I hate my sump- need recommendations!

[HaveFishWillTravel]

I always like diy, super easy to cut acrylic to size and silicone in place, takes a couple hours to make (plus curing time) and made to your preferences. They also cost a fraction of the price of branded ones

So true. There are a lot of places in the Seattle Area to buy acrylic. TAPP Plastics is one of them. Designing and building yourself is always a great way to go. I was thinking that since she was looking to buy an entirely new setup that the RedSea is a good option. Mine is too small for a Refugium within the cabinet and the aquarium is in my living room so, there are a few visual constraints. JL

 

[dedragon]

lifegard aquatics plastic filter mesh makes amazing removable baffles/bubble traps, if anyone needed to add any extra sections to a sump they work so well

 

[SaltyB24]

My XL200 RedSea 50 gallon w/the 11 gallon sump below. EcoTech Marine Return Pump, Simplicity D130 Skimmer and RedSea controls to adjust flow literally makes no sound at all. If there is any sound, it comes from the water getting to high and going into the overflow which is easily remedied by adjusting it. RedSea makes a very nice aquarium. For ~$2,000, you can get a 91 gallon aquarium + sump + cabinet stand. Nice way to start out. Easy to get to sump.

I love the look of the RedSea aquariums but if my seams failed on a new tank and it burst all over my living room…. I would never hear the end of it ‍

 

[HaveFishWillTravel]

I love the look of the RedSea aquariums but if my seams failed on a new tank and it burst all over my living room…. I would never hear the end of it ‍

I have no idea where you are getting the idea that the REDSEA aquarium seal’s fail. They are solid. They don’t miter the corners for one. Depending on how large of the aquarium that you purchase, the glass is thick and has quartz in it for the best visibility. My 50 gallon has 10mm glass. It’s basically a cube and one of the best aquariums I have ever owned. The other really cool aquarium I had was a Starfire 120 gallon w/8mm glass. It was a beautiful tank. It had clear silicone mitered corners and I was way more worried about that one than the RedSea.
The issue comes when people put water in them and drain them and let them sit. The seals dry out over time. I would buy a REDSEA time and time again. I was just trying to tell you my experience. You will dugout what is best for you. With the REDSEA, the plumbing is in place, the cabinet is accessible and convenient. The display tank is remarkably clear and beautiful. It’s a great environment, for sure. Best of luck to you Reefing…! JL

 

[SaltyB24]

I have no idea where you are getting the idea that the REDSEA aquarium seal’s fail. They are solid. They don’t miter the corners for one. Depending on how large of the aquarium that you purchase, the glass is thick and has quartz in it for the best visibility. My 50 gallon has 10mm glass. It’s basically a cube and one of the best aquariums I have ever owned. The other really cool aquarium I had was a Starfire 120 gallon w/8mm glass. It was a beautiful tank. It had clear silicone mitered corners and I was way more worried about that one than the RedSea.
The issue comes when people put water in them and drain them and let them sit. The seals dry out over time. I would buy a REDSEA time and time again. I was just trying to tell you my experience. You will dugout what is best for you. With the REDSEA, the plumbing is in place, the cabinet is accessible and convenient. The display tank is remarkably clear and beautiful. It’s a great environment, for sure. Best of luck to you Reefing…! JL

I’ve seen quite a few people lately talking about it on other forums but I’m glad it’s not every tank and you haven’t had any issues!

I appreciate all your input! Thank you and happy reefing to you as well!