Help- VERY loud overflow - see pics

ForTheLoveOfCoral21

Well-Known Member
View Badges
Joined
Apr 26, 2020
Messages
658
Reaction score
1,242
What state or country do you live in
New York
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Overflow is very very loud.
How do I stop the gurgling sound?

A4F7F5AE-1602-41D8-AA8B-E1FB4FB42D4F.jpeg 362EFBF3-381B-4774-BB94-5989935F3A65.jpeg
 
I'm not sure looking at pics, but, main pipe in overflow is low, which is good thing, but main drain pipe require valve to fine tune amount of flow, and by reducing flow, you raise water level in overflow box.

If you dont have valve on main drain line, you can take longer pipe and replace it, so that water enters pipe at higher level in of box.
That is not ideal solution!

Another poor solution is to reduce pipe diameter with coupling, maybe some guard etc, for example, if pipe is 1", to reduce it to 3/4 or 1/2.....

Also, dont see if this is only drain pipe, if so, all of this is very dangerous without second drain line, or even third emergency drain.

Tell us bit more about overflow configuration.
 
1) Open You Tube
2) Copy this, Herbie vs Bean Animal vs Durso overflow.
3)
Paste into You Tubes search bar.
4) Watch videos. You will be up to speed in no time.
PS. There are no dumb questions, just learning opportunities.
Reef on.
 
I think I've posted on similar scenarios about a million times already, but I'll do it again because why not. You can use a gate valve on the primary siphon line to raise the water level in the overflow box and quiet the drain to some extent BUT, seeing everyone for some strange reason thinks their tank needs three 1" or larger drains regardless of tank size and return pump flow, it's always going to be noisy no matter how much you try to "tune it" with a durso pipe, silencers or adjusting gate valves. I've seen probably a few hundred tanks in person and WAY too many people do exactly this, yet swear up and down how quiet their tanks are...even if it's only because the skimmer or wavemakers are so loud that they at least distract away from the constant gurgling noises, or the person has a dedicated "fish room" or garage that houses the sump and moves a lot of that noise some place else. I prefer to address the issue and not just mask it. The way you build a quiet drain system is by trying to fill the primary siphon drain pipe as much as possible, while displacing as many rising air bubbles coming back up the line from the sump as possible and then have your secondary, typically durso drain pick up the slack, which hopefully should be barely any remaining water flow. The problem is, if your return pump is only sending 500gph of flow to the display and the 1" primary full-siphon drain that handles around 1,700 gph fully open, there's going to be a vertical air gap along the entire length of that drain to "waterfall" directly into the sump. You can use a gate valve to reduce the flow BUT, the volume of the drain STILL won't be filled to prevent a large air pocket from forming the the pipe and you'll STILL have "waterfall" noise. If i'm correct and you're building a drain system for a 50g tank, you want a 1/2" - 3/4" primary siphon drain. A 1/2" will pair well with a return pump that will flow up to 450gph into the display (you have to calculate head height for this). A 3/4" will work good with a return pump that flows up to 800 gph. You'll still have to use a gate valve, but instead of having to close it 99% of the way with a 1" drain, you can have the 1/2" line's open halfway or more, which helps purge air out of the line past the gate valve and back into the sump. Between the primary and secondary lines, you'll have plenty of safety margin just in case something clogs and for the emergency drain, make it as large as you want because it should only operate as the name implies and hopefully be noisy enough to get your attention, which will especially be the case if your other drains are dead-silent. I personally ran a 100g mixed reef with 450gph return pump flow going to the tank. My drain sizes were 1/2", 3/4" and 1". It was nearly as quiet as a siphon overflow box setup and you'd have to stand a foot away from the drain and listen carefully to be able to notice it. I "stress tested" it numerous ways including creating clogging scenarios and simulated power outages and never had a situation where the secondary drain couldn't carry the entirety of the flow, especially when its little siphon line became submerged.
 
Last edited:
Judging by the pic, problem isnt noise from water coming from of box, problem is water coming into of box.....

And that problem is solved with raising water level in of box.....
 
In that type box, slow water draining out via a gate valve, which will increase water to just below the emergency drain and she’ll run silent.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%

New Posts

Back
Top