Help me diagnose my coral (bleaching?) issue

Scott.h

Valuable Member
View Badges
Joined
Feb 21, 2016
Messages
1,460
Reaction score
840
Location
Clio Michigan
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
I'm obviously missing something.

Long story short I got rid of a wet dry trickle filter because I had nitrates around 20 ppm, phosphate .25 ppm. My only apparent "problems". Built a refugium. A month later API test show zero, but salifert shows much higher still. 40? Salifert Color charts suck. So 2 weeks ago I started vodka dosing. Which I'm assuming could be a problem, but I'm going slower than recommended. Total water volume approximated at 85 gallons. I've worked my way up to 8/10 of a ML splitting that into two doses per day. My water looks clearer but my nitrates haven't budged a bit. and now I'm seeing what appears to be coral bleaching. I still have the original coral issue, a pagoda cup coral that isn't dead but won't open. Hence the start of everything I've learned and done. I have some corals doing better then before, but now some less then stellar.

All that aside I've put an RO water system in now, added a grounding probe, I'm testing parimeters daily, every level in my tank has been perfect for 2 months from what I see with two tests kits aside from possibly elevated nitrates. But still having issues. I'm at a loss.

This bleaching I'm convinced Has to be attached to one of three things. The vodka, stripping more nutrients out of my tank than what it was used to because of the refugium and the vodka, or possibly muriatic acid dosing to drop my Kh to a more desirable level of 9. I'm Talking a few cc's a week in my water change container two days prior to my regular weekly water change.

The polyps on the rocks are very thin and white. They used to be green. image.jpeg

Any thoughts?
 
Last edited:
my other problem Coral has been moved to the refugium in case the problem started from a fish picking at it. image.jpeg
 
In what time frame did you make all these changes? Reefs thrive off of stability. Something that has no effect on one coral can snowball on a different coral already stressed from another variable.

It seems like you have everything headed in the right direction but sometimes to quickly of a positive change can be detrimental. My pagoda is extremely slow growing, and takes a long time to adjust to a new spot polyp wise. The recession in yours worries me though. What kind of flow did you have it in and is it moved often?
 
In what time frame did you make all these changes? Reefs thrive off of stability. Something that has no effect on one coral can snowball on a different coral already stressed from another variable.

It seems like you have everything headed in the right direction but sometimes to quickly of a positive change can be detrimental. My pagoda is extremely slow growing, and takes a long time to adjust to a new spot polyp wise. The recession in yours worries me though. What kind of flow did you have it in and is it moved often?
image.jpeg I bought the pagoda dec 26th. Within 3 days all the polyps were inside so I moved it to an area with less flow, less light, more light, and so on. Took some water to the LFS. Nitrates 20 and cal 360. So I a adjusted accordingly over the next few weeks. Stated testing for magnesium.. And everything else I never used to. That's when I built the fuge. Just shy of two months ago.

I've had the pagoda in my sump for 6 days. I don't want algae to start growing on it, but it looks like the polyps are protruding more then the were in my display, I think? This pic is from a week ago.
 
Also this is what my polyps looked like after my tank was going for a few months vs what's happened over the last month or so. Looks like they are dying. image.jpeg image.jpeg
 
Ah, yes I see a little bit of polyp extension now, compared to that earlier picture. If it is showing a positive response give it time, my pagoda can take months to open fully if I move it or change the flow or lighting, especially if there is another stressing factor in the tank. Keep an eye on those spots of bare skeleton, keep the algae off it.

I wouldnt worry about your palys, you cleaned your water up in a hurry, give them time, they'll come back brighter than before they pailed out.


WP_20160226_003.jpg
 
Cool that looks good. Odd you'd think after a month things would acclimate. I guess there's nothing left to do but wait. I just didn't want to keep doing something if what I'm doing is incorrect
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%
Back
Top