ID please Desjardini or not?

[roberthu526]

Have had this guy for about two months now. Eating like a champ since day one. The LFS gal said it was a regular sailfin but I compared it to liveaquaria pics and felt it should be a desjardini. It was actually $30 more than other darker sailfins. Anyone wanna charm in?
Thanks in advance.

 

[Saltmix]

Desjsrdini all the way

 

[ca1ore]

When small, it can be difficult to tell the difference and I've seen many mis identified. Agree that this one looks to be a Desjardini.

 

[lion king]

I agree with Desjardini

 

[Salty1962]

Yeap, they get big quick

 

[ourcoralreef]

It very well could be a regular, desjardini even as juveniles have "dots" along the top and bottom fins the thing that's throwing me off is that it has yellow on the top thats usually on a desjarni but a regular just as well could have it take a look at the stripes on the top and bottom fin see if there is breaks in the stripes

 

[roberthu526]

Thanks to all. I will take a better photo when I get a chance. This guy is little but he sure flashes a lot and does not back off from anyone lol

 

[lion king]

Now I'm confused, how big is he. I saw one a little over 2" yesterday that looked alot like yours.

 

[ourcoralreef]

Now I'm confused, how big is he. I saw one a little over 2" yesterday that looked alot like yours.

Juvenile sailfins can be 3"

 

[roberthu526]

Now I'm confused, how big is he. I saw one a little over 2" yesterday that looked alot like yours.

It's a little shy of 3 inches