How to save this Acan? Please Help.

Solution is very simple; Stop doing water changes.

90's mentality should be long gone by now. With some light trace dosing and skimming you shouldn't have issues.

Why are you doing water changes in the first place?
 
Solution is very simple; Stop doing water changes.

90's mentality should be long gone by now. With some light trace dosing and skimming you shouldn't have issues.

Why are you doing water changes in the first place?
............ What you just said has contradicted literally everything I've ever been told by the most knowledgeable people I know.

no water changes = watch how fast a pico can crash?
light dosing = dude my elements are too HIGH
skimming = have you EVER seen someone with a skimmer on a 5 gallon? does one that would fit even exist?


Wow this is getting very frustrating.
 
............ What you just said has contradicted literally everything I've ever been told by the most knowledgeable people I know.

Who says they're right? You should meet new people. Here's some ellipsis for dramatic effect for you ..........................................................................

1) no water changes = watch how fast a pico can crash?
2) light dosing = dude my elements are too HIGH
3) skimming = have you EVER seen someone with a skimmer on a 5 gallon? does one that would fit even exist?

1) Wrong
2) INSTEAD, of water changes... isn't that proof you're doing too many water changes? Adding more elements than can be used, opposed to adding a very small manageable amount.
3) Many options these days, including sources other than skimmers --> ............................................................ (your favorite ellipsis)

Sounds like you're listening to people who are very out of touch with the hobby. Water changes aren't really needed with basic dosing, and can be detrimental to such a small tank. Furthermore, nutrients aren't bad. You are asking for help and refusing to listen to it. If you want to keep listening to people who are steering you in the wrong direction, nothing will change.

If you want to listen to marine biologists with immense knowledge and astounding tanks, try looking at Richard Ross.

Your problem is nutrients... NOT that you have them, but rather, someone convinced you they were bad. This is what I call 90's logic. It needs to be as dead as boy bands, because nothing seems to cause more problems to new reefers than listening to old outdated information from people who are out of touch with the hobby. 20-30 no3 is not only fine, it's a good range to be in.
 
Who says they're right? You should meet new people. Here's some ellipsis for dramatic effect for you ..........................................................................



1) Wrong
2) INSTEAD, of water changes... isn't that proof you're doing too many water changes? Adding more elements than can be used, opposed to adding a very small manageable amount.
3) Many options these days, including sources other than skimmers --> ............................................................ (your favorite ellipsis)

Sounds like you're listening to people who are very out of touch with the hobby. Water changes aren't really needed with basic dosing, and can be detrimental to such a small tank. Furthermore, nutrients aren't bad. You are asking for help and refusing to listen to it. If you want to keep listening to people who are steering you in the wrong direction, nothing will change.

If you want to listen to marine biologists with immense knowledge and astounding tanks, try looking at Richard Ross.

Your problem is nutrients... NOT that you have them, but rather, someone convinced you they were bad. This is what I call 90's logic. It needs to be as dead as boy bands, because nothing seems to cause more problems to new reefers than listening to old outdated information from people who are out of touch with the hobby. 20-30 no3 is not only fine, it's a good range to be in.

Even in a slightly mixed reef? I have a few sps, a pocillopora, montis, leptos. Also wouldn't no3 in the 30 range make algae an immense struggle? And are you really saying no water changes? I mean other people were saying minimal like 10% every 2 weeks, but none? And what skimmer or mechanism would you recommend?
 
should I still feed my fish every 2 days? I feel like I'm already feeding minimally everyone always seems hungry, especially my blenny.
 
I have nothing but SPS and run over 20+ no3 and po4 above 0.20 -- So does WWC, Richard Ross, Sanjay, and I think Paletta. Basically some of the people who made it possible for this hobby to exist as we know it. They have all long since left the "low nutrients" stuff behind. That is seriously some yester-year thinking.

I feed my fish 3-6x per day, and I make sure to feed way more than they can eat. It's done nothing but improve tank health. You do not want low nitrates and phosphates, corals need them (including SPS).

As for skimmers, there's the Tunze 9001, the IceCap N1, the Octopus H-50.

Other methods if you really care include chaeto or other algaes, or bio media. Bio media is extremely effective.

If you could hack it, i'd go with the octopus or Tunze. Otherwise, a HOB refugium with a small light and some chaeto will help you greatly. I am personally not a huge fan of refugiums because chaeto themselves need metals to be dosed once in awhile, or water changes. OR, even better in my eyes, do the same thing but with biomedia (Seachem Matrix, Siporax, etc etc) instead of algae.

Big water changes in a tank with little uptake is causing instability. If I remember correctly, somewhere you said you had 1700 mag? That is a STRONG indication that what you're doing is building up problems.

The issue with slowly building up problems is eventually it catches up to the corals, and they start slowly not being able to cope with these issues -- The whole time were stuck thinking "What happened? They were fine for months/years, they're dying for no reason!" -- The issue is they're dying for a lot of reasons, it just takes awhile for them to reach that point.

