How to get pistol shrimp out - urgent

JosephM

Valuable Member
View Badges
Joined
Nov 22, 2020
Messages
1,561
Reaction score
1,051
Location
Lincolnton
What state or country do you live in
North Carolina
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
I purchased the wrong pistol shrimp and need him out by tomorrow morning to exchange at fish store. He had his cave and I tried to lure him out but he never came out enough to get behind him. I tried probing in his cave with long tweezers hoping he would go out his exit hole, didn't work. I even tried completely removing the rock hoping he'd be in the sand below, NOPE. I guess he is in one of the holes. Any advice. I'd prefer not trapping because that's hit or miss and he might be too big to fit through hole of the water bottle. I have a breeder box ready to put him in until tomorrow but gotta get him out first.
 
I am not against taking the rock out. Would a quick FW dip get him out without killing beneficial life or harming him?
 
Make a plastic water bottle trap and fill it with a few rocks inside to weigh it down and some shrimp/silver side as bait. Place the trap near the shrimp’s cave. Turn all tank lights off and even cover it with towels if possible. Don’t disturb the tank until tomorrow. Shrimpy will come out at “night” to hunt food. With any luck it’ll be in the bottle before your deadline.
 
Make a plastic water bottle trap and fill it with a few rocks inside to weigh it down and some shrimp/silver side as bait. Place the trap near the shrimp’s cave. Turn all tank lights off and even cover it with towels if possible. Don’t disturb the tank until tomorrow. Shrimpy will come out at “night” to hunt food. With any luck it’ll be in the bottle before your deadline.
will he not get stuck if I put the rock back on the sand if he's in one of the holes? And I just put him in yesterday so he isn't comfortable yet with hunting at night. Only time I've heard his snaps was when I was trying to get him. Theres no way to cause him to evacuate the rock without harming him?
 
I purchased the wrong pistol shrimp and need him out by tomorrow morning to exchange at fish store. He had his cave and I tried to lure him out but he never came out enough to get behind him. I tried probing in his cave with long tweezers hoping he would go out his exit hole, didn't work. I even tried completely removing the rock hoping he'd be in the sand below, NOPE. I guess he is in one of the holes. Any advice. I'd prefer not trapping because that's hit or miss and he might be too big to fit through hole of the water bottle. I have a breeder box ready to put him in until tomorrow but gotta get him out first.
What do you mean by the “wrong” pistol shrimp. My experience says most shrimp will pair with most shrimp gobies if that is your concern. As to catching it, probably not going into holes in the rock. They can just essentially swim thru the substrate when trying to hide.
 
What do you mean by the “wrong” pistol shrimp. My experience says most shrimp will pair with most shrimp gobies if that is your concern. As to catching it, probably not going into holes in the rock. They can just essentially swim thru the substrate when trying to hide.
It's a bullseye pistol shrimp. Took the advice of my LFS instead of doing prior research. One of the few pistol shrimp that won't pair with gobies. I didn't know that. I guess I'll have to uproot all my rock and check the sand after
 
Not sure the size of your tank, but I have Yasha goby and a red banded pistol shrimp and a magnificent shrimp goby and a tiger pistol shrimp both in my 50 gallon no issues with all co-existing. If it’s a money thing, then that’s a different problem. Bullseye are pretty shrimp.
 
Joe don’t do it. Use the bottle trap. They can’t resist the smell of shrimp. And if you injure or kill him, your out $$. if he’s to big for a water bottle, get a small gator aid bottle.
 
will he not get stuck if I put the rock back on the sand if he's in one of the holes? And I just put him in yesterday so he isn't comfortable yet with hunting at night. Only time I've heard his snaps was when I was trying to get him. Theres no way to cause him to evacuate the rock without harming him?
Oh he’ll find his way out and i’m sure he’s hungry. Mine was out and about at midnight the same day I added it.
 
Not sure the size of your tank, but I have Yasha goby and a red banded pistol shrimp and a magnificent shrimp goby and a tiger pistol shrimp both in my 50 gallon no issues with all co-existing. If it’s a money thing, then that’s a different problem. Bullseye are pretty shrimp.
If it was a money thing I wouldn't have a Dracula goby and would've went with a YWG. The bullseye pistol shrimp prefers to live alone. I got a pistol shrimp just so they could pair up, I would rather go with a Randall's pistol that co-exists with the Dracula goby in nature.
Joe don’t do it. Use the bottle trap. They can’t resist the smell of shrimp. And if you injure or kill him, your out $$. if he’s to big for a water bottle, get a small gator aid bottle.
Hopefully I didn't kill him. They can dig their way under a rock through the sand right? I'm about to feed the fish then shut lights off early and bait two traps
 
If it was a money thing I wouldn't have a Dracula goby and would've went with a YWG. The bullseye pistol shrimp prefers to live alone. I got a pistol shrimp just so they could pair up, I would rather go with a Randall's pistol that co-exists with the Dracula goby in nature.

Hopefully I didn't kill him. They can dig their way under a rock through the sand right? I'm about to feed the fish then shut lights off early and bait two traps
Yeah, mine likes to “excavate” under my rockwork. Sand really isn’t a barrier to them.
 
If you do get in deep I recommend handling the tank in surgical disassembly order or you risk killing it via recycle. That sounds like a deep dive coming up, you won’t want to dive in without rip cleaning the tank and catching him when it’s parted out. Sure it might be ok without, but we are working in yet another thread where it wasn’t, cleaning always is safe and allows total access because we take the tank apart to clean it, that’s where you catch him.


it’s not hard to do, just strictly ordered.
 
If you do get in deep I recommend handling the tank in surgical disassembly order or you risk killing it via recycle. That sounds like a deep dive coming up, you won’t want to dive in without rip cleaning the tank and catching him when it’s parted out. Sure it might be ok without, but we are working in yet another thread where it wasn’t, cleaning always is safe and allows total access because we take the tank apart to clean it, that’s where you catch him.


it’s not hard to do, just strictly ordered.
care to explain further or link to instructions?
 
He is not dead from me taking out all the rock! Lights have been off for about an hour and a half with 2 traps set and he was nibbling on some food right outside of it along with a bristle worm. My dumb self switched from my phone flashlight to a super bright one and scared him away. I’ll check back on him in an hr. Hopefully I’ll have him out for tomorrow!
 
He is not dead from me taking out all the rock! Lights have been off for about an hour and a half with 2 traps set and he was nibbling on some food right outside of it along with a bristle worm. My dumb self switched from my phone flashlight to a super bright one and scared him away. I’ll check back on him in an hr. Hopefully I’ll have him out for tomorrow!
You will catch him. I have caught a many with a bottle trap. They cannot resist easy food.
 
Guess who got caught! Beautiful specimen I must say

0FC552A3-9C24-4502-BD81-47A659C0111F.jpeg 610A6F0F-047E-44C2-ADDD-E37EA36F52CD.jpeg
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 30 44.8%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 13.4%
  • No.

    Votes: 25 37.3%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.5%
Back
Top