How to make a Tank Last for 40 years with few problems

  • Thread starter Thread starter Paul B
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users None
Awesome approach!! Love it and have been doing it myself. However I can see many trying and failing.
With every system there are failures for one reason or another, why something as natural as can be would fail for somebody I am not sure. maybe because they tried to complicate a simple system and did't have the faith and trust in the first place. ;)
 
With every system there are failures for one reason or another, why something as natural as can be would fail for somebody I am not sure. maybe because they tried to complicate a simple system and did't have the faith and trust in the first place. ;)

I completely agree with you! Couldn’t have said it better.
 
I doubt the UGF traps any parasites, as a matter of fact I think parasites love UGFs and go to them to dance and hang out. The gravel is full of life all the way to the bottom glass because oxygenates water is always present. Very few people use those filters because they read silly things like nitrogen factory, crashing, global warming etc. Those people never used one correctly.
I also don't think it would do anything for metal accumulation.
But this might.

I absolutely love the bottles/ can, thats so sick lol
 
Keeping your reef sterile and unnatural sells more equipment/additives/controllers.

Yes, and medications, hospital and quarantine tanks. :p

maybe they are quaking in their boots and can't type.

I somehow doubt that. :rolleyes:

Awesome approach!! Love it and have been doing it myself. However I can see many trying and failing.

They don't do it right and think too much into it. Fish know how to stay healthy as long as we stay out of their way. :cool:
 
Hi Paul B.

I have come across a medication (branded conditioner by the producer) that kills the free swimming stages of the parasites (like ich, oodinum and other parasites with free swimming stage in their life cycle) - PolypLab Medic. I think it works by creating peroxide radicals in the water, which are well tolerated by the inverts and fish.
The theory is that the ich will detach off fish within 10 days of attaching to it and that if you dose this medication twice a day (early morning and after the lights go off) for at least ten days you should be able to annihilate an ich infestation.
Do you think this treatment could be made compatible with your immune tank method?

I used to quarantine, but delicate fish would perish in a quarantine tank and thrive if placed directly in the display.
I was thinking that placing fish directly in the display would give all the fish a chance to come in contact with the pathogen and using the medication would "re-sterilize" the tank of parasites, getting both immunity in the fish population and avoiding unpleasant outbreaks. This would be an acceptable compromise for me, liking your idea of a immune tank but not being brave enough to fully embrace it.
 
Do you think this treatment could be made compatible with your immune tank method?

I don't think so. My method relies on live parasites to keep the fishes immunity working. Killing the parasites would be counter productive. I would imagine you could use that on a fish before you added it to your tank as long as you don't keep it in the medication too long. My method ensures that there will still be parasites in the main tank so I assume the fish you are treating will still have some sort of immunity.
I really don't know if it would be helpful or hurtful.
 
Hi Paul B.

I have come across a medication (branded conditioner by the producer) that kills the free swimming stages of the parasites (like ich, oodinum and other parasites with free swimming stage in their life cycle) - PolypLab Medic. I think it works by creating peroxide radicals in the water, which are well tolerated by the inverts and fish.
The theory is that the ich will detach off fish within 10 days of attaching to it and that if you dose this medication twice a day (early morning and after the lights go off) for at least ten days you should be able to annihilate an ich infestation.
Do you think this treatment could be made compatible with your immune tank method?

I used to quarantine, but delicate fish would perish in a quarantine tank and thrive if placed directly in the display.
I was thinking that placing fish directly in the display would give all the fish a chance to come in contact with the pathogen and using the medication would "re-sterilize" the tank of parasites, getting both immunity in the fish population and avoiding unpleasant outbreaks. This would be an acceptable compromise for me, liking your idea of a immune tank but not being brave enough to fully embrace it.
IMO you could embrace Paul's method and keep something like PolypLab Medic as an emergency back up plan. Medic makes no claim to eradicate a parasite from the system. It will reduce the numbers available and prevent them from continuing to attack the fish for the period of time the product is used.
This product works almost exactly like Ozone. Instead of running ozone or a UV filter all of the time (which is what I would do if I were trying an immune system) this product could act like a temporary ozone generator to give your fish more time to build their adaptive immunity.
 
