I got a bta early and could use some advice now

Matt Miller

Well-Known Member
View Badges
Joined
Nov 20, 2016
Messages
877
Reaction score
424
What state or country do you live in
Ohio
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
I know I should've waited longer, but I have an impulse problem and grabbed a bubble tip during a live sale. It's been in my coral only qt 2 weeks now and it's been swelling up and down looking good till yesterday and today.

I think the light may be an issue but I'm looking for best chance to make it happy and stay alive.

I have 2 cycled tanks I can put it in now, a 20g cube with tons of snails 2 clowns and a firefish. This was supposed to be it's home but now there's an algae bloom in the sand. I have an AI prime on it so it's the best tank for it. I also have a 13.5 Evo that's cycled also, it's got hermits and snails and my fish just committed suicide through a tiny gap in the lid today

Bash me if you must, I'm just trying to save this thing. I feel like the cube would be best with the lights and it's been cycled longer I'm just nervous about the sand algae now. The smaller Evo has stock lights and a lot less going on right now.

Tia and sorry about the long post.
 
Whatever you put it in, ensure that tank has established live rock.
Most issues with nems are due to an immature tank.
Mature rocks will make it 90% better.

Next lighting and parameter stability is key.
If its not walking up towards the light....the light is likely ok.
 
Upvote 0
Whatever you put it in, ensure that tank has established live rock.
Most issues with nems are due to an immature tank.
Mature rocks will make it 90% better.

Next lighting and parameter stability is key.
If its not walking up towards the light....the light is likely ok.
The cube has been cycled about 4 months now, the Evo about 2.5.

I'm leaning towards the cube but considered the smaller Evo since the fish jumped and there's less hiding spots.
 
Upvote 0
The older tank is better. The more stable your parameters, esp alk, the better and that is why they do better in mature systems. Put it in the cube, get your alk stable and the nem should be ok. They are hardy and he will find a good spot for the light. But he does need a good light.
 
Upvote 0
The cube has been cycled about 4 months now, the Evo about 2.5.

I'm leaning towards the cube but considered the smaller Evo since the fish jumped and there's less hiding spots.
I would choose the most mature tank.
Even @ 4 months its a sub par enviornment tbh.
 
Upvote 0
Agreed with above comment.

Most 4 month new reefers dont completely understand the husbandry and chemistry of keeping stability.
Starting with established liverock can really help jump right into getting more sensitive animals imho.
 
Upvote 0
You are at a point where your tank will endure spikes and without your knowledge, the ammonia or nitrate or both can elevate real high then come back down and then by the time you test, it has reached near norms. Others stated- well established tank. THAT STATEMENT CANNOT BE EMPHASIZED. Shame on the pet store for throwing it in a bag and and selling it without asking questions such as age of tank, if youve ever had anemone before, suggested care, etc.
Impulse and rushing are the biggest enemies in this hobby and most hobbies and must be regarded and disciplined to resist any purchases which you know will likely not work out.
Your opening statement " I knew I should have waited longer" says you recognized the risk. Just something to keep in mind
Monitoring water quality, making water changes as needed and Adding .5ml of liquid bacteria daily per 10 gallons should hopefully get you through this.
 
Last edited:
Upvote 0
You are at a point where your tank will endure spikes and without your knowledge, the ammonia or nitrate or both can elevate real high then come back down and then by the time you test, it has reached near norms. Others stated- well established tank. THAT STATEMENT CANNOT BE EMPHASIZED. Shame on the pet store for throwing it in a bag and and selling it without asking questions such as age of tank, if youve ever had anemone before, suggested care, etc.
Impulse and rushing are the biggest enemies in this hobby and most hobbies and must be regarded and disciplined to resist any purchases which you know will likely not work out.
Your opening statement " I knew I should have waited longer" says you recognized the risk. Just something to keep in mind
Monitoring water quality, making water changes as needed and Adding .5ml of liquid bacteria daily per 10 gallons should hopefully get you through this.
I am a little frustrated with myself for making it this far and caving, it's been slow and steady till now. I've seen enough of these calls for help with nems so I really have no good excuse.
I won't have a problem keeping up with water changes and maintenance, and I'm not buying any more corals anytime soon.
The older tank is better. The more stable your parameters, esp alk, the better and that is why they do better in mature systems. Put it in the cube, get your alk stable and the nem should be ok. They are hardy and he will find a good spot for the light. But he does need a good light.
So I can definitely focus on keeping track of my alk and hope for the best.

