Looking at the BRS website, the eheim jager heaters, for example, call for 250w. The general consensus is to run 2 smaller heaters rather than 1 big one the help protect against over heating.
Find the brand you like and check the ratings to make sure.
So do you guys think 2 200w would do it? I planned on having 2 but wasn't sure if I needed 2 300w or if lesser would hear the whole tank. It will be about 150gallon total water volume.
I would go with 2-300 watts. I have basically the same setup and I can't get two of the eheim ones to heat the tank. Granted they are telling me that they are broken.