Help ID Bam bam look alike

[SeanJ]

Can any help me ID this Paly? Initially I thought they were bam bams, but these are palys and look different than my bam bams (now that I can compare them side by side). See pic below.

 

[Sobo's Reef]

Look like Bam Bams to me

 

[SeanJ]

Thanks! I'm still boggled by their size and the 'pinkish' color in the middle.

 

[Sobo's Reef]

When I had bam bams they're weren't big nor were they small. Right in the middle. But yeah it had the Orange middle and orange skirts. Do you have a picture of the other ones you have in the tank?

 

[SeanJ]

Im about to post a pic of the confirmed bam bams first, and then the unknown.... under day light

 

[SeanJ]

Bam bams

 

[SeanJ]

Unknown

 

[SeanJ]

Look at the more pinkish color in the center and the more vivid purple. Both under the same light, btw.

 

[Sobo's Reef]

I would go with the opposite, "confirmed" ones are unknown and vice versa. If I walked in and saw these, I'd say the 2nd pic are def bam bams

 

[SeanJ]

I would go with the opposite, "confirmed" ones are unknown and vice versa. If I walked in and saw these, I'd say the 2nd pic are def bam bams

I think you're right. Thank you for your help! Still 'new'to this. Less than a year.

 

[Sobo's Reef]

I think you're right. Thank you for your help! Still 'new'to this. Less than a year.

No prob, that's what we're here for!

 

[Bowlopho]

Looks like my bam bams. Your original colony looks like it's lacking something. Hopefully your new ones don't fade in color as those did