Is NOPOX supposed to smell?

AydenLincoln

Pufferfish lover!
View Badges
Joined
Mar 27, 2022
Messages
5,457
Reaction score
7,968
Location
Easton
What state or country do you live in
Pennsylvania
Rating - 100%
1   0   0
Has anyone used it before? Why does it smell like acetone it smells so bad I just googled it…it seems like the normal smell but now I feel like it’s toxic chemicals. I’m not going to kill anything by dosing it right it’s not chemicals right? It had good reviews but what’s in it?
 
Yes, that smell is normal. Go sloooow with it; I start with 25% of the recommended dose and adjust weekly based on my nitrate readings.
 
Simple answer yes it smells and it’s supposed to as it’s a mixture of vinegar and ethanol
Have you used it? I feel like I dumped straight acetone into my tank.
 
Yes, that smell is normal. Go sloooow with it; I start with 25% of the recommended dose and adjust weekly based on my nitrate readings.
I did 2 ML twice in a 20 gallon as recommend by the fish store. My nitrates are high though. I hope it’s not too much maybe I’ll cut back to 1 ML. I do have skimmer too I waited to dose before getting it.
 
I did 2 ML twice in a 20 gallon as recommend by the fish store. My nitrates are high though. I hope it’s not too much maybe I’ll cut back to 1 ML. I do have skimmer too I waited to dose before getting it.
Honestly, disregard how high the nitrates are; high doses of nopox will bring them down too quickly, and can cause bacterial bloom issues. Start as low as you can go, and ramp up over the course of many weeks.
 
I did 2 ML twice in a 20 gallon as recommend by the fish store. My nitrates are high though. I hope it’s not too much maybe I’ll cut back to 1 ML. I do have skimmer too I waited to dose before getting it.
You need to slowly increase the dose over several weeks. Personally, and especially with a smaller tank, I would recommend dosing kalkwasser saturated vinegar, as it’s easier to titrated the dosing (not such small amounts) and because it won’t affect the PH (because of the kalk). If you want specific instructions (that I got from @RandyHolmesFarley), feel free to ask. But if you stick with the nopox, I would follow the dosing chart for Vodka (as they are roughly the same potency):

EA3F0914-AA53-49BB-89AE-751229AA7DA8.jpeg

Dosing 2ml right off the bat is a lot for a small tank, you want to start much smaller (can create a bacteria bloom). If you decide to go with Vinegar, you will dose 8x what this chart calls for. You need to dose it daily for it to work though, it’s not something you dose periodically, and if you ever decide to stop, you need to titrate the dose back down. Also, you’ll want to run your skimmer on the wet side (it will be pulling out some of the bacteria that are holding nitrates as biomass). If you have any questions, feel free to ask.

Oh, and to answer your question, yes it smells like solvent, it’s basically vinegar and ethanol mixed, but if your titrate the dose slowly it’s completely safe.
 
You need to slowly increase the dose over several weeks. Personally, and especially with a smaller tank, I would recommend dosing kalkwasser saturated vinegar, as it’s easier to titrated the dosing (not such small amounts) and because it won’t affect the PH (because of the kalk). If you want specific instructions (that I got from @RandyHolmesFarley), feel free to ask. But if you stick with the nopox, I would follow the dosing chart for Vodka (as they are roughly the same potency):

EA3F0914-AA53-49BB-89AE-751229AA7DA8.jpeg

Dosing 2ml right off the bat is a lot for a small tank, you want to start much smaller (can create a bacteria bloom). If you decide to go with Vinegar, you will dose 8x what this chart calls for. You need to dose it daily for it to work though, it’s not something you dose periodically, and if you ever decide to stop, you need to titrate the dose back down. Also, you’ll want to run your skimmer on the wet side (it will be pulling out some of the bacteria that are holding nitrates as biomass). If you have any questions, feel free to ask.

Oh, and to answer your question, yes it smells like solvent, it’s basically vinegar and ethanol mixed, but if your titrate the dose slowly it’s completely safe.
Thank you! And I don’t plan on doing a water change because of but would this hurt or help it?
 
Has anyone used it before? Why does it smell like acetone it smells so bad I just googled it…it seems like the normal smell but now I feel like it’s toxic chemicals. I’m not going to kill anything by dosing it right it’s not chemicals right? It had good reviews but what’s in it?
Honestly everything we add to our tanks is a chemical of some sort. But what's in nopox is basically ethanol and acetic acid (vinegar). When I need too I just mix my own vinegar and vodka.
 
NOPOX should smell like ethanol/acetic acid/isopropanol and methanol. It shouldn't smell like acetone exactly.
Okay I understand it does smell like acetone to me though probably because I’m not willingly smelling methanol/ethanol and acetone is a smell I’m more familiar with as it’s nail polish remover.
 
Honestly everything we add to our tanks is a chemical of some sort. But what's in nopox is basically ethanol and acetic acid (vinegar). When I need too I just mix my own vinegar and vodka.
Also in terms of dosing. I have been dosing magnesium to get the level up and I regularly dose fish vitamins and occasionally bacteria because I know you can’t overdose it and now NOPOX but that’s it. I just try to avoid super harsh chemicals or chemicals that would make the corals unhappy.
 
You be better off using PNS probio which is a natural bacteria supplement no chemicals and it reduces nitrates by getting rid of organic waste. Makes the tank crystal clear.
 
Have you used it? I feel like I dumped straight acetone into my tank.
Acetone would have the same effect in terms of carbon dosing.

NoPox is simply a mixture of Acetic Acid (white vinegar) and Ethanol (Vodka) with a dash of Methanol added so that you're not tempted to drink it.

Many folks make their own NoPox using Vodka and Vinegar as it works out a lot cheaper.

You must run a skimmer if you wish to lower Nitrates.
 
Thank you! And I don’t plan on doing a water change because of but would this hurt or help it?
You can continue to do water changes/maintenance as usual. IME you won’t see a massive reduction in nitrates over night, it’ll be a slow gradual reduction over several weeks. When you get to where you want your nitrates to be, you’ll start lowering the dose (on the same schedule you raised it) and then as soon as you see nitrates going back up, you’ll raise the dose back up one step, and that will be your maintenance dose (assuming feeding/bioload stays the same, though you may need to adjust a little bit periodically).
 
You can continue to do water changes/maintenance as usual. IME you won’t see a massive reduction in nitrates over night, it’ll be a slow gradual reduction over several weeks. When you get to where you want your nitrates to be, you’ll start lowering the dose (on the same schedule you raised it) and then as soon as you see nitrates going back up, you’ll raise the dose back up one step, and that will be your maintenance dose (assuming feeding/bioload stays the same, though you may need to adjust a little bit periodically).
yep, thats what I did, and I've been dosing about 10ml a day for the last 5 years on my 90 gal system.

Nitrates hover between 4-10 ppm with monthly 10% water changes.
 
You can continue to do water changes/maintenance as usual. IME you won’t see a massive reduction in nitrates over night, it’ll be a slow gradual reduction over several weeks. When you get to where you want your nitrates to be, you’ll start lowering the dose (on the same schedule you raised it) and then as soon as you see nitrates going back up, you’ll raise the dose back up one step, and that will be your maintenance dose (assuming feeding/bioload stays the same, though you may need to adjust a little bit periodically).
And is it supposed to create this white fluffy stuff on the rocks? It looks like smoke almost and it won’t pickup on camera. I heard of it happening but what is it. If you know.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%
Back
Top