LED Lighting on a reef tank as the primary lighting will never work!

(2019) What type of lighting is the main source of "coral growing" light on your reef tank?

  • LED

    Votes: 579 77.6%
  • Metal Halide

    Votes: 35 4.7%
  • T5

    Votes: 104 13.9%
  • Other...

    Votes: 28 3.8%

  • Total voters
    746
I went from MH and VHO, and T5's to Radions.
I used them for 8 years.
Grew corals just fine, plus the other cost saving benefits.
But recently I got nostalgic for T5's.
Switched out both my tanks to ATI T5 fixtures, but I also added Reef Brite XHO strips.
 
Adding a few Radions soon

phone pics 795.jpg
 
I have 4 Orpheks and may be buying TWO more. Additionally 2 Orphek Bars and about to make a move on two of the new OR 150's
 
Last edited:
ATI 6x80 watts and 3 Kessil 360s on 210 gallon. I may add 2 more kessils in the future, but it’s more than adequate at the moment to grow SPS.
 
for my past 90G SPS dominant tank i used 2X Radion XR30 and 4x 54W T5 hybrid.

for the new 220 build we are doing its purely LED with 4x XR30 PROs over a 6ft tank. This tank will be mixed reef tho, not acro heavy
 
I have 3 Orphek's Atlantiks V4 compacts over a Red Sea 625XXL.
 
How does your poll account for hybrid?

I can only click other.

Hybrid LED/T5

I don't think either are primary.
 
We need more halide users!
Pheonix 14k 150w on cheap reflector and ballast.
LEDS
IMG_0007.jpg

Halides
IMG_0338.JPG

Same Camera, Same colony, The only difference is some time under the sun :)
 
I have three Radion XR15s over 36x30x16 tank, each running at 35%. I think they are decent, but I have always wanted to try hybrid and Orpheks, but what stops me is the hanging system, I like EcoTech's rail system too much, it looks classy with my open top tank. I have no canopy and can't hang lights from the ceiling.
 
Any "reef light" will "work".

I look into primary light source to achieve the growth, colors and health of the organisms I keep as I found them in nature, and there is absolutely nothing like halides, as a primary source of artificial light, to give me the results I want.
IMG_5627.JPG

I'm using a Giesemann Spectra with 2 X 250W 20K Hamilton bulbs for growth and color right now. The T5s are 2X 10Ks and 2 X Blue Plus bulbs.
But the very best growth and color I've ever had in my life was using 2 X 250W 6500K halides over a 55 gallon in the past.
I also can achieve amazing results with T5 only systems and had for decades, but the halides/T5s are much better IMO.
The only artificial light used as a primary source that I don't identify with, because of the results, are from LEDs (post # 31 is a good example to show the difference).

I think it is mostly a matter of taste in a sense of what we want, and/or what are the type of reflected light we like to see the organisms under.
That's why it is a tremendously relative subject.

There is no "BETTER light", but the "better RESULT" from that light we choose for each one of us.
Anyone can think that what I have with my halides here can be ugly to their eyes comparing to what they achieve with any LED fixture or T5 system because we think different.

Everyone has the right to use what they want over their systems.

Bottom line: results will be different with different light sources and you just have to choose the one you like the most because the tank is yours.
 
Last edited:
Those talking of wanting a hybrid option. It is more of a what is the PRIMARY solution. I’d wager most people aren’t running identical par numbers from either source. I’d take a par meter and see what is pumping out more and consider that to be the primary and anything else to be supplemental

At any rate...I run 2x250 watt MH on my 90 gallon, and will run 3x250 watt MH on my 150 gallon being built. Plenty of LED users with better looking corals and faster growth than me. But spending 2 months wages on aquarium lights just isn't something I'm interested in doing . Not interested in a showoff, as my tank is not packed, and I'm not trying to convince anyone of what to use. use whatever you want. I kind of packed in stuff too close, so I frag a lot and most my acros don't get enormous because of that. Full tank shot doesn't look like much from a distance picture.
 
Last edited:
I have two HD 26 led over the red sea 350. The corals are LPS, mushrooms, and zoas. Tank is 9 months old. All the corals are growing. I increased the lights power and started up bleach an acan. So went back to old settings and lowered acan, it recovered. Do not know par levels. But those light appear to work well at least with lps.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 30 44.8%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 13.4%
  • No.

    Votes: 25 37.3%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.5%
Back
Top