In need of serious assistance!

  • Thread starter Thread starter Zack K
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users None
I also ran that caulerpa in a refugium on two different systems for years. It was my tangs favorite meal.

My lawnmower Blenny lives for it. Every time their is even the slightest leaf he snatches it up.
 
I agree that doing the large water change should help. You'll then need to monitor your params to see if you might need to adjust your feeding or some other maintenance routine.
I will give it a shot. Will do a 50% water change Tuesday, Thursday, Saturday. I dont feed very often, 1 every other day, rarely once a day. Doesn't take much to keep my chromis and firefish happy.
 
+1 big water changes. It the tank does not respond to wc quickly you should find the source of the nitrate factory in the tank.
 
+1 big water changes. It the tank does not respond to wc quickly you should find the source of the nitrate factory in the tank.
If this doesnt work i am going to buy a big black rubbermaid tub and take all the rock and livestock out, redue my DSB and re aquascape.
 
My last tank was a caulerpa tank. It was supposed to be a reef tank, but instead it grew massive amounts of that awful algae. I would pull out a 5g bucket worth every week or two. I'd definitely be pulling that out of your refugium and looking for some real chaetomorpha.

Good luck with the water changes.
 
I have no idea why it happens though.


Typical scenario, Person puts caulerpa in the sump to lower nutrients. It grows like crazy increasing is size many times. Between the caulerpa drawing out nutrients and other measures the nutrient level drops to a point where it cannot support the large mass of caulerpa that has not been pruned. The stress on the algae causes it to spread its spores before it dies. This is what they call going sexual. Keeping the mass small prevents this.
 
Typical scenario, Person puts caulerpa in the sump to lower nutrients. It grows like crazy increasing is size many times. Between the caulerpa drawing out nutrients and other measures the nutrient level drops to a point where it cannot support the large mass of caulerpa that has not been pruned. The stress on the algae causes it to spread its spores before it dies. This is what they call going sexual. Keeping the mass small prevents this.

Mine isn't growing...yet... will keep it pruned [emoji23][emoji1360]
 
How deep is that sand bed? My guess is you created a mess when you moved the tank (assuming you moved it). Are you vacuuming the sand when you're doing your water changes or just the water change itself? Considering you have a FOWLR, I would absolutely do the larger water changes. If you had coral, different story, but just my two cents. I would also take a turkey baster to the rock work and get the water as dirty as possible before doing your water changes. The nutrients are coming from somewhere regardless if you're truly feeding light.

Get some chaeto!
 
How deep is that sand bed? My guess is you created a mess when you moved the tank (assuming you moved it). Are you vacuuming the sand when you're doing your water changes or just the water change itself? Considering you have a FOWLR, I would absolutely do the larger water changes. If you had coral, different story, but just my two cents. I would also take a turkey baster to the rock work and get the water as dirty as possible before doing your water changes. The nutrients are coming from somewhere regardless if you're truly feeding light.

Get some chaeto!
Sand bed is anywhere from 1-4inces because of the flow and sandsifter over time. Yes it was moved and ran and a predetor tank for 3 years before me. A CUC was impossible due to the fact of a pink tailed trigger. I do have coral, I have some GSP, Colt coral, and a heliofungia.
 
UPDATE...
The Nitrates are at 40ppm due to the water changes and the calurpa is growing tremendously! I appreciate all the help. Now I have to deal with the next problem that looks to be bryopsis[emoji19]
IMG_5447.JPG
IMG_5448.JPG
 
The nitrate will rebound soon because the physical stores of protein (sandbed and bioload waste vs export) haven't changed by system design.

Google this article to see

Nitrate in the reef tank, Randy Holmes Farley

The amount of plant binding shown isn't enough to prevent the rebound imo something will have to change with the sandbed, waste storage or production in the tank

The sandbed is your greatest source of nitrate leak, it should be removed or cleaned fully if you want truly manageable nitrates in a setup like that

Let's see full tank frontal shot showing sandbed cross section and fish details

It's also ok to simply have higher nitrates and select corals that deal ok with that design outcome. Carbon dosing works well as nitrate offsets as well


I too do wc to export nitrate and wastes weekly in my little pico tank as the sandbed builds up over time...since I don't want to do full sandbed cleanings every Friday. For the times I do take apart the system and clean the sand, it can go months and months before the heavy wc work is required again, solely because a full sandbed cleaning removes all the source of the nitrate in a coral only tank. Your challenge is fish + fish feed and waste + sandbed + partial disturbance of the waste when it was fish only.

The article from RHF positions water changes alone as a very busy method of dealing with nitrate vs removing the sinked source of proteins as I read it.
 
Last edited:
9dc9c70535b345af7744e301ba3b7634.jpg
79a04d563ba23729eb6d831819e8e0f7.jpg


So it has been 1 month since I have dont the three 50% water changes and, well, the nitrates are back at 160ppm. I do my weeks 15% water changes but it doesn't seem to help. My Fuge algae has grown ALOT these past few weeks and it is starting to look good! We will see. Only time will tell.
 
**UPDATE** Just finished tearing down the tank and vacuuming the sandbed fully 4 times. While doing all of this I have been fighting Velvet and lost some fish. Sad times. But I reaquascaped last night and put the tank back together! Now time to test. Coral looks HAPPY!

Before

13e73535ed90fc2b50b5ebcfec96ea3a.jpg


After

fb95e9eb50897ac821f4637f057f2915.jpg
 
Hey that is good work

It's tricky to skip cycle clean a tank that big well done, strong coralline potential is evident

Were you able to use any peroxide after or during the cleanup for algae on the rocks (growback work anticipation/planning)

These tank cleanups are a series of steps not just the big clean

What we do as follow up maintenance in as soon as a couple weeks is just as impactful as the big clean run

Algaecide use impacts the growback time frames... cheats used during the cleaning get us longer times until growback, giving more of a window to find the right params to stop the algae from coming back

That's a nice clean up will have to link this

If that tank was mine, the number one most important next step isn't the param tuning/low nutrient chasing it would the the expectation to pull and clean the rocks in a few weeks as growback intercept. It's a fine time to consider cheat actions at that time which will reduce or stop the next growback cleaning depending on conditions
 
Hey that is good work

It's tricky to skip cycle clean a tank that big well done, strong coralline potential is evident

Were you able to use any peroxide after or during the cleanup for algae on the rocks (growback work anticipation/planning)

These tank cleanups are a series of steps not just the big clean

What we do as follow up maintenance in as soon as a couple weeks is just as impactful as the big clean run

Algaecide use impacts the growback time frames... cheats used during the cleaning get us longer times until growback, giving more of a window to find the right params to stop the algae from coming back

That's a nice clean up will have to link this

If that tank was mine, the number one most important next step isn't the param tuning/low nutrient chasing it would the the expectation to pull and clean the rocks in a few weeks as growback intercept. It's a fine time to consider cheat actions at that time which will reduce or stop the next growback cleaning depending on conditions

I do appreciate the response. I actually didn't clean or scrub any rocks! I used all of the rocks that were the supporting structor first which had minimal to no algae on them. Now that I have a "clean slate" I can keep my nutrients under control. I am also running a shorter light schedule than was run before me. I am grabbing some phosphate RX today to bring down the phosphates when they get too high and hope my Fuge controls the nitrates. If I see algae starting to come back strong I will put in a bigger CUC. The way I look at it is everything can be fixed by nature. I ran a very successful 29 gallon before I acquired this one. It was run with a canister filter and was algae free.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 30 44.8%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 13.4%
  • No.

    Votes: 25 37.3%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.5%
Back
Top