Help out the Hawaiian Fisherman

reefcleaners

Active Member
View Badges
Joined
May 15, 2008
Messages
470
Reaction score
427
Rating - 100%
3   0   0
You have probably seen threads here and articles in other magazines about the aquarium fishery in Hawaii and how it faces shut down. I know people have mixed feelings about wild caught species, but let me just share my perspective as a fisherman in Florida.

The aquarium industry in FL is heavily regulated, and it has worked. The ocean is a commons, and if fisherman are left unchecked we could deplete it with wasteful fishing practices. Regulations solve that. Bag limits, gear limits, all keep fishery populations sustainable. Not just in the aquarium fishery, we also ban gill nets that have disastrous effects on the ocean. I think all of that helps. No species regulated by FWC is in permanent decline, or at the risk of extinction. Nearly all species that were a concern have now rebounded. Perhaps Hawaii can follow that middle ground solution instead of closing it down.

It is true, I have noticed some massive decline in populations of certain aquarium species where I dive - mostly local changes in the population. I also have seen many rebounds. From any given year Yellow Atlantic Tangs in my area can be numerous with hundreds to be seen, and then I can not see them for a year or more. These aren't species I collect, they are being pushed out (and possibly killed) by run off and weather events (which often cause massive runoff).

If you love the ocean and want to do the most you can to protect it, please tell our local leaders to stop dumping so much wastewater in the ocean. (Pretend you are one of their constituents, they care about votes. :)) I used to see fields with hundreds of thousands of acres with macroalgae, until some runoff caused a cyano bloom that wiped it out entirely. In FL, fast growing cities dump untreated wastewater in the ocean, and when it rains it goes right out to sea because we drained the swamps and we have houses there now.

Other times declines are the direct cause of weather. Sometimes heavy wave activity covers their food with sand and they move on. Fish don't wait for conditions to be favorable to them, Tangs and Surgeonfish are especially nomadic. The freeze we had here in 2009 killed millions of zoanthids, anemones and tropical fish that washed up on the shore for weeks. I saw more dead seahorses in just one mile stretch of beach that year than the entire FL fishery collects in a decade. The aquarium fisherman has nothing on mother nature, pound for pound we take the least from the ocean compared to all other fisheries. We might not like to think of it this way, but our pets are at the bottom of the food chain in the wild. The good news is as a result, they tend to be prolific breeders.

At least in FL, the real threat isn't fisherman. It is likely the same in Hawaii, or it could be made that with regulations. I don't want to judge a place I have never seen. I know lots of fisherman though. We do this job out of love and respect for the hobby and the ocean. You can't spend so much time in the water unless you love the ocean, we get wet everyday. I don't know a single aquarium fisherman who isn't a complete nerd that gets all giddy when they talk about those rare species they come across out there etc... We can be worked with.

If I were in their shoes I would want one of them to share their experience, so I thought I would share mine. There are usually other factors that affect fisheries far more than the aquarium industry, aquarists shouldn't accept blame that isn't ours.
 
Last edited:
Good read
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 30 44.8%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 13.4%
  • No.

    Votes: 25 37.3%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.5%
Back
Top