It’s been a year, please help ID

Christopher Presley

Active Member
View Badges
Joined
Aug 24, 2017
Messages
113
Reaction score
39
What state or country do you live in
Ohio
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
I’ve thrown the kitchen sink at it. Need a positive I.D please

5771DF17-C7D5-4D39-B881-C9DE2555C3A8.jpeg 1B64EA1C-2AB1-425D-A3F4-A80D92EC93DE.jpeg 4AD1C88B-884A-4598-9BFD-1A4216DF87EC.jpeg
 
Looks like GHA. green hair algae.
If you do a search on the forum you'll find all kinds of ways to get rid of it.
I forsure had GHA in the past but my tangs devoured the stuff and they won’t touch this. Is it possible it’s something else?
 
Nutrients are low, any lower would be undetectable. Hydra 26 hd’s running slightly modified saxby.
 
Nutrients can be deceiving when you have that much algae. As the algae basically works as a giant turf scrubber or refugium consuming them quickly. To have that much algae you have excess nutrient, it's just that the algae is consuming it.

Best method to get rid of it is manual removal (frequently), and working on keeping your water quality good and low nutrients. To starve out the algae.
 
I forsure had GHA in the past but my tangs devoured the stuff and they won’t touch this. Is it possible it’s something else?
It's possible but that's what it looks like to me. It's interesting that your tangs ate it before, mine never touched it when I had it.
 
Nutrients can be deceiving when you have that much algae. As the algae basically works as a giant turf scrubber or refugium consuming them quickly. To have that much algae you have excess nutrient, it's just that the algae is consuming it.

Best method to get rid of it is manual removal (frequently), and working on keeping your water quality good and low nutrients. To starve out the algae.
+1 this.

Also is your tang well fed by you that it isn't going after algae?
 
+1 this.

Also is your tang well fed by you that it isn't going after algae?
I’ve wondered this too and have drastically cut feedings to no luck. When I had what was an obvious gha outbreak (more hairy and longer) all the tangs and the foxface would constantly graze. For the longest time my tank looked great and then this slowly started taking over.
 
I’m off work the next few weeks and am really going to hammer this tank and see what I can do.
 
It looks more like a turf algae which wraps itself around prices of rock. It’s harder to remove than regular GHA. I agree that you have more nutrients in your water than the test show.

What are your maintenance habits? What do you use for nutrient export?
 
It looks more like a turf algae which wraps itself around prices of rock. It’s harder to remove than regular GHA. I agree that you have more nutrients in your water than the test show.

What are your maintenance habits? What do you use for nutrient export?
Maintenance is pretty good, only thing other than a skimmer and water changes is a algae reactor that I can’t grow chaeto in.
 
Maybe lower the amount of food being fed, and the manual removal will help you get ahead. Once that happens hopefully your cheato takes off and out competes the nasty stuff.
 
The thing to remember about measuring nutrients is that you can only measure what is free floating in the water. Where as when you have a bunch of Algae, all of your excess nutrients are locked up in the algae where your test kit can not measure it.
 
I’ve had good luck with scrubbing the rock in a bucket of tank water and squirting it with peroxide. Try that on the small chunk of rock in your pictures to see if that helps. Are you able to remove the rest of the rocks?
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%
Back
Top