Is it wise to QT fish from LA and DD together?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Tanggy
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users None

Tanggy

Active Member
View Badges
Joined
Nov 14, 2017
Messages
440
Reaction score
306
What state or country do you live in
California
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
I just got a pintail wrasse from DD yesterday. I just ordered a flame wrasse from LA (been waiting for a while for this one). They will be in the same QT. Fish from DD is "conditioned and treated". While fish from LA comes from a wholesaler (assuming not conditioned and treated). I am scared the flame wrasse from LA may be carrying disease while the pintail from DD might be "clean". I will be treating them prophylactically with prazipro and copper power. Does it matter to place them in QT together??? thanks
 
If you have 2 tanks you may want to separate and observe for a week before treating.

If you’re going to treat right away, then it shouldn’t matter as long as you complete the the full treatment protocol and maintain therapeutic levels of copper throughout.
 
As soon as they are eating well and acclimated I'll start treatment. Might take a few days to a wk...
 
I keep everything in a QT for ~40 days, learned that the hard way but I don’t always treat. Copper is pretty harsh on fish and if you’re lucky and get healthy fish then no need to treat prophylactically. Most symptoms will manifest within a week or two. Just another option to consider. Best of luck!
 
In my opinion, placing the LA fish in with the DD fish is undoing all the good and extra time DD puts in to their fish (and the reason you pay more for it). That's not to say the DD fish should not be QT'd, that's just saying there is a higher percentage the DD fish is already disease/parasite free and is going to make it, whereas the LL one you have no clue. If you have the ability to keep in separate QT's I would.
 
In my opinion, placing the LA fish in with the DD fish is undoing all the good and extra time DD puts in to their fish (and the reason you pay more for it). That's not to say the DD fish should not be QT'd, that's just saying there is a higher percentage the DD fish is already disease/parasite free and is going to make it, whereas the LL one you have no clue. If you have the ability to keep in separate QT's I would.
Yeah...that's why I am hesitant about adding the LA fish to the QT. I'll probably cancel my LA order...
 
I think the biggest issue is the difference in salinity of shipping water from those facilities. I prefer to match my qt to shipping salinity to minimize acclimatization stress, so I would keep them separate until salinity was equalized.

Regarding disease, I would not consider skipping a full qt protocol with any fish including those from dd so in that sense quarantining them together would be perfectly acceptable to me.
 
Just to be clear for the OP, I'm not in any way suggesting to skip QT on Diver's Den fish. You should put all fish through your own QT process regardless of where they came from. My point is the DD fish go through a QT over a month long, where they are observed, evaluated, provided antibiotics, ensure they eat, and that they are acclimated to the aquarium environment. It doesn't give you a bullet proof guarantee by any means, but it definately allows them to cull out those that won't make it and leaves you with a fish that has a great shot at being healthy and getting through your own QT when they arrive.

In comparison, the LA fish more or less get shipped in and then shipped out and have a higher chance of carrying parasites and infections. Once you put the DD fish in with those, it's as if they never went through the DD quarantine procedure. It's like putting a healthy person in a room full of people with the flu. :D
 
I think the biggest issue is the difference in salinity of shipping water from those facilities. I prefer to match my qt to shipping salinity to minimize acclimatization stress, so I would keep them separate until salinity was equalized.

Lots of good reasons to NOT put them in QT together ..... this is at the head of the list! DD comes in at 1.025; LA typically at 1.018. Why undo the former or rush the latter.
 
Lots of good reasons to NOT put them in QT together ..... this is at the head of the list! DD comes in at 1.025; LA typically at 1.018. Why undo the former or rush the latter.
Actually I recieved a pintail yesterday from DD and salinity was 1.021. I received another fish today from DD and salinity is 1.021 also.
 
