I just cannot catch a break in this hobby!!!!

Macdaddynick1

Valuable Member
View Badges
Joined
May 20, 2014
Messages
1,790
Reaction score
2,307
Location
Reseda, California
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Before I can tell you guys the immeasurable level of frustration I am feeling right now. Here is a little background.

Chapter 1: I used to consider myself to be pretty good at keeping corals. I use to have a tank stacked full of SPS which I grew from frags. Anything I put into my tank would just grow. At one point I found out that my tank has flatworms, I think I've had over 100 colonies at that point. Well, that didn't stop me, my SPS still grew substantially even with the flatworms. One day however, my tank just started crashing. For the life of me I could not figure out what it was. I decided to do an ICP test and check what was going on with it. Well NOTHING was going on with it. The parameters were great and stuff was just dying. The beautiful retracted skin of the SPS was receding deep inside of the skeleton. I watched and admired on how hours and days of my life that I spend on this tank were dying before me. Eventually I though my problems were caused the lack of nitrates. Long story short, stuff died ... the end.

Chapter 2: My tank was bare for a few months, as I had no intentions of restocking it until recently. Meanwhile, Dinos hit my tank. Well I didn't freak out. I just put on a UV on my tank, started feeding a lot and dosed nitrates. Long story short, I beat Dinos. I decided to try to keep my nitrates above absolute 0 to avoid another crash. Well after the Dinos algae started growing everywhere, (honestly forgot the name of it). After looking for a solution for quite a while I finally picked up a few halloween urchins. The urchins took care of the algae in no time. Great!... well not really.

Chapter 3: Since there was no more regular algae to compete with, here comes the Bryopsis. Here's where there fun really begins. t this point I have some of my collection back. I dose NO3 to keep it slightly above 0 for my corals, but it causes the bryopsis to go crazy and grow in days, my nitrates drop to 0 again. I spent every weekend taking 99% of it out, tank looks great. I dose nitrates to get them above 0, here comes more bryopsis. A few days ago my calcium reactor pump stopped working, I didn't catch it until it was at about 6.5 (usually that is not a big deal for my corals, and I raised it a bit, polyps were still out and corals looked OK. ).
Being tired of constantly fighting Bryopsis I decided to do some research on flucanizole. I read that wonderful Flucanizole/Bryopsis post, ALL 280 pages of it. Finally after hours of reading, I decided to dose 7 pills into my tank. As I was preparing my mixture, I was thinking to myself, all of the corals are going to die, they will definitely die, I should probably just live with Bryopsis. Well I decided to dose it anyways, and yet again, all of my corals are dying. Bryopsis looks good though. I was genuinely considering tipping my tank over when I got back from work. Anyways, this post probably has no other use than for me to vent to you guys.

Thank you for reading.
 
Sorry man! I totally get it. My husband and I went through this 15 years ago, which is why we completely left the hobby. Well, we've been back since February of this year and I have to say, it's like night and day. Don't quit! :)
 
Sorry to hear about your span of luck.

My most recent build which was suppose to be “perfect” culminating of experience has been anything but. I will say though I’m grateful for the “ride” if you will. While I’ve had my downs for sure it’s the feeling you get when you see your tank succeed that makes it all worth it. Don’t give up!
 
I feel your pain. I was battling high nitrate last year and now phosphate. Most stuffs are doing ok, but coral just slowly died one after another. (Lost a squareback anthias as well R.I.P).

Now setting up a second tank I picked up from a member here. Scratching my head is that I don’t know what’s the right direction to cure the old live rocks I collected over the years. It’s leaching phosphate.

Glad that the lock down spare me sometimes to take care of them. At the end, this hobby is pretty fun so stick with it!
 
Sorry to hear about your frustration. If it's not too late maybe you can save some frags. I went through something similar about 8 years ago with a 120g tank. I got so tired of battling that dang bryopsis I bought a used 30g biocube off craigslist for like $150. Transferred over as big a frag of everything I could. No rocks. Then I basically reset the main tank over the course of a month. Scrubbed every single rock, gave the rocks with bryopsis a peroxide bath, drained and cleaned the sand. Gave away most of the fish. Have not had that issue since. Sold that biocube a few months later for $200 :)
 
Thanks everyone for your responses. I think I just need to get back to the basics and just let the tank settle for a little while, before making any changes. I might do a water change and see how things react by tomorrow.
Hey if you start selling I’ll start buying but good luck
 
Do not give up ,Nick. You can do it.
If you need my help, you know how to find me.
 
