Help I.D. Please

Dfrashid

Active Member
View Badges
Joined
Oct 17, 2022
Messages
260
Reaction score
152
Location
Hayward
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
It's some sort of sponge tho and can it affect calcium levels
20221219_223734.jpg
20221208_161626.jpg
 
Picture too purple to see, if it is a sponge it shouldn’t have a significant effect on calcium.
 
If it's a calcareous sponge (a sponge whose spicules - and by extension, skeleton - are made of calcium carbonate - taxonomic class Calcarea), then it would use calcium, and depending on how fast it grows it could potentially affect the calcium level in your tank. However, aside from pineapple sponges (genus Sycon), calcareous sponges are relatively rare in our aquariums (which makes sense since they make up up less than ~5-10% of all known sponge species at the moment).

So, odds are that they shouldn't use a meaningful amount of calcium, but there's a very small chance they may.
 
If it's a calcareous sponge (a sponge whose spicules - and by extension, skeleton - are made of calcium carbonate - taxonomic class Calcarea), then it would use calcium, and depending on how fast it grows it could potentially affect the calcium level in your tank. However, aside from pineapple sponges (genus Sycon), calcareous sponges are relatively rare in our aquariums (which makes sense since they make up up less than ~5-10% of all known sponge species at the moment).

So, odds are that they shouldn't use a meaningful amount of calcium, but there's a very small chance they may.
My issue isn't low calcium but high calcium I've even switched to a different salt type trying to lower calcium levels all my test are done with Hanna testers I can't seem to figure out how to lower my calcium levels the tank is 3 almost 4 months old now
 
My issue isn't low calcium but high calcium I've even switched to a different salt type trying to lower calcium levels all my test are done with Hanna testers I can't seem to figure out how to lower my calcium levels the tank is 3 almost 4 months old now
Yeah, you're not going to find any creatures that'll put calcium into your tank. From what I've heard, the Hanna Calcium Checker is one of the few that gets pretty bad reviews on it, so I'd say to get a second opinion on the calcium (either by testing with a different kit or by having your LFS test your water).

That said, you may want to ask in a different thread why your calcium is high (chemistry isn't my forte at this point, so I at least won't be much help there, but hopefully someone else will be).
 
Yeah, you're not going to find any creatures that'll put calcium into your tank. From what I've heard, the Hanna Calcium Checker is one of the few that gets pretty bad reviews on it, so I'd say to get a second opinion on the calcium (either by testing with a different kit or by having your LFS test your water).

That said, you may want to ask in a different thread why your calcium is high (chemistry isn't my forte at this point, so I at least won't be much help there, but hopefully someone else will be).
Thank you for all your help.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%

New Posts

Back
Top