Thanks for the tips and not just bashing me for a bad decision. I'm going to try like hell and hope it pulls through.
 
Upvote 0
I have another noob question.....will my all swing with no other corals in the tank? This bta will be the first in the tank.
 
Upvote 0
I have another noob question.....will my all swing with no other corals in the tank? This bta will be the first in the tank.
More than just corals use up alkalinity. Coralline algae, green algae, and loss due to precipitation all contribute to drop alk. Test it daily. To find out how much your system uses, test one day and exactly 24 hours later, test again. That will tell you how much you use and how much you need to dose. I use soda ash from BRS with an auto dosing pump I highly recommend it. I will provide you with links. Don't worry, I put a BTA in my tank too early, around the 6 month mark. I have an impulse problem too. It struggled for a couple months till I changed the light and got my levels stable.



There are directions on the link to the soda ash on how exactly to dose. And this is a link to a calculator that tells you how much to dose of soda ash to get to your desired level. I keep mine at 9 dkh. Hope this all helps.

 
Upvote 0
More than just corals use up alkalinity. Coralline algae, green algae, and loss due to precipitation all contribute to drop alk. Test it daily. To find out how much your system uses, test one day and exactly 24 hours later, test again. That will tell you how much you use and how much you need to dose. I use soda ash from BRS with an auto dosing pump I highly recommend it. I will provide you with links. Don't worry, I put a BTA in my tank too early, around the 6 month mark. I have an impulse problem too. It struggled for a couple months till I changed the light and got my levels stable.



There are directions on the link to the soda ash on how exactly to dose. And this is a link to a calculator that tells you how much to dose of soda ash to get to your desired level. I keep mine at 9 dkh. Hope this all helps.

Thanks but I think it died in my qt overnight
16173713281527053157424019653525.jpg
 
Upvote 0
yeah nems dont much care for QT tanks might just be IMO/E but i have found that having a QT tank that has a few pieces of aged live rock really help with nem QTs just make sure you never use those rocks in anything but a Nem QT cause of the possible chemicals and anti biotics you can put in there.
 
Upvote 0
You are at a point where your tank will endure spikes and without your knowledge, the ammonia or nitrate or both can elevate real high then come back down and then by the time you test, it has reached near norms. Others stated- well established tank. THAT STATEMENT CANNOT BE EMPHASIZED. Shame on the pet store for throwing it in a bag and and selling it without asking questions such as age of tank, if youve ever had anemone before, suggested care, etc.
Impulse and rushing are the biggest enemies in this hobby and most hobbies and must be regarded and disciplined to resist any purchases which you know will likely not work out.
Your opening statement " I knew I should have waited longer" says you recognized the risk. Just something to keep in mind
Monitoring water quality, making water changes as needed and Adding .5ml of liquid bacteria daily per 10 gallons should hopefully get you through this.
"Impulse and rushing are the biggest enemies in this hobby"
Just thought that should be said again. So true.
 
Upvote 0
"Impulse and rushing are the biggest enemies in this hobby"
Just thought that should be said again. So true.

More than just corals use up alkalinity. Coralline algae, green algae, and loss due to precipitation all contribute to drop alk. Test it daily. To find out how much your system uses, test one day and exactly 24 hours later, test again. That will tell you how much you use and how much you need to dose. I use soda ash from BRS with an auto dosing pump I highly recommend it. I will provide you with links. Don't worry, I put a BTA in my tank too early, around the 6 month mark. I have an impulse problem too. It struggled for a couple months till I changed the light and got my levels stable.



There are directions on the link to the soda ash on how exactly to dose. And this is a link to a calculator that tells you how much to dose of soda ash to get to your desired level. I keep mine at 9 dkh. Hope this all helps.

Thanks for this, I appreciate you actually trying to help me instead of just reminding me what I already admitted. I knew I probably messed up and hoped I could keep it alive.

I'm going to start monitoring my alk now because I will have bubble tips in this tank.
 
Upvote 0

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 30 44.8%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 13.4%
  • No.

    Votes: 25 37.3%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.5%
Back
Top