Is my Hammer dying?

  • Thread starter Thread starter mdreid
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users None

mdreid

New Member
View Badges
Joined
Nov 12, 2018
Messages
4
Reaction score
1
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
bought this hammer back in august and it looked normal at my LFS but its always looked like this in my tank, none of the tentacles are uniform. some are really swollen and extended while otheres look almost like a torch. this is in a LED biocube about halfway up and i finally just cut the extra powerhead (koralia nano 565) off last night so just the mj1200 return pump is running, this thing seems like it can barely take any flow. i have the red sea test kit and will be testing for calc and alk when i get home from work.


IMG-0278.JPG
IMG-0278.JPG
IMG-0277.JPG
 
it's not dying, but it does look like something is possibly irritating it to make the polyps shrink. It could be a few things. My one hammer shrunk when i moved it to higher flow, but it puffed up again. My other hammer shrinks it's polyps if my clowns bother them too much, or chew on it. My anemone also decided to move right next too it and some days the hammer has some shrinkage and some days the anemone does. I already moved it over one and the anemone moved with it.
 
Also test for mg as euphyllia do not do well in high mg. 1500 is detrimental to them 1400 is ok 1350 is my sweet spot in my tank. They do like flow but not direct flow and medium light. It might be just the picture but you may have them under to much light. Mine are under about 100 to 150 par with medium indirect flow. They also like your water to be on the more dirty side nutrient wise. Also in the picture I see a Fire Shrimp they will pick at them to clean them which could make them made but if you have any peppermint shrimp they are know to eat euphyllia's.
 
just finished testing,

this is 24 hours after a 5 gallon water change using the regular Red Sea Salt, it had been roughly 10 days since the last water change

Ca- 420
Alk- 7.3
Mg- 1540
 
Your mg is way way to high for euphyllia! 1500 will melt them. Are you sure on your mg test? Are you dosing mg?
 
just retested and i got the same result, and no im not dosing mg, i only can dose calcium and alk via red sea method manually.
 
Have you ever tested a fresh batch of your salt mix? Reg Red Sea should be way way lower then that. #reefsquad how would you suggest getting his mg down?
Do you have any other salt and a separate tank you could move it to temporarily?
 
I thought mg over 1500 was detrimental to euphyllia? I'm glad I'm wrong!!!!
 
Hey bud. Welcome to Reef2Reef!

Do you feed that frag? My LPS always perk up after a meal. Reefroids, shrimp, etc will help that frag settle in.
Glad you found this place. :)
 
I don't thing your wrong per say, every tank is different. Maybe running higher alkalinity gave me a different reaction with the euphyllia. So many variables, lol.
Absolutely true. I run my mg at 1350 - 1390 and Alk at 11 and mine are happy happy! Different strokes for different tanks lol Life would be to easy if there was a perfect set of parameters. Could you imagine you we all could dial our tanks into 1 set of perfect parameters and grow anything with zero worries or hands on work! Lol The dream is real lol
 
Absolutely true. I run my mg at 1350 - 1390 and Alk at 11 and mine are happy happy! Different strokes for different tanks lol Life would be to easy if there was a perfect set of parameters. Could you imagine you we all could dial our tanks into 1 set of perfect parameters and grow anything with zero worries or hands on work! Lol The dream is real lol
Mine runs MG between 1500-1550 and Alk of 7.3 The Euphyllia absolutely Love it. I have not found Euphyllia to be very picky at all when parameters are within reason. I use Salifert tests for MG, CA and ALK.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%
Back
Top