Help - my cleaner crew is dead

  • Thread starter Thread starter tstag
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users None
When you say you switched of the bio pearls, did you then remove them from the tank? or just leave them stationary.
I left the pellets in the reactor for a couple of days and then pulled them out, wasn’t very long
 
Given my nitrates are low to non existent I’m wondering if avoid another water change but switch on the carbon reactor to try and get rid of any pollutants. Or do I do a 50% water change which will hit nitrate recover even harder, wait for nitrate levels to come up and the phase the carbon reactor back in?

I hasten to add the algae is going mad and the corals may be looking a little bit better
 
Sounds to me it was the acclimation, 30 minutes is quite fast, best to drip them over an hour or better 1.5h,then check temp is correct, you need to make sure the shop water is near enough fully replaced with your tank water over a long period before adding to the tank? Just adding a little tank water to the bag a few times over 30 minutes is not going to get the salinity, ph and alk to match your tank, inverts need a slow acclimation,!fish are not as delicate.
No evidence of a pollutant killing the cuc.
 
copper?
is the algae actually brown stringy bubbly dinos?
 
Do you think it could be the fact I washed the filter socks with a capful of bleach. I put them in at a high temp and tried to wash it out over a couple of cycles. It’s really the only pollutant I can think got in. I feel like I’m clutching at straws with it....
I’ve been doing that for three years so far so hopefully it’s not the bleach! Hahaha
 
Given my nitrates are low to non existent I’m wondering if avoid another water change but switch on the carbon reactor to try and get rid of any pollutants. Or do I do a 50% water change which will hit nitrate recover even harder, wait for nitrate levels to come up and the phase the carbon reactor back in?

I hasten to add the algae is going mad and the corals may be looking a little bit better
What’s your pH and what kit do you have for that? Sorry if you already answered I didn’t see it lol.
 
I watched shrimp instant die in a friends tank....tons of testing then found he was at like 7.3-7.5 pH most of the time. Coral and fish were mostly ok (some coral losses for no reason over time) but she could never have shrimp or snails until we fixed her pH.
 
Are you using RoDi? Didn't see it asked yet. If using tap water copper may be building in your system.
 
Sounds to me it was the acclimation, 30 minutes is quite fast, best to drip them over an hour or better 1.5h,then check temp is correct, you need to make sure the shop water is near enough fully replaced with your tank water over a long period before adding to the tank? Just adding a little tank water to the bag a few times over 30 minutes is not going to get the salinity, ph and alk to match your tank, inverts need a slow acclimation,!fish are not as delicate.
No evidence of a pollutant killing the cuc.
That doesn’t explain why the snails that were already in there died.
 
I lend more towards acclimation too. I aire on the side of caution with inverts and drip acclimate at a steady one drop per second flow for up to 3 hours to give them the best chance to become accustomed to my tank.
 
Filter socks require no bleach or soap. I simply place in washer on warm cycle and wash in warm water Only and clean as a whistle.
Tank age does not help as there will be little food source for them.
Zero readings tell me that you are likely using API test kits which are notorious for false readings and your levels are likely higher without your knowledge. In this instance, take a water sample to a trusted LFS that does NOT use API test kits and have them test for you to see what readings they come up with.
Acclimation for snails is VERY important. How did you acclimate/introduce them to the tank and for how long before releasing them?
 
My socks soak in a bleach solution after removed until washing time. Then get double hot extra rinsed with a half cup of vinegar. I doubt that’s it. I also float and plop everything I get and have never had an acclimation loss except for 1 fish I dripped. I know that isn’t the norm, but that’s what my experience has been. I get things in the tank ASAP. Not saying to do that, but that’s what works for me. I’d bet your salinity is off. I bet you’re hypo, but that is a bit of a WAG.
 
Can you provide a picture of your entire setup? Will help to tie in all info given.
 
Ok so the plot thickens. I went to pull the dead snails out and found they are alive, just not moving much. Now I’m completely confused
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%

New Posts

Back
Top