LED advice, opinions: 450nm 440nm

Pete polyp

acro serial killer
View Badges
Joined
Oct 16, 2012
Messages
5,828
Reaction score
1,895
Location
Arkansas
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
So I have noticed that most LED fixtures use a standard 450nm. Photosynthesis absorption is most efficient at 438nm. So would using a 440nm led be more absorbing compared to 450nm? The reason I been able to find much information backing this up though.ask is because theoretically it works. I have not
 
So I have noticed that most LED fixtures use a standard 450nm. Photosynthesis absorption is most efficient at 438nm. So would using a 440nm led be more absorbing compared to 450nm? The reason I been able to find much information backing this up though.ask is because theoretically it works. I have not

420-440nm is great for photosynthesis in Chlorophyll A along with 660nm Red.

LEDs however are industrial and reefers have capitalized on this...Seize The Moment...

450nm or Royal Blue has numerous industrial applications including exciting a phosphor coated cover to produce a white light. This specific application totally rocks as a single Royal Blue LED can replace a Light Bulb....This said there are some hurdles like oxidation and price but that will be solved in a few years as long as hurdles to innovation are removed. Other applications pop up every day and its great to see an industrial LED grow coral.

Back in the day street light and bud light MHs were used to grow coral until Ushio stepped up to the plate. The main reason they grew coral was their 450nm spike.

450nm or Bin 36/37 or 316 is great for coral growth. This is the sweet spot for Chlorophyll A & B. I've seen awesome growth with 450nm dominant lights as well as 460-465nm dominant. The difference is looks the 450nm gives a much better colour pop in the corals.

The 450nm is really not standard. Cree Royal Blue are 450-465nm. The 1 and 2 watt chinese LEDs offer a tighter spectrum but in my book they don't count based on their efficiency.

Binned Cree LEDs offer the best looks and growth.

This chart has been around more than Paris Hilton but is still useful.

6a010535f11c3d970c0153913a22d7970b-800wi.jpg



Bill
 
Last edited:
But, would 440nm led be more beneficial than a 450nm since coral maximum absorption is at 438mm?
 
But, would 440nm led be more beneficial than a 450nm since coral maximum absorption is at 438mm?

Chlorophylle A will respond better to 430-440nm, Chlorophylle B will respond better to 455-465nm

450nm is the sweet spot were they cross

Having two spectrum specific LEDs would work well, but there is not a quality 438nm LED available. That is one that puts out the same amount of PAR as the latest generation of Cree XT-E do.

The Zooxanthellae Algae in the coral are very adaptable. The same coral can be found in a wide range and depths were the warmer spectrums of light are blocked very quick.

I've personally seen great growth in my personal tanks using primarily 450nm Royal Blue and Cree Cool White.

Bill
 
Last edited:
Zooxanthellae primarily has chlorophyll a correct? Chlorophyll a has its peak a 438nm, and chlorophyll b at 553nm. I do understand that 450nm being the middle of the road between the two. Would you happen to have a comparison between the par values of cree xt-e r5 and other diodes?
 
Zooxanthellae primarily has chlorophyll a correct? Chlorophyll a has its peak a 438nm, and chlorophyll b at 553nm. I do understand that 450nm being the middle of the road between the two. Would you happen to have a comparison between the par values of cree xt-e r5 and other diodes?

We've done numerous PAR tests of our fixtures. According to the experts the PAR readings are undervalued. Thats why we say our 45 LED Kit with optics driven at 700mA (3 40 watt drivers) has a PAR between a 250 and 400 watt MH and 30-50% more measured PAR than those 120 watt Chinese Fixtures.

When comparing PAR and LUX readings from MHs, Cree LEDS and Cheap Chinese Fixtures. One thing we noticed was the relationship between LUX and PAR from our measurements was rather Linear.

If LED A has a PAR of 5 and a LUX of 7, LED B with a PAR of 10 normally had a LUX close to 14.

I know this is an unscientific observation but given the number of different LEDs and their life cycle testing each one would be non-conducive to ones sanity, the Manufacturer Data Sheets normally list Lumens or Flux per watt. This can be a very good
indicator on which LED produces more PAR per watt.

Say for the Cree XP-G R3 vs The R5, Calculated Luminous Flux at 1000mA is 305 vs 348. If I was a betting man, I would say with certainty of a very high probability that the R5 has close to 14% more PAR than the R3. Now the design game, is 14% worth the initial higher cost based on $.26 a KWH...Normally Yes. R5 v Gen II R5 close call as the latest generation often carries a price premium when they first come out.

XP-G Data Sheet

I would caution that when using this methodology keep apples with apples. In other words ensure the measurements between companies are similar.

Hope this helps

Bill
 
Last edited:

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%
Back
Top