Is this the reason my GSP didn't open for months

brandon4432

Active Member
View Badges
Joined
Aug 3, 2015
Messages
300
Reaction score
98
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Several months ago I ventured out to buy the first coral for the nano reef. Tank had been up for 4 months and all levels were pristine. So naturally I bought a big piece of GSP as I've always loved it. Acclimated, and put it in the tank. Sadly I never dipped it in coral RX etc. well after two weeks of happy fully extended polyps it closed. Never to open again for two months. Today, seeing a few bits of algae I took it out and most of it disintegrated in my hand. Unfortunately, I realized my coral was most likely a goner so I tried to salvage all of the still sold polyps and I cut into it to frag out the good stuff. Upon cutting I stumped upon this guy beneath the flesh of the coral. Is this why my beloved coral didn't open in months? All other corals are open, fully extended, and thriving. Current levels ca 420 KH ~9dkh mag 1400 po4 <.04 nitrate 0 ph 8. These levels have been constant since tank cycled


Pest:
c1cf481594924e56df1d143653b66c9d.jpg


Coral after initial purchase:

07e08e39229ec3c44ce811568c4202a0.jpg


Coral before I took it out:

36a7a49f9046e166da1c4b76607a22b4.jpg
 
No. Not likely to say the least, likely you had your gsp in a spot it didn't like. Some people also just can't keep it.

What was the pest? Why did the coral open fully extend and thrive and then randomly close of it didn't like the spot?
 
What kinda fishes do you have? That looks like some polychaete worm, not necessarily a harmful one.
Two clowns. Even though it burrowed in the flesh of the coral? Wouldn't that bother it? Just questions here, hope I'm not coming across rude
 
Those actually keep all the little crevices and holes etc around under and through everything, clean by eating and or disturbing detritus build up. They are not coral eaters unless it is dieing and decaying in which case it will clean it up. So that's probably why it was there.
 
I'd vote a definite maybe. Its hard to id the worm with the grainy pic and it being all dead.
But the algae growth is an indicator of other problems too and gsp can be a good barometer of tank health.(trust me Ive killed a few)
bummer too. That's a nice species of gsp with the big center disk.

If you find more worms or bugs pull em out and put em in a cup so they open up.
 
Most of the time these worms don't burrow into healthy living tissue. Bristle worms get a bad rap as people usually think they kill clams and corals, but think of them like maggots that only eat rotten stuffs.
 
Those actually keep all the little crevices and holes etc around under and through everything, clean by eating and or disturbing detritus build up. They are not coral eaters unless it is dieing and decaying in which case it will clean it up. So that's probably why it was there.
we were typing at the same time. any idea what its called? never run across it.
 
Those actually keep all the little crevices and holes etc around under and through everything, clean by eating and or disturbing detritus build up. They are not coral eaters unless it is dieing and decaying in which case it will clean it up. So that's probably why it was there.

Oh really? Such a bummer to lose a coral
 
I'd vote a definite maybe. Its hard to id the worm with the grainy pic and it being all dead.
But the algae growth is an indicator of other problems too and gsp can be a good barometer of tank health.(trust me Ive killed a few)
bummer too. That's a nice species of gsp with the big center disk.

If you find more worms or bugs pull em out and put em in a cup so they open up.

Yes, I did have a algae bloom lately. That area seems to not get any work done by the snails so that area had accumulated algae over a period of time. Simply laziness or I would have picked it off. Usually when I pick the algae off it doesn't grow back. Unfortunately I killed my favorite coral. I loved that piece! Even though it's not sought in the coral world I've always absolutely loved GSP
 
Algae is a nutrient thing.
Thats why gsp is such a good barometer. If its doing well even with some algae your good. If gsp going bad start checking the parameters and cleaning stuff.

Dou you have bristle worms. The pic doesn't look like one.
I have a lot.
 
Algae is a nutrient thing.
Thats why gsp is such a good barometer. If its doing well even with some algae your good. If gsp going bad start checking the parameters and cleaning stuff.

Cleaning as in? Unfortunately I think I've battled phosphate for months. Algae stays at bay( usually) but I have to replace the Phosguard ever three days. I think my rocks have been leaching
 
I was assuming it's a bristle worm but hard to tell from the pic. Sorry for assuming I should know better but this is generally a once a week post if not more. Bristles don't really look like bristles when there dead and sitting on a paper towel.

Can we get some clarification, Brandon?
 
As in sand sump and filters, the usual. Uhmmm phosguard every 3 days isn right thats a LOT.
and ya gotta put phosphate in for it to leach out, unless they're used rocks.
 
Algae is a nutrient thing.
Thats why gsp is such a good barometer. If its doing well even with some algae your good. If gsp going bad start checking the parameters and cleaning stuff.

Dou you have bristle worms. The pic doesn't look like one.
I have a lot.

No, no bristle worms as far as I can tell
 
As in sand sump and filters, the usual. Uhmmm phosguard every 3 days isn right thats a LOT.
and ya gotta put phosphate in for it to leach out, unless they're used rocks.
It gets exhausted in four days, but mine generally gets exhausted every three. Turns brown and then the algae on the glass comes back. The Rock is live that I bought online and cycled with the tank while no inhabitants were inside. I feed micro pellets with Kent garlic every third day very minimal feedings to ensure they eat all of it. I don't feed my corals as of now due to the nutrient problem. I should also say I do a 20% water change every week in order to help keep nutrients down as well as manual removal of any hair algae I can find. Fortunately the algae has started to taper down
 
I was assuming it's a bristle worm but hard to tell from the pic. Sorry for assuming I should know better but this is generally a once a week post if not more. Bristles don't really look like bristles when there dead and sitting on a paper towel.

Can we get some clarification, Brandon?

Before it died, it was squiring around with little "bristles" a long the entire body covering one for every millimeter
 
Before it died, it was squiring around with little "bristles" a long the entire body covering one for every millimeter

I initially didn't think it was a bristle worm but with so many different species and variation of bristle worms I'm keeping it open as an option
 
What water are you using for top off and salt mixing. Something is dumping po in you tank
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 30 44.8%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 13.4%
  • No.

    Votes: 25 37.3%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.5%
Back
Top