Help with ID

Hawkaholic

Active Member
View Badges
Joined
Mar 8, 2022
Messages
123
Reaction score
61
Location
SW Kansas
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
9D03459E-6856-4F35-97EF-4BF8544DD5DA.jpeg

Any idea what this is? I found about 10 of them stuck between two rocks. At first I thought it might be bubble algae, but they are all clear with that same big headed worm looking brown deal floating in the middle.
 
9D03459E-6856-4F35-97EF-4BF8544DD5DA.jpeg

Any idea what this is? I found about 10 of them stuck between two rocks. At first I thought it might be bubble algae, but they are all clear with that same big headed worm looking brown deal floating in the middle.
Looks like a syllidae worm know as autolytinae worm
 
Those look like tunicates of some kind to me - the worm thing in the clear ball is basically the organs of the tunicate. It’s hard to tell in the pics, but the first pic looks like the ball may have (or be forming) two openings (siphons) on the right side, and in the other pic showing multiple of them, it looks like a couple of them near the middle of the pic (the one with the really shiny spot on the bottom of it, and the one two specimens below it) may have thin parts that jut out from the body. If the they do have little parts jutting out, then they may be just finishing up metamorphosis.
 
Last edited:
I pulled one off while doing maintenance and it was sticky to the touch (felt like an anemone). They seem smooth over the entire surface. It held its shape out of water.
 
I pulled one off while doing maintenance and it was sticky to the touch (felt like an anemone). They seem smooth over the entire surface. It held its shape out of water.
I would be very surprised if it’s not a tunicate. Some examples that look relatively similar:
If it’s a tunicate, then it’s harmless, so I’d leave it in the refugium personally.
Another tunicate photo to help decide:
1657284797401.png

Photo from here:
 
I would be very surprised if it’s not a tunicate. Some examples that look relatively similar:

They’re very similar to some of those. It looks different than the tunicates I’ve had, in that it has no openings. I squeezed one softly it had the firmness of a grape. Could be a tunicate, but I’m not sure how it filter feeds. -I put them right back where I found them after I finished drilling some holes in the top of the rock.
 
They’re very similar to some of those. It looks different than the tunicates I’ve had, in that it has no openings. I squeezed one softly it had the firmness of a grape. Could be a tunicate, but I’m not sure how it filter feeds. -I put them right back where I found them after I finished drilling some holes in the top of the rock.
Yeah, the openings can be really hard to spot on some specimens (there are a few species I’ve seen multiple pics of that I still can’t find the siphons on) - like I said, in the first pic you shared, if you look at the far end of the tunicate (the right hand side of the pic, opposite the brown insides), it looks like it may have or be forming the siphon holes (zooming in on the pic helps).

If they’re not adults yet and they’re just now undergoing metamorphosis, though, then the holes may not be formed yet - I’ve only seen the metamorphosis of one specimen of one definitely different species, so I’m not sure how long it would take for these to form the siphons complete the process.
 
Yeah, the openings can be really hard to spot on some specimens (there are a few species I’ve seen multiple pics of that I still can’t find the siphons on) - like I said, in the first pic you shared, if you look at the far end of the tunicate (the right hand side of the pic, opposite the brown insides), it looks like it may have or be forming the siphon holes (zooming in on the pic helps).

If they’re not adults yet and they’re just now undergoing metamorphosis, though, then the holes may not be formed yet - I’ve only seen the metamorphosis of one specimen of one definitely different species, so I’m not sure how long it would take for these to form the siphons complete the process.
It’s a poor picture. Hard to get a good one. The one I popped off was perfectly smooth. No openings yet.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%

New Posts

Back
Top