Any "reef light" will "work".
I look into primary light source to achieve the growth, colors and health of the organisms I keep as I found them in nature, and there is absolutely nothing like halides, as a primary source of artificial light, to give me the results I want.
I'm using a Giesemann Spectra with 2 X 250W 20K Hamilton bulbs for growth and color right now. The T5s are 2X 10Ks and 2 X Blue Plus bulbs.
But the very best growth and color I've ever had in my life was using 2 X 250W 6500K halides over a 55 gallon in the past.
I also can achieve amazing results with T5 only systems and had for decades, but the halides/T5s are much better IMO.
The only artificial light used as a primary source that I don't identify with, because of the results, are from LEDs (post # 31 is a good example to show the difference).
I think it is mostly a matter of taste in a sense of what we want, and/or what are the type of reflected light we like to see the organisms under.
That's why it is a tremendously relative subject.
There is no "BETTER light", but the "better RESULT" from that light we choose for each one of us.
Anyone can think that what I have with my halides here can be ugly to their eyes comparing to what they achieve with any LED fixture or T5 system because we think different.
Everyone has the right to use what they want over their systems.
Bottom line: results will be different with different light sources and you just have to choose the one you like the most because the tank is yours.