ich treatment

dave171 · Jun 9, 2015

Has anyone used this I'm going to try it for 2-3 weeks and see if it cures my ich with my tang. Some say it works other say it dosent. Assuming its based on severity of ich. Anyways all fish are eating and look healthy.

rlman41299 · Jun 9, 2015

doesn't work. tried it before. Ended up running the tank fallow for 10 weeks

dave171 · Jun 9, 2015

Hmm I believe you yet have heard multiple statements that it has worked have you used mardel parashield?

rlman41299 · Jun 9, 2015

You asked if anyone has used them before and I have used it for 6 weeks and did not do anything.
Have you heard multiple statements that only copper, hyposalinity and tank transfer method are the only tried and true treatment for ich?

dave171 · Jun 9, 2015

Clearly you didn't read my post. If you did you would have known I was just asking for other peoples experience using this. Who knows why it didn't work in your tank maybe ur water conditions + ich made it to severe for something natural to help. And yes I have heard about copper and hyposalinity but both aren't going to get rid of it in the whole tank since its a Reef DT tank. So mind as well treat natural and have it gone totally.

rlman41299 · Jun 9, 2015

I just shared my experience using the said treatment in a mixed reef system for 6 weeks. If you read my first reply I ended up running my tank fallow for 10 weeks which is the only way to rid of ich in a display system.
To sum it up I just answered your first question. Of course I have heard people say it worked in their system. It did not in mine, followed instructions.
Have you tried it? It seems like you have made up your mind that this natural treatment works so go for it. I am just sharing my experience with it.