I have a little problem, any answers?

TX Twin Mommy · Mar 11, 2013

Hi. I'm new to the world of saltwater ownership. I did work in a pet shop about 22 years ago as an assistant manager, quickly moving my way up from caretaker of the many fish tanks she had in the store, both salt and fresh water. I did do all of the testing, cleaning, conditioning, medicating, upkeep and feeding. I've always had freshwater tanks ranging from 5 gallons to 55 gallons. I've always wanted a saltwater aquarium but I've always heard it's very difficult to get one started. I have a basic knowledge of them from my pet shop experience; but, the fear of putting all that work, time and effort into something for months and have it crash scares me to death! I've seen quite a few ads on Craigslist lately where people are selling saltwater tank set ups with fish, live rock, and everything included in the sale. Would this be a better bet for me to go with, something that's already up, running and established? I'm not sure if it's better for me to do that or just start out new. I know these things get extremely expensive when it comes to start up costs, supplies and especially fish! Please let me know what you all think. Thanks for your time in reading and responding! :~)

Kheebl · Mar 11, 2013

As far as going with a setup that includes fish I would personally not go that route because not only do you have to take the existing system down, transport it to your place set it up then acclimate the existing fish and possibly coral. You are guaranteed to have loses in the process. I would look for a setup that does not have any livestock that way you are not rushed into getting the tank setup and making a mistake causing a tank crash. You could always sell the fish to a LFS for a store credit and then when you are ready you could apply that credit towards your livestock purchase.

TX Twin Mommy · Mar 11, 2013

Thanks. I guess I'd have losses either way, but, that is a good idea. They usually have whole set ups (without the fish) on there too. I'll have to research that so I can do it at my own pace.

fragmatic · Mar 11, 2013

Nix the fish. They are getting out the hobby for a reason. You don't want to inherit their problems on top of the many things you will have to solve.
If you go Craigs you can save hundreds, but hold out for the tank, sump, refugium, and skimmer you want.

Eienna · Mar 11, 2013

The main thing, it seems, is to take your time and make sure you start with the right equipment. Grabbing substandard stuff to start with can cost you a lot more than you saved in the long run.

Eienna · Mar 11, 2013

This is true for both SW and FW, though in FW there are fewer things to consider and losses are usually less difficult and/or expensive to replace. Patience and research (and cycling!!!) are key for both.

CALI DIPPIN · Mar 11, 2013

Id go with a setup on CL but find a setup with the rock still alive youll save alot of money

Sent from my SPH-D710 using Tapatalk 2

Eienna · Mar 11, 2013

You could go with a CL setup, if the equipment is obviously doing its job well. I personally am planning to get my tank and stand (and possibly sump) off CL, but buy the other equipment - such as a skimmer - new unless I come across a great deal on a healthy setup.

revhtree · Mar 11, 2013

Hello and welcome to R2R!

We appreciate your membership!

Thanks for joining and please make sure and post often!

TX Twin Mommy · Mar 13, 2013

Thanks to all for your advise. I didn't end up getting the tank or supplies on CL. The local pet store gave me a good deal on a 60 gallon tank, stand, light, and supplies at a discounted price. They said to set it up, wait 2 weeks then bring them a sample of my water and they would test it. If it's okay, they will sell me 1 or 2 Damsels and some live rock to put in the tank to help "cycle" the system. Once they're in there for a couple weeks they said to bring them back to the store and they'll give me credit towards the fish I want to start putting in there. They said you can't leave Damsels in there because they get very territorial and will attack the new fish. Now I guess it's just a waiting game....

Nails12 · Mar 13, 2013

Agreed, moving the tank and it's inhabitants you will have loss. Also I like knowing exactly what I am putting in my expensive tank. I dont want any pest or parasites that are on the rock that the previous owner may have.