Is this zoa dying?

[derekg]

3 days ago all 7 polyps were fully open, now one of them looks like this. Is it dead? The other polyps seem healthy and it was fully open like 3 days ago.
t

 

[derekg]

this was it a few days ago

 

[Dude64]

hard to say... my peppermint zoa puffs and shrivels but it's been going for a year now! salinity 1.025-1.026 if that helps

 

[Dom]

We need a bit more info:

What kind of lighting do you use?
What is the depth of the tank?
How old is the tank?
What are your most recent test results?

 

[Dude64]

hard to say... my peppermint zoa puffs and shrivels but it's been going for a year now! salinity 1.025-1.026 if that helps

I did noticed a hermit crawling over one pod and it took 2 days to recover

 

[derekg]

We need a bit more info:

What kind of lighting do you use?
What is the depth of the tank?
How old is the tank?
What are your most recent test results?

right now im using a 18w par38 full spectrum from amazon

https://www.google.com/aclk?sa=l&ai=DChcSEwjd0oqKxYL_AhXm0eMHHXJEBVUYABAIGgJ5bQ&sig=AOD64_3WEAlO9jkVWugk-YhjZF4JUNumsA&ctype=5&q=&ved=2ahUKEwjyjoKKxYL_AhVFFlkFHbp_DgsQ9aACKAB6BAgDEA4&adurl=

the tank is around 2 months old, corals been in for around a month

its a pico jar so the whole tank is only around 12 inches deep.. the zoas are probably in 6-7 inch deph

 

[derekg]

I did noticed a hermit crawling over one pod and it took 2 days to recover

i did see my snail near it, but the other polyps seem unbothered

 

[Dude64]

Please post a full pic of that setup... I gotta see it!!

 

[derekg]

Please post a full pic of that setup... I gotta see it!!

 

[derekg]

hard to say... my peppermint zoa puffs and shrivels but it's been going for a year now! salinity 1.025-1.026 if that helps

i've never kept zoa puffs or heard of them. Are those shriveled up? They look more opened than mine is right now at least

 

[derekg]

could this be why they're unhappy? I assume these r copepods but idk if they eat coral. But they keep making the healthy polyps close. There's also some black / grey ones that are bigger. Could they have eaten the entire other polyp?