Help with cycling

tee1172

Community Member
View Badges
Joined
Feb 1, 2020
Messages
32
Reaction score
75
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Hello, I’m confused and on Facebook I’m getting so many different answers. I started cycling my Biocube 32 on May 25 with about 25 lbs of Caribsea life rock shapes, 20 pounds of Caribsea live sand and a bottle of Dr Tim’s. On the 26 I added some Fritz ammonia chloride(about the end of a house key) I’ve been doing water test and I saw on Dr Tim’s where you need to add ammonia to 2ppm and when ammonia shows on the test to drop to 0 in 24 hours your tank is cycled. Mine was taking about a day and a half to go to 0 so on Wednesday night I put a bottle of Bio Spira in the tank and added some ammonia to 2 pp because my ammonia was at 0. Well my ammonia dropped in 24 hours to 0 but my nitrite was still at .25 yesterday. This morning I did a test and my ammonia is zero and my nitrite is zero, I didn’t add ammonia yesterday. Am I good to do a water change and add fish? It will actually be probably another week until I do add fish but I’m so confused.i will attach a pic of my test from June 6, June 12 and June 13 in that order I hope.Thanks in advance

31AB7618-2329-4E2E-A997-D4886ED19B00.jpeg 0115DE3D-4946-4077-A733-708ACC0063AA.jpeg FB1741C7-55AE-44E3-93F1-EAAC42086726.jpeg
 
your cycle is done, here's why, and what's making it hard to confirm:

liferocks self activate/painted on bac within about 10-12 days, per site.

wet sand=brings in nitrifying bac too

redundant bottles of bac, Fritz has already been tested to cycle a tank in 24 hours (where changing all the water, and redosing ammonia, still oxidizes=proof of cycle)

reason testers make it hard: you're using old cycling rules and guess testers.

new cycling rules: only ammonia matters not the other two, kick them out altogether

where ammonia is being measured, to not use seneye (a $300 meter) is to totally guess, you can't use that tester above to search for zero ammonia, since ammonia converts in the thousandths ppm in all reefs with rocks and sand and no dead fish wedged in the rocks. that tester can't read thousandths ppm, on the card it says zero. we think they register a fraction of free ammonia as they try and indicate this natural conversion, but overreport it.

You'll have to assess your cycle using other means. given the timeframes above, you're cycled, you'd change water and add some life and it lives, because your tank is ready. no matter how you slice, dice, adjust lighting, doesnt matter-API is not seneye. your tank is ready.

all you do is change out your wastewater, its algae fuel, makes uglies get ugly even faster.

input some reef life into the tank with clean water, and they all reef normally day to day. thats how you confirm a cycle when seneye isnt avail.

if determined to use that tester, you still could. spike liquid ammonia until that goes up one tiny color level, NOT 2ppm just one color block up from where it sits right now which is calibrated zero.

dose up

then in 24 hours itll lessen just a bit/down, might even take 48 hours since this isnt seneye. the move down within a couple days re proves what we already know due to submersion timed cycle studies. and ten thousand fish-in cycles.

not everyone agrees painted on bac/liferock is real/works

guess what we're missing to make that claim? a smidge of proof testing. Until then, its 2020 if you want to paint bac or ship it to me in a bottle, Im not amazed. we are heading to Mars, man. some water loving bac in dormancy cast around in different ways is not mindblowing.

Our own cycle testing can't confirm/disconfirm liferock activity since so many side sources of bac are mixed in, namely wet sand already claimed to carry bac (we know bottle bac works by testing, would bottle bac placed into a plastic bag with wet sand die? I think not)
 
Last edited:
Seems cycled to me if ammonia dropped to zero twice. Some may quibble with the "fully" cycled term, but good enough for early organisms.

Hello, I’m confused and on Facebook I’m getting so many different answers.

Facebook may not be a good place for chemistry advice. lol
 
Seems cycled to me if ammonia dropped to zero twice. Some may quibble with the "fully" cycled term, but good enough for early organisms.



Facebook may not be a good place for chemistry advice. lol
I know that is why asked asked here too
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%

New Posts

Back
Top