Help! Coral catastrophe

MattReefs

Community Member
View Badges
Joined
Aug 14, 2019
Messages
32
Reaction score
6
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Hi. Got these corals about 2 weeks ago. They have not opened since. Here are my parameters. I have 3 acans, and one zoa. I have been dosing Seachem prime every 48 hours. From the past levels of ammonia being about 0.5-0.25

-79°F
-1.025 Salinity
-0ppm Ammonia
-8pH
-0ppm Nitrite
-30ppm Nitrate

D5AA15C4-FF15-4E67-A098-5CA5B653F15D.jpeg 864530CA-8A6D-49A9-BBF9-3B02529FB3ED.jpeg 1782BB99-0B3D-4C5D-B324-138B2F4498AF.jpeg 35CD35E9-1281-4CB1-9657-A3060FDBC0B2.jpeg
 
Your tank looks new plus you started with dry rock. How long has the tank being running?
 
Lighting, salinity (hydrometer or refractometer), all other parameters (alk, phosphate, mag).
All those are dead except the zoas and they appear to be melting. Something is clearly wrong if everything has just died like that. The ammonia seems like the main issue here, why is it showing in a cycled tank? Are you using rodi? Flow? So many possible issues.
Dry rock isn’t the issue, I started with all dry rock in my 20 and a month after starting had zoas, a stylo and hammer In it doing well and still have all of them.
 
Nitrates seem a bit high, wondering why you are still having ammonia problems. Check alkalinity levels and magnesium levels as well. This early with dry rocks is always a hit or miss. I also started my tank with dry rock added my first corals after six months worked perfectly.
 
Lighting, salinity (hydrometer or refractometer), all other parameters (alk, phosphate, mag).
All those are dead except the zoas and they appear to be melting. Something is clearly wrong if everything has just died like that. The ammonia seems like the main issue here, why is it showing in a cycled tank? Are you using rodi? Flow? So many possible issues.
Dry rock isn’t the issue, I started with all dry rock in my 20 and a month after starting had zoas, a stylo and hammer In it doing well and still have all of them.
Started the tank not using rodi. Was able to finally get one two weeks ago and have been using for my ATO system and all water changes.
 
Started the tank not using rodi. Was able to finally get one two weeks ago and have been using for my ATO system and all water changes.

I would definetely check your alkalinity. If you started with tap your alk my be high. If you used tapwater and a high alk salt it could possibly be dangerously high
 
Apart from that, what about your lighting time?
Someone said that fritz turbo start is the only bacteria that actually does anything, but more doesn't means better.
 
From the photos, it looks like the uglie's are just starting, so it is too early for corals in my view. I would not buy any more corals until you have had the successive waves of ugly algae come and go and you start to see the first hints of coraline taking hold. When your tank can support coraline, it can support corals.

In the meantime, I would suggest becoming familiar with keeping the most important 3 parameters of your tank stable and in the preferred zones. Those being temperature, alkalinity and salinity. Keeping those 3 stable and in range, gets you well on your way to success. It looks like you are already working on temperature and salinity.

One of the biggest problems, and cause for frustration, is unreliable test results. Many a reefer has been foiled by basing their tank husbandry on test results that proved to be inaccurate and as a result led them astray. With that in mind, every reefer should have a method for testing the important parameters that can't be inaccurate. I strongly suggest the following:
  • Tropic Marin High Precision Hydrometer
  • Tropic Marin High Precision Thermometer
Both of those require no calibration and are deadly accurate. The expectation is that they would be used to cross check and confirm the easier and more convenient methods, that trade convenience for margin of error.

For alkalinity, there is no test that guarantee's accuracy unfortunately. Using a quality test like Salifert will help though. Stay away from tests that are known to be problematic (like API).

Most importantly, don't be discouraged by the results with your frags. Almost everyone kills their first frags (unfortunately). Anyone can be successful in this hobby given enough patience and attention to detail. Stick with it you will get there.

Dennis
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%
Back
Top