Is this Bryopsis ? Need ID help

Sagecritter4life

Active Member
View Badges
Joined
Jan 21, 2017
Messages
370
Reaction score
370
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
I have this algae growing on my frag of cats eyes zoa's and it has had peroxide dip at 50/50 for three minutes multiple times along with manual plucking and just comes right back!! Grrrr now on day 10 of fluconozole and no apparent results there yet
IMG_20170721_205159.jpg
either. Stiff stuff and when pluck pulls fairly hard.
 
Thanks..when peroxide dip it turns white goes away for week or so then comes back pretty quick and takes a little force/yank but feels rooted pretty good.
 
Sorry for picture quality it's in my QT and only have blue actinic in that fixture lol and my droid doesn't take best pics of things in tank sigh....
 
There are some species of ha and bry that are extremely difficult to eradicate unfortunately. Is there a way to cut the zoas off that plug and put them on another? I just wouldn't want to chance that one spreading in my tank.
 
There are some species of ha and bry that are extremely difficult to eradicate unfortunately. Is there a way to cut the zoas off that plug and put them on another? I just wouldn't want to chance that one spreading in my tank.
Havnt mastered fragging yet since pretty new and worried on palytoxin issue [emoji43] ..chuckle but yeah have had hair type and green fuzz etc in QT tank almost 6 months old and peroxide seems to work well on them but this stuff... not so much... lol it is wiry and stiff and sure looks like branching or ferning out as sprigs get bigger and have read that's kinda Bryopsis look but heck as newbie can use feedback [emoji6]
It is really hard to see in this picture. Let's see if we can get our algae expert in on this ;)

@twillaird
 
I understand :)

Might be a species of turf algae... I'm not an algae expert but so far fluconazole kills bryopsis and some GHA. Hopefully twillaird can shed some light as to what this one is and possibly know of a way to kill it.
 
It's not a bryopsis.
I'd need a bit clearer pic to to see detail. Do you have any pics of it once it's developed more? Like does it branch?


Some of these root into the surface , bryo and some turf algaes and others, so if it's an easy spot you might want to score or slightly rasp the rock. I use a utility knife. And just scratch it or twist the blade point like a drill.
 
It's not a bryopsis.
I'd need a bit clearer pic to to see detail. Do you have any pics of it once it's developed more? Like does it branch?


Some of these root into the surface , bryo and some turf algaes and others, so if it's an easy spot you might want to score or slightly rasp the rock. I use a utility knife. And just scratch it or twist the blade point like a drill.
Hey salty [emoji106] Well it's sure rooted good almost pops/snaps kinda when you pull it and my eyes are questionable nowadays for intricate work where right in tiny cracks between polyps with a razor... chuckle..but may not have any option. Stiff enough doesn't really wave or blow around in current like my other hair algae spots do.

This is as big as I've let it get since it originally showed up in QT just because using fluconozole this round to try knock it out (day 11) just in case but scratching my head...chuckle...usually tweezers or peroxide by now.

I've dipped it in 50/50 water- peroxide for three minute durations 3 times allready over past two months and it turns white recedes to base looks like gone then comes right back and possibly thicker so.......

When lights on later will try for better pic with phone again maybe [emoji6]
 
Might be Caulpera prolifera; tough stuff

fatherree051.jpg
Ten four that crossed my mind but as newbie could be alien life form and I would be clueless lol. Its really not fluffy fern like and as the stems get taller they seemed to be getting wider thought maybe trying branch but not sure of that. I don't want to pitch frag away unless absolutely had too actually zoa doing pretty well sigh....how invasive is caulerpa spreading wise?
 
Ten four that crossed my mind but as newbie could be alien life form and I would be clueless lol. Its really not fluffy fern like and as the stems get taller they seemed to be getting wider thought maybe trying branch but not sure of that. I don't want to pitch frag away unless absolutely had too actually zoa doing pretty well sigh....how invasive is caulerpa spreading wise?
I would say invasive; I keep some in a nano tank to add to the biodiversity and "trim" it with every water change. I would definitely keep it away from corals and use tweezers to pick the stuff out. Some reefers use it for nutrient export but you have to be careful if it "goes sexual" and adds nutrients back into tank.
 
I would say invasive; I keep some in a nano tank to add to the biodiversity and "trim" it with every water change. I would definitely keep it away from corals and use tweezers to pick the stuff out. Some reefers use it for nutrient export but you have to be careful if it "goes sexual" and adds nutrients back into tank.
+ 1! The only system you might want to have this stuff in is possibly a seahorse tank and that's it!
 
The first pic. I believe is bryopsis. I was able to eliminate it with a two week treatment of fluconazole. If you look closely there are a few strands mixed in with the bryopsis that almost look like a single strand of hair algae. They don't have the "fern look" of the bryopsis..... But it's not hair algae. As you said, this stuff is well rooted and tough to pull off of the rock. It looks like a scraggly beard once it takes off. (pic #2) I found several threads on forums about cladophoropsis and i believe that could be what I have. I have several thick clumps of this stuff established in my rock work. It all started with one frag and a few innocent looking strands on a frag base. I don't feel good about manual removal of algaes of this type because I've read too many times that when small fragments get loose in the water column they settle somewhere else in your rock work and start a new "patch".
In the future I'm going to be a lot more careful about the frags I select and remove and discard as many frag bases I can from new corals.

IMG_6928.JPG


IMG_9052.JPG
 
The first pic. I believe is bryopsis. I was able to eliminate it with a two week treatment of fluconazole. If you look closely there are a few strands mixed in with the bryopsis that almost look like a single strand of hair algae. They don't have the "fern look" of the bryopsis..... But it's not hair algae. As you said, this stuff is well rooted and tough to pull off of the rock. It looks like a scraggly beard once it takes off. (pic #2) I found several threads on forums about cladophoropsis and i believe that could be what I have. I have several thick clumps of this stuff established in my rock work. It all started with one frag and a few innocent looking strands on a frag base. I don't feel good about manual removal of algaes of this type because I've read too many times that when small fragments get loose in the water column they settle somewhere else in your rock work and start a new "patch".
In the future I'm going to be a lot more careful about the frags I select and remove and discard as many frag bases I can from new corals.

IMG_6928.JPG


IMG_9052.JPG
+1 I agree to not manually remove any algae, especially those that you don't know what they are and how they spread or don't spread, inside your system. Bryopsis spreads like wildfire as does hair algae when you pull it within the system. And I suspect many more forms of algae do as well. For the ones that are treatable with h202 I like to pull the rocks out and let them soak overnight whenever possible in a 5 gallon bucket with a bottle of h202 to four gallons of water. It may seem like Overkill but it works for hair algae. However it did not work for bryopsis or turf algae. So we know now that fluconazole Kills bryopsis very easily, h202 kills HA and hopefully someone will come up with a Turf algae solution too [emoji12]
 
If it comes back get some superglue gel, take the frag plug out, dry off the area with the algae, then apply some gel over it and put it back in the tank. It won't make it through the gel lol
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%
Back
Top