How Many reefers keep Angels in a mixed reef tank?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Emoney
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users None

Emoney

unregistered
View Badges
Joined
Oct 6, 2009
Messages
1,306
Reaction score
14
Location
Baltimore
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
I'm what you might consider to be a more "higher end" collector of different corals (mostly chalices, z-p's and SPS). I've always been fascinated with Angels but very scared to put them in my tank with a lot of expensive corals. I know people that have kept them (mostly in SPS tanks) . Was wondering if there are experienced hobbyist who keep Angels in a full blow mixed reef ? pros and cons? do's and donts?
 
I think the answers are going to leave you more confused than before. I have a Pygmy and Bellus in mine but the bellus is a planktonic feeder and the Pygmy is so small he can't do much damage. I can't think of a single angel species that at least one person hasn't had a problem with. I'm in the same boat as you. I want an emperor but i dont have the guts to go for it.
 
I have a Japanese Swallowtail Angelfish pair. They have been the perfect tank citizens.
DSC_0064.jpg
_DSC0022.jpg
 
I tried a pygmy angel. Was fine for a few months and then went hay wire and started to pick at my prized lps including plates, acan, chalices etc. You know the fish isn't worth it over the coral.
 
It really depends on your feeding and such. Ive had success with flame angels, coral beauties, lemon peel angels, the key for me was keeping them fed good. Plus when I have seen angles pick its been more on Zoas. But the Swallowtails are basically 100% reef safe.
 
I have a Japanese swallow tail in mine that is no problem at all
a6aryry6.jpg



Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
I have had a coral beauty for over year now with lps and sps corals and he never once bothered a single coral, just ate algae for the most part. But from what I was told when purchasing my angel was that its like rolling the dice, you never know how that particular angelfish will turn out. He told me, at least with the coral beauty, that some will get into the habit of nipping corals and some won't. Fortunately I haven't had an issue.
 
Ive kept flame angels before. always wondered why my sps polyp extension was very small..Once I got rid of the flame angel the polyps where long and wavy. I Have a 180gl 6' tank with plenty of swim room.. Just worried about them eating z-p's and LPS.. think the sticks will be fine
 
I, personally, wouldn't trust any dwarf angel in a tank with fleshy LPS. Mine would still eat them no matter how much I fed them.

This LPS was healthy, until the angels decided they liked it.

[video=youtube;_-Ma1xsjMTY]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_-Ma1xsjMTY[/video]
 
I am with you. Some angels are just irresistible. OTOH, the SPS dominated mixed reef is doing so well, I hate to jeopardize it. So, I got another tank for non-reef safe fish!! LOL!!! Blue face angel is in there now.
 
Last edited:
I've had a pygmy with no issues. None of the bigger ones though. I'm interested in the answers you get here. I'm setting up a 180g tank and would love to have some.
 
Wouldn't trade my regal for any coral. He/she is great and never even looks twice at sps,lps, zoas, clams. Loves some sponges each time I roll over a rock with them. I have more trouble with my foxface eating xenia.

I think its a matter of the gamble. If my regal started nipping to the point of destruction, well gsp is taking over my DT and I'm getting more angels. Good luck.

Country Boy using tapatalk on his EVO
 
The only Angels that are reef safe (as already mentioned) are from the Genicanthus genus. I am a huge fan of the Bellus personally. They show up on Diver's Den quite commonly.

Otherwise, from everything I have read, Flame and Coral Beauty's would be your next best bet. I have a Flame in my mixed reef, but only for a couple of months now so can't comment longterm.
 
Had...key word "had"...a flame back angel. It picked anything with flesh. My acans where always shrunken. After the angels departure, acans plumped.
 
There are certain LPS I wont keep. But for the most part my angels are behaved as long as I keep up my end of the bargain and keep them full of food.

025-4.jpg
 
I have at the moment
(2) Golden Angels
(2) Multi bar Angels
Red Sea Regal
Flame
Multi-Color
Venustus
(2) Flameback
(3) Bellus
And recently lost my mature Goldflake.

I have lots of zoanthids in the tank (probably over 1000heads) and on occassion with the Goldflake a I would lose a cluster - Usually Blue or Reds.

The pair of multibar do some picking at the SPS, but they do minimal damage and then move on. So occassionally I will find a coral with the tips nipped off, and then within a week it's healed over. I wasn't so excited when it was my Oregon Tort, but they nailed some tips and then left it alone and it's fine now.

Dave B
 
I have had an RTC hybrid resplendens/fisheri for 6 years, since it was a wee baby. I keep a mixed reef tank. I had a pair for about 3 years until my FoxFace nailed one of them and it died. Neither of the angels bother/ed anything. I don't keep super fleshy LPS though. I do have all sorts of Blastos, zoas, chalices, fungias, Rhyzos, Dendros and such. It was worth the risk to get two of Frank's babies at the time. I love the one I have left despite his punky attitude (as of the last 6 months he has tortured my Earli Wrasse into hiding most all day long...stressing him out terribly). Ahh well, such is nature's way. He doesn't bother corals and a little less polyp extension on some corals does not bother me in the least.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 30 44.8%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 13.4%
  • No.

    Votes: 25 37.3%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.5%
Back
Top