Is my coralfrag is dead or alive

Yess I did everthing is normal but it looks more alive I think the light was deteriorating it

If you want help please give following answers. We are trying to help but you give us very vague answers.

  • What day did you move the tank?
  • What day did you start adding corals?
  • What kind of light do you have?
  • What are you using for flow?
  • What are you parameters? All you say is they are good. Please let us know. If you have not tested please be honest and say so.
  • Do you have any other livestock in your tank?
You tank is probably not ready for corals and is cycling due to being moved.
 
If you want help please give following answers. We are trying to help but you give us very vague answers.

  • What day did you move the tank?
  • What day did you start adding corals?
  • What kind of light do you have?
  • What are you using for flow?
  • What are you parameters? All you say is they are good. Please let us know. If you have not tested please be honest and say so.
  • Do you have any other livestock in your tank?
You tank is probably not ready for corals and is cycling due to being moved.

Nitrates between 40 - 80
Amonia 0
Ph 8.4
Kh 214
Phosphate. 025
Calcium 560

Everything is normal I see it doing better on mid light I had it for 3 weeks to close to the light and I answer how I can am new to this and is the way I can give u answers thanks for trying to help
 
This is my tank only have 2 corals a blasto wich is doing great and the gonipora and those red trees

20190213_135805.jpg
 
Nitrates between 40 - 80
Amonia 0
Ph 8.4
Kh 214
Phosphate. 025
Calcium 560


Thanks

Yor nitrate are through the roof. They should be less than 5 or close to it to be close to normal.

Ph is ok

your KH but it should be between 7-12 DKH 125-200ppm to be considered normal.

Phosphate is ok

Calcium is very high. Should be around 480 to be normal.

Chances are, your magnesium is off also
 
We want to know what they are specifically not just good which is different in everyone’s opinion
 
What kind of salt do you use to make your water? Do you know what your salinity is?


This is my tank only have 2 corals a blasto wich is doing great and the gonipora and those red trees

20190213_135805.jpg

Nice tank rock scape.
Can you post a photo of the blasto and goni?

Chances are your lights are insufficient.
How old are the bulbs on the t5 fixture?
If they are as old as the tank, approx 4 years. They need to be replaced. 4 bulbs would be a lot better than 2.
 
What kind of salt do you use to make your water? Do you know what your salinity is?
The salinity is in between 1022 -1023 not sure how old the bulbs are





Nice tank rock scape.
Can you post a photo of the blasto and goni?

Chances are your lights are insufficient.
How old are the bulbs on the t5 fixture?
If they are as old as the tank, approx 4 years. They need to be replaced. 4 bulbs would be a lot better than 2.

15500874927156894151355657308846.jpg
 
Gonipora she was really close to the light wich cause her damage but lower it and now I see the tentacles and she is moving I know is not the nicest frag but I will bring it back

15500876892185010913680918470999.jpg
 
Thanks

Yor nitrate are through the roof. They should be less than 5 or close to it to be close to normal.

Ph is ok

your KH but it should be between 7-12 DKH 125-200ppm to be considered normal.

Phosphate is ok

Calcium is very high. Should be around 480 to be normal.

Chances are, your magnesium is off also
welllllll 40ppm nitrate is fine. so i disagree with you on that.
agree'd on everything else.
 
I haven't check magnesium and my tank on 40 nitrate seem to be stable

Exactly. My tank is comfy on 20-40ppm. Lps and softies are loving it. Spreading like crazy. Plus macro algae is blooming. Just gave some to my LFS to sell.
 
Hey guys wanted to let u know that my frag is very much alive the ganipora flower open up and they staring to grow up it was the ligh I had it up close to the light and it was to much it got really stressed I lower it to mid bottom where the light hit but not much was kind of shadowy si ir u but a ganipora frag a lil below halfway
 
welllllll 40ppm nitrate is fine. so i disagree with you on that.
agree'd on everything else.

To disagree or not they are on the higher side and depending on what test kit is being used the actual number could be even higher 5-10 is a norm for most people. If you ask 100 different people, you'll probably get 100 different answers. So basically saying they are through the roof was my opinion and not a fact. Although, saying they are on the high end of the scale is a fact

Hey guys wanted to let u know that my frag is very much alive the ganipora flower open up and they staring to grow up it was the ligh I had it up close to the light and it was to much it got really stressed I lower it to mid bottom where the light hit but not much was kind of shadowy si ir u but a ganipora frag a lil below halfway

Glad to hear it is doing better. Please post a photo for us to see. We like to see photos of recovered livestock.

Get rid of that rust infested hose clamp for starters

Good catch and I agree.

Majano wand works perfectly for killing those pest.

Only thing when using these, if you dont get every piece they will come back with a vengeance. The majano wands and aptasia x are the most common removal techniques.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%
Back
Top