Hey if you start selling I’ll start buying but good luck
For some reason this post strikes me as callous and totally inappropriate to the conversation. This would have been a better private message, but the vibe it gives off is "I'm ready for you to fail because I want to buy your equipment when you're at a low point in the hobby".
 
Before I can tell you guys the immeasurable level of frustration I am feeling right now. Here is a little background.

Chapter 1: I used to consider myself to be pretty good at keeping corals. I use to have a tank stacked full of SPS which I grew from frags. Anything I put into my tank would just grow. At one point I found out that my tank has flatworms, I think I've had over 100 colonies at that point. Well, that didn't stop me, my SPS still grew substantially even with the flatworms. One day however, my tank just started crashing. For the life of me I could not figure out what it was. I decided to do an ICP test and check what was going on with it. Well NOTHING was going on with it. The parameters were great and stuff was just dying. The beautiful retracted skin of the SPS was receding deep inside of the skeleton. I watched and admired on how hours and days of my life that I spend on this tank were dying before me. Eventually I though my problems were caused the lack of nitrates. Long story short, stuff died ... the end.

Chapter 2: My tank was bare for a few months, as I had no intentions of restocking it until recently. Meanwhile, Dinos hit my tank. Well I didn't freak out. I just put on a UV on my tank, started feeding a lot and dosed nitrates. Long story short, I beat Dinos. I decided to try to keep my nitrates above absolute 0 to avoid another crash. Well after the Dinos algae started growing everywhere, (honestly forgot the name of it). After looking for a solution for quite a while I finally picked up a few halloween urchins. The urchins took care of the algae in no time. Great!... well not really.

Chapter 3: Since there was no more regular algae to compete with, here comes the Bryopsis. Here's where there fun really begins. t this point I have some of my collection back. I dose NO3 to keep it slightly above 0 for my corals, but it causes the bryopsis to go crazy and grow in days, my nitrates drop to 0 again. I spent every weekend taking 99% of it out, tank looks great. I dose nitrates to get them above 0, here comes more bryopsis. A few days ago my calcium reactor pump stopped working, I didn't catch it until it was at about 6.5 (usually that is not a big deal for my corals, and I raised it a bit, polyps were still out and corals looked OK. ).
Being tired of constantly fighting Bryopsis I decided to do some research on flucanizole. I read that wonderful Flucanizole/Bryopsis post, ALL 280 pages of it. Finally after hours of reading, I decided to dose 7 pills into my tank. As I was preparing my mixture, I was thinking to myself, all of the corals are going to die, they will definitely die, I should probably just live with Bryopsis. Well I decided to dose it anyways, and yet again, all of my corals are dying. Bryopsis looks good though. I was genuinely considering tipping my tank over when I got back from work. Anyways, this post probably has no other use than for me to vent to you guys.

Thank you for reading.
I feel sorry. I think all the reefers would have gone through the same frustration as yours. We try to make ocean world in a small tank with all the gadgets and chemicals. Eventually we won't have perfect situation like nature. Buttom line is we have to move on.
 
I remember your tank and I always wondered how the heck you packed so much coral in and kept it looking nice and growing.
I know how you feel, I went through this type of thing w my large tank. Just couldnt figure out what was wrong. I ended up blaming chloramines (and buying a large chloramine block for it) but in reality I don’t really know what was the cause of periods of Stn in my previous tank .
This hobby is freaking maddening especially for sps keepers. If there is anything I can do, you know how to reach me.
 
I feel your pain I have also had two major tank crashes over the years. After each crash I left my tank on full automation for a year or two while I tried to rekindle my enthusiasm.
Don’t give up, just take a break and start back slowly and in small steps.
 
didn't realize u were you going through so much... i was wondering y you were selling your amazing tank =( sorry...
 
The element of luck required in this hobby is overlooked.
 
Nick I remember ur tank and I still have some of the frags u sold me :) i lose almost all my corals when I switched to calcium reactor.. just keep going and if u need any frag I have, I can give to you to help repopulate ur tank.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%
Back
Top