Water changes are probably the worst way to export nutrients. You've trapped yourself in a false narrative, thinking it's the only way. It's really not, and we can fix this easily -- I promise. You just have to let go of 'what you know', and be a little more modern. Again, I promise this can easily be solved.
 
Last edited:
I appreciate the info, I'm also going to pick up that coral book by Borneman.
 
I used to have the same problems too, certain corals kept dying and I did the good ol' "if there's something wrong, do a water change". Of course, it didn't work for me; in fact, it felt like doing a water change kept going downhill.

It was later that when I had a busy schedule, I did less WC and that's when things were rebounding. Now, I do a 10% WC every 2-4 weeks.

And if you don't beleive Rakie's advice, check out this post he made in the acan show-off thread:
https://www.reef2reef.com/threads/o...is-show-off-thread.32900/page-47#post-5493598
 
I used to have the same problems too, certain corals kept dying and I did the good ol' "if there's something wrong, do a water change". Of course, it didn't work for me; in fact, it felt like doing a water change kept going downhill.

It was later that when I had a busy schedule, I did less WC and that's when things were rebounding. Now, I do a 10% WC every 2-4 weeks.

And if you don't beleive Rakie's advice, check out this post he made in the acan show-off thread:
https://www.reef2reef.com/threads/o...is-show-off-thread.32900/page-47#post-5493598

Was yours a pico reef too? Similar size (5gallon)? It's currently 9 days since my last water change and the acan is looking GREAT (well.. too much algae but the coral looks happy). Tonight I'm going to test my elements and based off that I will likely do a small 10-20% water change. I'm also going to sell off my clown fish, and just keep my blenny and cuc in my tank. I think my bioload is likely the largest contributor to my imbalance. I'm hoping with my smaller bioload, less wc (25% wc every 7-10 days) will balance everything out.
 
This video is AWESOME, especially love the part about the titration tests! I'm VERY bad with seeing different shades of colors. Those 4 photos he posted I only saw numbers on 2 of them instead of all 4. lol
 
I'm not all knowing and have alot to learn but I would agree with others on changing the water. Water changes as a primary nutrient exportation is usually not the best and it can be quite expensive in the end. I usually change5% every week but as a way to keep calcium alkalinity and trace elements where I want them. I personally have had great luck with NoPox. I grow cheato as well and between the skimmer and the cheato I keep my levels where they need to be. If my nutrients start to get too high I just dose a little bit of NoPox and it will be significantly lower. If you drop everything to zero things will get mad for sure. Also I had a similar problem when I added a brain coral. My problem was that the substrate caused the ressesion as the coral was grown on a frag rack
 
Was yours a pico reef too? Similar size (5gallon)? It's currently 9 days since my last water change and the acan is looking GREAT (well.. too much algae but the coral looks happy). Tonight I'm going to test my elements and based off that I will likely do a small 10-20% water change. I'm also going to sell off my clown fish, and just keep my blenny and cuc in my tank. I think my bioload is likely the largest contributor to my imbalance. I'm hoping with my smaller bioload, less wc (25% wc every 7-10 days) will balance everything out.

The water changes are CAUSING your imbalance. Water changes are creating the problem, the problem IS the water changes.

You need to change the way you're thinking about things, as the main point everyone is trying to hammer home is being ignored.
 
Last edited:
The water changes are CAUSING your imbalance.

Yea we covered that, 50% water changes ever 4-5 days are CAUSING the imbalance, wouldn’t switching to 0 water changes right away be dangerous? Wouldn’t it be safer to ween them out or ween them to smaller changes/longer intervals of time? Excuse me for ignorance but I thought the golden rule of reefing was to go slow?

I had asked you to clarify whether you meant I should do 0 water changes or if you were meaning I should cut back, but I hadn’t heard a clear response. Even if you’re suggesting I should move towards not doing changes, are you confirming going “cold turkey” on ALL water changes is wise?
 
Last edited:
Also, I just checked my levels and all my elements after 9 days are identical.... seems odd. I can’t check for nitrates with these frickin AI strips wither 0-40 look the same to me. I also have no way to check for phosphates currently.

Everything in the tank looks incredible happy, but my glass algae is totally getting out of control. Any advice on that?
 
Yea we covered that, 50% water changes ever 4-5 days are CAUSING the imbalance, wouldn’t switching to 0 water changes right away be dangerous? Wouldn’t it be safer to ween them out or ween them to smaller changes/longer intervals of time? Excuse me for ignorance but I thought the golden rule of reefing was to go slow?

Water changes are fast, not slow. It will takes months and months of 0 water changes for the excess things building up to get used.

At this point. ALL water changes = bad. Stop doing them completely. It will only make things worse.
 
Algae on glass is a GOOD thing. You should have algae build up every single day. If you don't have that, your tank is not running properly.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%
Back
Top