How long can fish/corals be in sub-optimal conditions?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Gopi
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users None

Gopi

Active Member
View Badges
Joined
Nov 19, 2014
Messages
419
Reaction score
86
Location
Raleigh
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Well...I'm in a pickle. I had to move fish and corals into temp holding containers over the weekend while floors were redone in our house. It was only supposed to be for a week....

Apparently the room where I had my reef (my new 90 gallon!!) will not be completed for another 2 weeks. There was some miscommunication with the contractor about the flooring for that room (tile) so I won't be able to set up my tank for a bit. This is a problem.

The fish (2 clowns, 2 diagonal bar gobies, 1 indigo dottyback) are in a 20 gallon storage container with some LR, heater and RW8 in the bathtub. The skimmer has not been up and running. My corals (all frag size) have been in 10 gallon tanks on the bathroom floor without "proper" reef lighting. One tank has all the reef tank corals: zoa/palys, anthelia, sympodium, 1 psammacora frag, euphyllia, toadstools, chalice, gsp, cloves, duncan- they got the strip light, modded AC70 and heater. My nano tank corals are in another 10 (sump from the reef tank) are are mostly mushrooms and rics as well as a couple small gorgonians. My macro algaes are also in one section of that tank. They have an RW8 turned down very low but no heater (will be going into a seahorse tank, room temp has been OK).

With water changes, I think the fish will be OK. I've been feeding sparingly. I'm concerned about lighting and corals. I could probably put my a 48in fixture over the 10s (I have a spare 2 bulb Coralife or the 4 bulb aquatic life) I suppose...but that might be a bit much given the shallowness. I also have a 12inch Wavepoint LED from the nano, but that would only cover one tank and would need to be propped on a lid of some sort because these are rimmed tanks.

I suppose I could also set up the 90 in one room and then empty it and move everything in a couple weeks but...that would be a huge PITA. I could also do the same with the previous 55 which I hadn't sold off yet...but also moving that back into the house, setting up and then tearing down is a pain. So...positive words and suggestions please?
 
This may or may not be a suggestion, but can you contact your LFS to hold your corals? And if they will, of course, thank them by buying something nice.
 
I'm buying the 90 from them... I, uh, wouldn't trust my corals there though (won't buy corals from them either...) My coral source is about 45 minutes away, they might hold them and the fish (since I bought them there as well...I would've bought the tank from them if they were in that business) but I wonder what's more stressful: getting packed up and acclimated to other water/lighting conditions and then repeat in 2-3 weeks or stay put.

I guess the upside is I have more time to plan out my sump, plumbing, and finish the stands...
 
I'm buying the 90 from them... I, uh, wouldn't trust my corals there though (won't buy corals from them either...) My coral source is about 45 minutes away, they might hold them and the fish (since I bought them there as well...I would've bought the tank from them if they were in that business) but I wonder what's more stressful: getting packed up and acclimated to other water/lighting conditions and then repeat in 2-3 weeks or stay put.

I guess the upside is I have more time to plan out my sump, plumbing, and finish the stands...
Either way they are going to be stressed. Especially if you upset their habitat a few weeks from now anyways, fish more so than the corals. If you have the ability to give the corals light, some light is better than no light. Sorry I'm not much help.
 
Some improvement in the situation. The company owner stopped by...(I had some issues with his workers) I pointed out my $100s in corals in the bathroom and said that's what was in the big tank in the kitchen. They are live animals and these are not the best conditions for them. He'll start the tile Wednesday and will work through next weekend until it is done. So, 1 more week in the bathroom rather than 2 or 3 or 4.
 
Some improvement in the situation. The company owner stopped by...(I had some issues with his workers) I pointed out my $100s in corals in the bathroom and said that's what was in the big tank in the kitchen. They are live animals and these are not the best conditions for them. He'll start the tile Wednesday and will work through next weekend until it is done. So, 1 more week in the bathroom rather than 2 or 3 or 4.

Oh good!
 
FYI ....... and if the situation ever happens again just purchase a Rubbermaid Stock Tank and put your skimmer and heater in, run the lights across the top. I've been running one for years as a frag tank and it gets no cheaper. I added a big Aqueon filter but you'd not have to .....

.
Noname.jpg
 
Last edited:
Back to the drawing board. I need to find a different installer to finish the job now... Critters seem relatively OK but I'm sure stressed out!
 
Wow I thought the owner was stepping to the plate and now out the door, sorry to hear that. I would say you don't need to overly stress about the livestock if you have had them a while, month or so. Once corals settle in they are very durable, more so than we give credit. Your fish plan is good, some rock, flow and temp control. Same for the coral but you do want some light. I'd put the two bulb fixture on it. If concerned it's too much can you build legs for it? Just a cut 2x4 would do it. Definitely don't want to make them try to adjust to new lights when not in optimal conditions. Big Dog has a good point with the stock tank. I had a temporary set up in a 150 stock tank for three years. Became rather permanent as a look down tank. I now keep one in storage just in case.
Gets some light on the coral, and go stress about an installer not your coral. Hope things go well for you, or better.
 
Last edited:
Thanks, Rob. I've had my critters from years to months. I did get lights on them last week. Everyone has been opening and coloring up. And... Two appointments for quotes when I get home from work tonight.
 
Oh no! What happened?

He was a no call, no show on Thursday. After starting to make inquiries about the where my tile was, he sent me an e-mail saying he had an emergency and would 'be in touch.' This is 10 hours after he was supposed to show. I'm feeling more confident about the contractors I had in for quotes today, but it may still be awhile before my tank gets going...Much more drama about what needs to happen to prep before the tile can be laid. (No big surprise, it's still at the store. Thankfully!)
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%
Back
Top