I am leary of products that kill something. Any time a product kills something, it also stresses the creature you are trying to keep alive. A parasite is an invert just like our crabs and shrimp, only not as cute or big.
My theory is that fish are supposed to live with healthy, spawning parasites and are very well equipped to live in harmony with them as they normally and naturally live carrying a few parasites every day of their lives.
We aquarists feel parasites are bad because they kill our fish. They kill our fish in an un-natural system that prefers parasites to the detriment of the fish.
All living creatures including us normally carry parasites. Removing the parasites is not normal and detrimental. Just look at the disease forum.
Quarantining fish or feeding them dry, bacteria and parasite free food doesn't hurt the parasite, but removes the fishes only defense against them by destroying their immunity. Fish and parasites are supposed to go together like platypuses and duck bills. Parasites have no effect at all on healthy fish with a functioning immune system. It is a much simpler system than what almost everyone does which is why we have a disease section on all forums. People with immune fish never have to go on those forums or buy medications. Diseases are a non issue for healthy fish fed the correct food.
 
Paul, Your methods aren't as crazy as some people claim. I've always drawn people's ire when I tell them how often and enthusiastically I add just about anything I can find in the ocean to my tank. I'll routinely head out to tidepools with my tiny net looking for food; the fish love it and it's definitely adding beneficial bacteria.

When I set up my latest tank last year I drew a lot of inspiration from your tank and methods, as well as some tweaks based on my own thought processes. I use a RUGF, have a larger sump/fuge than display and use NSW about 70% of the time. So far this is the most stable tank I've ever had and I'm loving it.

I think that just like with our own health, people hear the word "bacteria" and they imagine horrific little monsters; few people realize that the vast majority are benign, and there are as many beneficial types as harmful. A healthy balance is what I aim for; as in nature, it's when one type grows out of proportion that things go south.
 
Thank you for that post BigRed. It still boggles my mind that after 45 years of this hobby people still allow their fish to get sick using inside the box thinking that hardly ever works. It's common sense that fish and parasites go together and fish eat living bacteria and parasites with every meal in the sea. But when we try to change the way fish normally live, thats when we have problems.
I never worry about diseases or worry that my new fish eat as it never happens. Fish are very robust and hardly, if ever get sick unless we force them to live in a way we want them to live instead of the natural way they have been living since Star Trek started on TV.
 
Paul, Your methods aren't as crazy as some people claim. I've always drawn people's ire when I tell them how often and enthusiastically I add just about anything I can find in the ocean to my tank. I'll routinely head out to tidepools with my tiny net looking for food; the fish love it and it's definitely adding beneficial bacteria.

When I set up my latest tank last year I drew a lot of inspiration from your tank and methods, as well as some tweaks based on my own thought processes. I use a RUGF, have a larger sump/fuge than display and use NSW about 70% of the time. So far this is the most stable tank I've ever had and I'm loving it.

I think that just like with our own health, people hear the word "bacteria" and they imagine horrific little monsters; few people realize that the vast majority are benign, and there are as many beneficial types as harmful. A healthy balance is what I aim for; as in nature, it's when one type grows out of proportion that things go south.

Could you please give us the details of your RUGF and sump set-up? what substrate you use with the RUGF?.
 
Ramona, I don't have a sump. they were not invented when I started the tank they were not used. I use dolomite gravel. There is a powerhead inthe tank that pumps water to a DIY manifold. The 3 UG tubes go into the bottom of the manifold and go to the UG plates. About 150 GPH is pumped down each tube. It needs to be slow like that so it doesn't clog the gravel.
You can see my gravel here

 
Thank you Paul. Actually I've been reading your writings and i have to admit I've been enjoying very much; they are quite inspiring; I don't have 40 years but a RUGF is very tempting, I think I will give it a try (in a 9 g tank)? Dolomite gravel is nowhere to find, would you use CaribSea Florida Crushed Coral in these days?

BigRed set up his tank last year using RUGF and sump/fuge, it would be interesting to know more details about it).
 
I would use crushed coral. but as fine as rice, no finer.
Run it as slow as you can. Good luck, but don't tell anyone because you will be told it can't possibly work. :p
 
Last edited:
Thanks Paul. How deep would you suggest?
 
