How much should I sell these for

[JosephM]

I have a few corals that I’m trying to sell because I’m overstocking my tank and need to be more picky and they don’t go with my scheme. I’ve never really sold corals and don’t know how much these will be worth. Thank you for any help
Mr. Miami chalice:

Toxic rim favia:

Sun god leptastrea:

Purple haze monti:

Teal crush monti:

Punk rocker zoas (8polyps)

USA palys (7-8 polyps, they morphed or something, not what it’s supposed to look like)

 

[JosephM]

Bump for some help

 

[dedragon]

IMO 10-20 for most, montipora 25-35, mr miami chalice i havent heard of, does it have lineage or a mother colony?

 

[JosephM]

IMO 10-20 for most, montipora 25-35, mr miami chalice i havent heard of, does it have lineage or a mother colony?

That’s reasonable. Around what I was thinking. I couldn’t find teal crush anywhere online not even from where I bought it so I didn’t know even a range. The chalice was bought off ASD, i don’t think it has lineage

 

[mdb_talon]

The Mr Miami would probably be most valuable, but honestly looks nothing like one. Not sure if just unhealthy or if it always been like that for you.

 

[JosephM]

The Mr Miami would probably be most valuable, but honestly looks nothing like one. Not sure if just unhealthy or if it always been like that for you.

It’s always been like that. It was a little more drab but it’s colored up after a couple weeks in my tank. Never had a chalice so can’t speak on health, it gets a tiny dust of reef roids when I feed everything else and I have no clue if they eat or how lol

 

[dedragon]

gotchu lol I literally just bought a chalice from ASD and got it today, hopefully it will be something in the future, they called it masterpiece chalice but their names change so much at ASD.

 

[dedragon]

notice how ASD used mr miami and didnt call it my miami coral. they made it different but confusing for the buyer

 

[JosephM]

It looks pretty close to what’s online just no as prominent green outer ring and of course the big difference in photo abilities

 

[JosephM]

notice how ASD used mr miami and didnt call it my miami coral. they made it different but confusing for the buyer

Mr Miami and Miami chalice actually look different. Mr Miami is more purple while Miami is blue

 

[dedragon]

problem is ASD drops their corals to half price or more most if the time so its hard to gauge their prices sometimes. mine was listed at 200 at first then dropped to 40 plus coupons added after

 

[JosephM]

problem is ASD drops their corals to half price or more most if the time so its hard to gauge their prices sometimes. mine was listed at 200 at first then dropped to 40 plus coupons added after

True true. Their live sales are wild but definitely hit or miss. Some are crappy pieces and some are pretty nice

 

[dedragon]

if it looks like the miami i think 25-40 is fair

 

[dedragon]

ugh dont i know it. sticking with tck and arc livesales in the future i think

 

[JosephM]

ugh dont i know it. sticking with tck and arc livesales in the future i think

Yeah. I have to say though, I did take part in ASD auction and got a lot nicer pieces out of that one. But my tank is almost fully stocked so I’m sticking to pieces I can see in person and high $$$$ ones lol

and talking about the pieces in trying to get rid of I might just sell it as a package deal for cheap to a club member local to get it off my hands lol

 

[dedragon]

thats nice to do especially for the newer reefers out there to get a great deal on well adjusted corals.
i actually posted earlier this week on the paly poisoning post about why i dont keep any zoa or grandis polyps (or any soft coral in general) but they sent me a freebie of zoa. not their fault and i cant get mad at a free coral but now i need to find someone to take it cuz i dont want it and my lfs wont take corals lol

 

[JosephM]

thats nice to do especially for the newer reefers out there to get a great deal on well adjusted corals.
i actually posted earlier this week on the paly poisoning post about why i dont keep any zoa or grandis polyps (or any soft coral in general) but they sent me a freebie of zoa. not their fault and i cant get mad at a free coral but now i need to find someone to take it cuz i dont want it and my lfs wont take corals lol

Yeah I like helping out people because i love when people help me out. Man I love me some zoas, got about 12 different types in my zoa garden

 

[dedragon]

lol im afraid of the zoa plus i have too many stony corals in the rocks that they can kill. Definitely look next week at the TCK sale, man have I got good things from them, $30 beach bum monti, 40 kung pao monti, got lucky with a $5 wildfire millepora, their sales are insane

 

[ReeferLou]

It’s always been like that. It was a little more drab but it’s colored up after a couple weeks in my tank. Never had a chalice so can’t speak on health, it gets a tiny dust of reef roids when I feed everything else and I have no clue if they eat or how lol

You would be surprised the feeders that come out of these Chalices at night. Try peaking after lights out - it will be worth it!

 

[mdb_talon]

notice how ASD used mr miami and didnt call it my miami coral. they made it different but confusing for the buyer

What they coined as mr miami is different than my miami.