release from the state Department of Land and Natural Resources.
Aquarium fishing in West Hawai‘i is not allowed simply because the injunction has been lifted, said lead counsel for the state, Deputy Attorney General Melissa Goldman, during the hearing.
The state Department of Land and Natural Resources said it has not considered or issued any aquarium fishing permits for the West Hawaiʻi management area.
The West Hawaiʻi Regional Fishery Management Area is marked in gray. Map: Hawaiʻi State Division of Aquatic Resources


This management area extends along the west coast of the Island of Hawaiʻi from Ka Lae, Ka‘ū (South Point) to ‘Upolu Point, North Kohala and from the high-water mark on shore seaward to the limit of the state’s management authority, which extends to 3 miles offshore.
Yea we won today to lift injunction for west Hawaii. We still have to go to permitting which I haven’t set the date for yet. Trust me, I know first hand as I’m the person in command of this process. There is no legal collection within the state of Hawaii atm period. If and when things change I will drop in here to give the public some news. Talk later
 
Yea we won today to lift injunction for west Hawaii. We still have to go to permitting which I haven’t set the date for yet. Trust me, I know first hand as I’m the person in command of this process. There is no legal collection within the state of Hawaii atm period. If and when things change I will drop in here to give the public some news. Talk later
Ahhh - Good to know
 
Still waiting!
 
Last edited:
Just people ripping off naive people..It's a fish. That same fish 5 years ago you could buy for 39.99
 
Just people ripping off naive people..It's a fish. That same fish 5 years ago you could buy for 39.99

Any guess what a gallon of milk cost you 5 years ago? A Big Mac? A taco from Taco Bell? Pair of jeans?
 
Yellow tangs at my LFS are $299
The moment the ban lifted they had 2 stock
Captive bred or wild caught from Hawaii? The ban itself may have been lifted but to my knowledge it'll take a while for the permits to be issued.

I can't imagine the prices will drastically decrease though, sellers now know that people will pay a higher price for them so they would not have much on an incentive to bring down prices all that much. If anything it's just an increase in revenue on their end since it'll be cheaper to acquire.
 
Captive bred or wild caught from Hawaii? The ban itself may have been lifted but to my knowledge it'll take a while for the permits to be issued.

I can't imagine the prices will drastically decrease though, sellers now know that people will pay a higher price for them so they would not have much on an incentive to bring down prices all that much. If anything it's just an increase in revenue on their end since it'll be cheaper to acquire.
Yea, I doubt they'll go back down to anywhere close to what they were before ($40 for small?). Small blue tangs around here are around 90-100 so I think that's where the Yellows are going to end up at.
 
Not a difference of 10x. This isn't about inflation.

It is all relative. If you want a legal yellow tang today $165 is the going rate. I hear, and can understand, push back on the ban and forcing some to choose captive bred or raised animals. Similar to aquaculture corals. We all have our own side of the fence we are on so I'll just leave it at that.

But if you want one, regardless of the prices of previous years, this is the entry cost. Flip side is that at least one knows the age plus or minus a month or two and will be able to enjoy it for many, many, years to come. Assuming that they are conscientious aquarist.
 
Exactly ..

And people are paying $250 a head of a torch or 1/4" fresh cut frag of an artificially named acropora. More actually. And yes there are those who are frugal and shop around but look at any of the adds on this forum and the prices are equally expensive compared to 5 years ago.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%
Back
Top