But even the form isn't the same. I guess if you are looking at it as it relates to passive cooling maybe but that is a stretch even. Phillips went the route of incorporating power supply and thermal in a single unit. ATI went the route of power conservation and number of LED's per panel and external power source which allowed a thinner panel.
The weight part threw me because it really isn't applicable. Hobbyist who use them will factor that in. 15 lbs isn't that big of a deal but duly noted.
Bars are all the rage it seems as GHL announced their Mitra Lightbar 3.
You bring up a few areas which really perturb me in "innovation". These companies are not developing anything new and considered forward progression. They're simply using some existing products to rearrange and resell as NEW, GROUND BREAKING, etc. It's absolutely an insult to the reefing world.
Let me see, GHL. I had their first fixture and it was just the same as their current fixtures, more or less. Now, the "brand new" light bar! They somply took the pucks of the LX series and put them in a straight line. I guess some things are measured on a different progression level....
Red Sea 90s and 160s - a direct knockoff of Kessil. Nothing more to say.
Orphek - The only fixture I think I've never used and owned. They actually did make progress as far as spectrum, lenses, etc. Now, in the last couple of years, they're doing the same thing.
OR3 bars stacked with a controller - light bars - nothing new, nothing different, but can't argue they provide coverage.
I do really like their Icon series. I wish they would have left the deeper 390 to 365 spectrums like they had in previous versions.
I could go down the list and I'm not picking on any one vendor. Instead of repurposing existing, stale technology, innovate and let's make it easier for hobbies to get lighting right.
I don't know, companies are getting very lazy and producing subpar equipment and jacking up the prices. I guess the best example is the AI Blades..... Give me a break. Those are the cheapest pieces of junk in 2024. Those are literally a few LEDs mounted on some cheap plastic. It's just insanity.
I mean look up the guy that has the huge tank, I forget his name. Toolio hangs out there a lot. I the last 2 or 3 years, the ones I can remember off hand, they've used Ecotech Radions, they did a video on how Metal Halide was so much better than LED and he switched a lot of that 30k gallon tank to MH. Then, I see a video on switching to Orpheks...... It's all a marketing scheme. "You too can have this beautiful ocean in your home if you buy product A, B, and C!"
Ok, I'll get off my soap box, I can remember when reefing was about people helping each other and the welfare of the animals we keep.