Just to be clear for the OP, I'm not in any way suggesting to skip QT on Diver's Den fish. You should put all fish through your own QT process regardless of where they came from. My point is the DD fish go through a QT over a month long, where they are observed, evaluated, provided antibiotics, ensure they eat, and that they are acclimated to the aquarium environment. It doesn't give you a bullet proof guarantee by any means, but it definately allows them to cull out those that won't make it and leaves you with a fish that has a great shot at being healthy and getting through your own QT when they arrive.

In comparison, the LA fish more or less get shipped in and then shipped out and have a higher chance of carrying parasites and infections. Once you put the DD fish in with those, it's as if they never went through the DD quarantine procedure. It's like putting a healthy person in a room full of people with the flu. :D
That's my dilemma right now. LA fish might put the DD fish at risk to diseases. I will still medicate and treat DD fish prophylactically.
 
I have received fish at the same time from both sources and QT together without problems. I start medication immediately.
 
Actually I recieved a pintail yesterday from DD and salinity was 1.021. I received another fish today from DD and salinity is 1.021 also.

I'd check your refractometer. Not saying it's impossible, but of the many dozens of DD fish I have bought they have all been right at 1.025, including a trio of zosters last week.
 
In comparison, the LA fish more or less get shipped in and then shipped out and have a higher chance of carrying parasites and infections. :D

LA is just the 'order taker', they never actually possess the fish. The orders are fulfilled directly from the wholesaler, Quality Marine.
 
I have received fish at the same time from both sources and QT together without problems. I start medication immediately.

That you haven't had problems .... yet ..... doesn't make it a sensible thing to do. I would not do it.
 
I'd check your refractometer. Not saying it's impossible, but of the many dozens of DD fish I have bought they have all been right at 1.025, including a trio of zosters last week.
Thanks. I'll check my refractometer again.
 
Thanks for your help all of you. I've decided to forgo the flame wrasse from LA. I've got a lineatus and pintail in the QT and I don't want to risk them getting any disease...
 
That you haven't had problems .... yet ..... doesn't make it a sensible thing to do. I would not do it.

I follow Humblefish's protocol and begin immediately with 4 weeks of CP followed by 2 treatments of Prazi. Fish from both sources usually arrive on the same day the way I order them. Separately they are drip acclimated to the QT system salinity of around 1.020. Going from higher salinity to lower is easier on the fish than the other way around. QT tank water and water used for water changes is dosed at 50mg CP per gallon of water. Within the 14 day guarantee from LA/DD, I have lost 2 fish in the past year in QT. Most of the time I have several fish starting QT at the same time and have never had other fish impacted by the loss of one so disease is not spreading in my QT system from the fish that died to the others. I believe CP from day one is the key to my experienced success. What amazes me most about the fish from DD and LA is that after day 1 acclimation, the fish usually start eating immediately. That says a lot about how well the fish are shipped. They come out of the bags hungry like little pigs!

In my 30 gallon long tank QT, I siphon debris from the bottom of the tank once or twice a week through a 7" filter sock sitting on top of a 6" PVC T fitting in a 5 gallon bucket and pour the tank water back into the tank. I do about a 1 gallon water change daily. Of course the new water has the same 50mg CP per gallon dose.

When QT is done, instead of adding newly prepared water to the tank, I use water from my main tank over a week to acclimate the fish to the higher salinity and chemistry of where they will end up.

All of this QT started for me after not QT a fish which ended up wiping out most of my fish last year.
 
I commend you for doing a thoughtful QT. Nothing quite like losing all fish to change mindsets. CP is a vastly superior treatment for most fish (be careful with wrasses) than copper, and will treat a broader range of parasites. The trouble is with the sources, some dodgier than others. I've been using it for the last five years with very good success.

I suppose if one only has a single QT tank and have fish arriving at the same time from disparate sources, then QT'ing them together is better than not; however, I would always prefer doing them separately - but I have 5 QT tanks that I can press into service as required. Right now, they're all occupied :D
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 30 44.8%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 13.4%
  • No.

    Votes: 25 37.3%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.5%
Back
Top