Paul B just to let you know I told
My wife she looked fat in her nightgown because of you and now she is eating ice cream....lol guess she didn’t care but I found it hilarious....I am with you 100% and although my methods are different because I didn’t start 40 years ago I agree with everything you said....I cycled my tank with live rock with decaying matter and added a few fish to begin with when the got ick I left them alone and the strong survived and built an immunity while the weak perished...I continued to add fish and most importantly ones that got along and were not of the same species...eventually added coral shrimp and a bunch of inverts...I have most LPS and softies....my tank has nitrates at around 50 ppm and my corals are fat and juicy and everything’s happy...the minute I tryed an experiment and slowly decreased my nitrates to what the people on
The forums say is good everything suffered I let it run that way for almost a year and nothing was ever that healthy when I decided to let it go
Back to the normal 50-60ppm all
The corals
Plumped
Back up....at the end of the day every tank is different but I seem to agree with your methods....you from Long Island? I grew up in West Islip currently living in Syosset...Where you getting these live black worms from?
 
Thanks Paul. How deep would you suggest?

2 to 3"

Vipete, if you use too many of my methods, people will laugh at you because most of them just can't work. :p
Of course my nitrates of 160 prevent me right now to keep most SPS corals but I have done that for a long time and am past that now. As a matter of fact, I am past so many things I am not sure exactly why I have a tank in the first place. :rolleyes:
I would like my nitrates to hover around 20 or 30 but if you have too many fish and you want to keep them spawning and immune, you need to feed them correctly. Many people feed dry foods which are easier on water parameters but leave your fish wandering around in a stupor fearing parasites and other diseases.
Dirt, bacteria, viruses and parasites are what fuels our systems and keep the bad things away. Many people will never realize that and will go through great pains to try to keep those things away.
To me a successful system is where all your fish that can spawn are spawning and all your fish live long enough to die of old age and never get any sort of affliction except for the occasional headache especially if they accidently hear Rap music. :cool:
 
Hi Paul, I got your book and am reading it as time allows. My tank is just a hair under a year old and after losing over half my fish to MV in June, I'm making the switch from frozen foods to more live. I don't feed flake, and only use pellets for the cuc--a few tossed in every few days. I have a good pod population, am culturing them and phyto for the mandarins and feeding brine shrimp I hatched. I'm going to try the mussels and clams and ween off the various frozen (in other words, mix it in to use it up-have a freezer full...). Haven't found any live black worms--place that sells them in CA had to close off production. I did get some freeze dried. I also picked up some Larry's fish food but am going to have to more finely chop it to use it.

I don't like the idea of medicating just to medicate, people or fish, hate prison style qt tanks and think they add stress. What I've done is set up a 20 gal observation tank, a small display tank with decorations, sand and a couple rocks. I adjust the stuff in it to what fish are in there and their needs. The OT is more to allow the fish to adjust to a tank, pig out on foods and fatten up and recover from shipping and the lfs setups which aren't always ideal. I just removed the 2 darwin clowns and barber shop goby after 5 weeks from it and added them into the DT. They had no issues so did not medicate. Maybe I'm setting myself up for more losses but I don't want a totally sterile tank as if something gets in there, it will be devastating.

I've been fretting about high nitrates 40-80 yet all my corals are doing pretty fantastically so am thinking I should stop. Even one acro has great PE. The new one not as much yet.

So on clams or mussels or oysters. If I buy them in the shell, can I remove them and freeze them that way? I don't want to shell them and would make my hubby do it <g>. What about buying them already frozen in the supermarket? Or raw oysters in a jar? Right now I have all small fish (chromis, clowns, goby, mandarins and scooter blenny, damsel, and another goby who is bigger) so I could blend them small and freeze in cubes?

Your style makes a lot of sense and something some of us noobs can aspire to!
 
Susan. Thank you for reading my book, it was fun writing it. I may read it again as I forgot what I wrote. :rolleyes:
I would not use those freeze dried worms or freeze dried anything unless you want to put some Selcon on it for some reason. LRS food is great and they do sell smaller particle food, I forget what it is called. I use it also.
You can take the meat out of the shellfish and freeze it but I find it is easier to freeze it in the shell then shave off paper thin slices. But whatever you find easier.
Don't use mussels in a jar because they have to sterilize them before they put them in the jar. You can buy them frozen and I assume they would contain living bacteria but it could have been frozen last year so much of the bacteria may be dead. I am guessing though. Fresh is always better but if you can't get it, get the best you can.
Your nitrate numbers are not that high unless you want to keep some of the more delicate SPS. LPS love those nitrate readings.
I don't like to tell things to Noobs because my methods are very controversial and many, OK all the people don't agree with me. You can find many of those people posting on the disease threads. :eek: (Only kidding)
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 30 44.8%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 13.4%
  • No.

    Votes: 25 37.3%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.5%
Back
Top